Posts: 438   +7
Staff
A hot potato: Apple's infamous "walled garden" approach is often cited as an example of limiting consumer freedom, but it seems the Android ecosystem is erecting restrictive fences as well. The most recent development in this direction is Google supercharging its Play Integrity API to give developers more power to block apps installed outside the Play Store.

For the uninitiated, sideloading means installing apps from third-party sources instead of Google's official app marketplace. There are reasons why users go this route: maybe an app isn't available on the Play Store in their country, or they want an ad-free modded version. App makers have criticized this practice since it allows piracy.

Additionally, sideloaded apps don't contribute to Play Store metrics like download counts and ratings. There are also stability concerns – improperly sideloaded apps can crash due to missing resources or device incompatibilities.

Whatever the motivations, Google has handed developers a big new stick via some Play Integrity API updates, as reported by Android Authority. The API, which checks for signs of app tampering, untrustworthy software environments, and more, now lets developers easily determine if an app was legitimately downloaded from the Play Store. If not, they can hit users with forceful "remediation" pop-ups that ask them to "get this app from Play."

One new remediation flow called "GET_LICENSED" prompts users to obtain the official Play Store version if it detects the app was sideloaded. Close the dialog and the developers get notified, following which they can block all functionality. Users must either back out entirely or initiate a process that removes the sideloaded version and any associated data and reinstalls the app from the Play Store.

It's worth mentioning that developers have previously been able to detect sideloads, but this implementation streamlines the whole process significantly.

While these countermeasures were announced at the Google I/O developer conference back in May, it looks like they're rolling out now. A few apps have already deployed them, including popular games BeyBlade X and Diablo Immortal.

For the average user, these restrictions may be no big deal; they could even be a blessing in disguise, protecting people from sketchy sideloaded apps. But for tinkerers, modders, and power users, it could be a major blow.

In other related news, Google is reportedly working on functionality that would let the Play Store update sideloaded apps – likely to eliminate any security issues associated with third-party downloads.

Image credit: Android Authority

Permalink to story:

 
Good.
 
Is anyone really surprised by Google doing this? Nope, not at all.

Remember... GOOGLE IS NOT YOUR FRIEND!
 
Revanced made Google mad.
 
I have a couple of games sideloaded--because they are no longer in Play.
They're 7-10 years old and still fun to me. Whenever I get a new device or wipe one to start fresh again, I need to sideload them again.

It will get interesting when apps that have this "Only From Play" in them are no longer available in Play... I guess they will just have to die.
 
The more Google tries to screw with sideloading, the better Apple looks. Freedom is the one major thing android has going for it.
Taking choice away form the consumer is a good thing to Apple-cels. Better not be allowed to make choices!
 
I guess before this move nothing damaged Android more (and now I wont by even pixel tablet) than Amazon Fire Tablets' lock in updates gluing bloatware n blocking even earlier working fearures like working gamepads then few weeks/months later abrupt feature/detection fails. This has annoyed so much that though Fire HD 10 was my 1st.. it will be last Google tablet not even chrome/pixel tablets.. and the step captioned in article will speed android's death.. I guess lunar lake tablets is the wisest to switch to n run anything android in emulation their.. Even MS doesn't strangle so much to stop piracy.. for flip side of more coverage, reach, poor world readiness..
 
I would miss being able to install the most recent version of an app from trusted sources on occasions I don't want to wait for it to roll it to my phone on its own.

If the block is needed to keep devices secure I can live with that if I have to.
 
Really not sure how this relates to Apple's Walled Garden at all, other than by things the T&Cs don't allow me to mention.

Allowing an apk to detect that it isn't the official licensed version from the Play Store IS NOT Google restricting access to other apps or stores in any way.
 
Really not sure how this relates to Apple's Walled Garden at all, other than by things the T&Cs don't allow me to mention.

Allowing an apk to detect that it isn't the official licensed version from the Play Store IS NOT Google restricting access to other apps or stores in any way.
It's laying the groundwork for said API to allow google to force this notice into every non store app, and eventually block said apps even if the end user agreed to installing them.

Did we learn nothing from Google's war on the SD card?
 
A reminder as always that while android and things like Chromium maybe "open-source", they are well and truly in Google's mitts, and will always have plenty of ways for Google to do its bidding in showing you as many ads as possible as that is their entire business model, absolutrly seems like like Vanced/revanced existing has irked them that they can't guarantee getting their precious ad money, and while this doesn't seem to block sideloaded installs yet, it absolutely seems to be made for that purpose (though one would hope doing that would make someone like the EU wake up and start diving in)
 
Perhaps Google is now dealing with Android's fragmentation? Manufactures are able to skin or do what they need to do for android to work with their devices when the stock android does not have it. So when Google submits updates, the manufacturer needs to include their changes in Googles update as well. If the manufactures don't keep up then it becomes a security issue. You can update from Google but something may not work because it's missing the manufactures file. At least this is what I understand.
 
Last edited:
A reminder as always that while android and things like Chromium maybe "open-source", they are well and truly in Google's mitts
Hence my statement that Google is not, never has been, and never will be your friend.
 
The internet and the tech world is becoming over restrictive and regulated. You cant use aftermarket or refill ink on your printer, cant own software or music anymore, it's all subscriptions... Games need to connect even for 1 player action, forced updates, censorship on forums and social media. On top of that, all the products and services seem to get more expensive and the quality and customer service is terrible.
 
Welcome to the brave new world.
 

Similar threads