Democracy Dies in Darkness

Opinion Emmanuel Macron has the right message but is the wrong messenger

The French leader is wisely warning about Europe’s vulnerabilities, but is anyone listening?

Columnist, European Affairs|
May 8, 2024 at 6:15 a.m. EDT
French President Emmanuel Macron and Chinese President Xi Jinping at a restaurant in the Tourmalet Pass of the Pyrenees Mountains in France on Tuesday. (Aurelien Morissard/POOL/EPA-EFE/Shutterstock)
5 min

In March, Emmanuel Macron’s official photographer posted arresting black-and-white photos of the French president pummeling a heavy bag, teeth bared, biceps swollen. The image Macron projected, of toughness and resolve, meshed with his hawkish determination to rally fractious Europeans against Russia’s blood-soaked war in Ukraine.

The photos themselves were the subject of debate — riveting to some, ridiculous to others. But there is no dismissing the gravity of the president’s analysis regarding Europe, reinforced with a forceful two-hour speech last month warning that the continent faces an existential threat arising from Moscow’s aggression, U.S. disengagement, and Europe’s own economic torpor and rising populist illiberalism.