Dear Carolyn: Through work, I was “situational friends” with “Laura.” Despite having a good life overall — devoted and financially supportive partner, well-compensated work, close family — Laura can be quite negative.
She doesn’t seem to have many close friends, so I hesitate to just stop having anything to do with her. At the same time, there’s only so much I can take. Any ideas?
— Anonymous
Skip to end of carousel(For The Washington Post)
End of carousel
I’ve written an advice column at The Post since 1997. If you want advice, you can send me your questions here (believe it or not, every submission gets read). If you don’t want to miss a column, you can sign up for my daily newsletter. I also do a live chat with readers every Friday: You can submit a question in advance or join me live. Follow me on Facebook and Instagram.
Anonymous: It is neither your job nor your responsibility to “fix” Laura, to stay in a friendship you don’t want, or to save her from her own negativity or self-absorption.
Just saying that upfront, because:
Since you’re reluctant to quit Laura completely, you might as well try to put your compassionate stamina to practical use. Stop hinting and nudging toward “genuine conversation” and instead give her clear guidance on what you’d rather discuss.
That part is your job and responsibility, after all — to manage your side of your friendships, to set your own priorities and boundaries, and to communicate clearly.
So, for example: “I don’t mean to be insensitive; I know things are tough.” They are, by the way — those woes are, whoa. “But I am struggling with negativity right now, and I would take it as a huge favor if we didn’t dwell on problems. Deal?” Present other topics to minimize awkwardness: “Tell me what shows you’re watching? Great books you’re reading?” Keep returning gently — or obviously, or goofily — to those Laura-friendly topics. You have much more leeway to do this after you’ve been clear about your intent.
Or go further and suggest walks instead of lunches, or shared activities that either drive the conversation (museums, crafts, causes) or prevent it (biking, concerts). It’s not “shut her down” so much as firm and friendly redirection.
Or go even further and say: “We’ve been friends for a while. And I want to help, but I feel as if I’m in over my head with your — very legitimate! — struggles. Have you been screened for depression? Considered therapy?”
Laura could just be bad at this friendship thing. She could also be in an emotional rut, deepened by the flight of other friends who skipped the clear communication and went straight for the exits.
As I said, this extra effort is not an obligation. But it is an option, a generous one, to offer Laura the kind of friendship you’d gladly maintain, complete with user manual.
Either she accepts the offer or she will have the information she needs — to understand why you no longer invite her to lunch and what she can do to improve her situation.
Or, third possibility: She takes enough offense at your candor to end the friendship for you. From here, at least, each looks like an improvement over sprinting to the exit yourself.
