Innovative sand battery can heat entire town for a week

Shawn Knight

Posts: 15,267   +192
Staff member
Forward-looking: A Finnish startup has secured $7.6 million Euro ($8.2 million) in seed funding to scale up its unique sand battery technology. The money will be used to grow the company's sales and R&D teams, and help advance the tech's capabilities. But what exactly is a sand battery, anyway?

A sand battery uses sand or sand-like material as a medium to store energy as heat. Its core purpose is to serve as a high-capacity reservoir for surplus wind and solar energy. The unit consists of an insulated silo filled with sand, and is outfitted with heat transfer pipes and tech to convert electricity to heat. When needed, heat can be extracted from the system for a variety of uses.

The system doesn't rely on exotic materials, either. The company said sand grain size isn't all that important, and they prefer to use materials that aren't typically used in the construction industry.

Polar Night Energy installed its first sand battery in Vatajankoski's district heating network in Kankaanpää, Finland, which went into service in 2022. That battery affords 100 kW of heating power and 8 MWh of capacity.

Last month, Polar Night Energy announced it had partnered with Finnish district heating company Loviisan Lämpö to build an industrial-scale sand battery in Pornainen. The unit will measure approximately 13 meters (42.7 feet) high and 15 meters (49.2 feet) wide, and will take a little over a year to construct and test.

Once operational, the bigger battery will be able to store up to 100 MWh of thermal energy and provide 1 MW of heating power. In Pornainen, that'll translate to a full week of heat supply in the winter and nearly a month's worth during the summer.

The sand inside the battery can be heated to more than 1,000 degrees Celsius and is typically limited by the heat resistance of the materials used in construction of the storage facility. Polar Night Energy said its storage system can even be built underground, ideal for regions where real estate is highly valued.

Permalink to story:

 
Yes, it's an actual battery. But it's hardly new tech -- such thermal storage solutions have been tried before. The primary issue is their low efficiency -- smaller installations can easily lose half the stored energy in through conductive cooling. And then, if you want the energy in the form of electricity rather than pure heat, expect another 50% loss on that conversion as well, with an E2E efficiency of 25% or less.

A very large subterranean system can be more efficient, but even here unless you're planning on consuming most of the stored energy as heat itself, it's not economical.
 
Yes, it's an actual battery. But it's hardly new tech -- such thermal storage solutions have been tried before. The primary issue is their low efficiency -- smaller installations can easily lose half the stored energy in through conductive cooling. And then, if you want the energy in the form of electricity rather than pure heat, expect another 50% loss on that conversion as well, with an E2E efficiency of 25% or less.

A very large subterranean system can be more efficient, but even here unless you're planning on consuming most of the stored energy as heat itself, it's not economical.
They must have discovered new ways or new materials that make it more viable now
 
The word Battery implies portability. A house-size fixed installation doesn't qualify.

BZZZT!!! wrong!

Battery definition:
bat·ter·y
/ˈbadərē/
noun
noun: battery; plural noun: batteries; noun: the battery

1.
a container consisting of one or more cells, in which chemical energy is converted into electricity and used as a source of power.
"battery power"
h
Similar:
cell

accumulator
power unit
2.
a fortified emplacement for heavy guns.
"anti-aircraft missile batteries"

an artillery subunit of guns, men, and vehicles.
h
Similar:
gun emplacement

artillery unit
artillery
cannonry
ordnance
heavy weapons
heavy weaponry
guns

cannons

3.
a set of units of equipment, typically when connected together.
"a battery of equipment to monitor blood pressure"
h
Similar:
array
set
bank
group
row
line
lineup
raft
collection
assortment

an extensive series, sequence, or range of things.
"children given a battery of tests"
h
Similar:
series

sequence
range
set
cycle
chain
string
progression

succession

4.
Law
the crime or tort of unconsented physical contact with another person, even where the contact is not violent but merely menacing or offensive.
"any act which puts a person in immediate and reasonable fear of battery"
h
Similar:
violence
assault
mugging
beating
striking
thumping
thrashing
bashing
grievous bodily harm
actual bodily harm
GBH
ABH
5.
Baseball
the pitcher and the catcher in a game, considered as a unit.

In this case definition 3 applies.
 
BZZZT!!! wrong!

Battery definition:
bat·ter·y
/ˈbadərē/
noun
noun: battery; plural noun: batteries; noun: the battery

1.
a container consisting of one or more cells, in which chemical energy is converted into electricity and used as a source of power.
"battery power"
h
Similar:
cell

accumulator
power unit
2.
a fortified emplacement for heavy guns.
"anti-aircraft missile batteries"

an artillery subunit of guns, men, and vehicles.
h
Similar:
gun emplacement

artillery unit
artillery
cannonry
ordnance
heavy weapons
heavy weaponry
guns

cannons

3.
a set of units of equipment, typically when connected together.
"a battery of equipment to monitor blood pressure"
h
Similar:
array
set
bank
group
row
line
lineup
raft
collection
assortment

an extensive series, sequence, or range of things.
"children given a battery of tests"
h
Similar:
series

sequence
range
set
cycle
chain
string
progression

succession

4.
Law
the crime or tort of unconsented physical contact with another person, even where the contact is not violent but merely menacing or offensive.
"any act which puts a person in immediate and reasonable fear of battery"
h
Similar:
violence
assault
mugging
beating
striking
thumping
thrashing
bashing
grievous bodily harm
actual bodily harm
GBH
ABH
5.
Baseball
the pitcher and the catcher in a game, considered as a unit.

In this case definition 3 applies.
What they made is a stationary heat storage, which can convert heat into electricity on demand, it is not a battery.
 
The word Battery implies portability. A house-size fixed installation doesn't qualify...[it] can convert heat into electricity on demand, it is not a battery.
Volta's original battery wasn't portable, and there are already lithium-ion batteries larger than an entire football field -- Tesla built one in 2017 to power an entire town. Grid-scale batteries utilizing pumped hydro are even larger. And all batteries work by converting some other form of energy into electricity on demand., usually chemical. Excepting ultracapacitors, the electricity isn't already there inside, floating around on its own.

If you wish to be truly anal about language -- like myself -- the word battery originally denoted a "battery of units" -- an assemblage of multiple electrochemical cells, each generating its own electricity independently. Volta's original unit was a "battery" of two dozen such cells piled atop each other. By this stricter definition, Tesla's football-field-sized battery qualifies as such, but the "single cell" 1.5v batteries you've been using your entire life do not.
 
Evidently the meaning of the word "battery" has expanded to include any device that can be "charged" via the use of any form of energy and then discharged via the use of any form of energy.
 
It's like referring to a large tank of water, filled via a solar-powered pump from a lower point, as a battery simply because you can convert water back into electricity... it doesn't make sense.
 
It's like referring to a large tank of water, filled via a solar-powered pump from a lower point, as a battery simply because you can convert water back into electricity... it doesn't make sense.
Interestingly enough, hydro-pumped facilities are indeed referred to as "the world's largest batteries". They store energy, and release it as electricity on demand -- the modern definition of the term. Would you be more comfortable calling it a battery if your "large tank" was the size of a D-Cell flashlight battery, and produced electricity as the water inside flowed downward?

Words change meaning over time. A "deer" used to mean any animal at all, if you worked in an "office", it meant you were a member of the Church, and the terms "awesome" and "awful" used to mean the same, rather than polar opposites. Originally the term battery meant a group of units working together, such as an artillery battery. But "a battery of voltaic cells" was too cumbersome, so it became shortened to just "battery" -- even when we're only talking about one cell alone.
 
Interestingly enough, hydro-pumped facilities are indeed referred to as "the world's largest batteries". They store energy, and release it as electricity on demand -- the modern definition of the term. Would you be more comfortable calling it a battery if your "large tank" was the size of a D-Cell flashlight battery, and produced electricity as the water inside flowed downward?

Words change meaning over time. A "deer" used to mean any animal at all, if you worked in an "office", it meant you were a member of the Church, and the terms "awesome" and "awful" used to mean the same, rather than polar opposites. Originally the term battery meant a group of units working together, such as an artillery battery. But "a battery of voltaic cells" was too cumbersome, so it became shortened to just "battery" -- even when we're only talking about one cell alone.
I can poetically call anything a battery, but it's not accurate to refer to sand storing heat or a dam storing water as a battery.

I'm not a fan of this juggling of words.
 
Galvanic Cell - Stores energy in form of Chemicals
Dam - Stores energy in form of Potential Energy of water
Capacitor - Stores energy in Electric Field
Inductor - Stores energy in Magnetic Field
Flywheel Battery - Stores energy in Rotational motion
Radioactive atoms(?) - Stores energy in form of unstable Nucleus
Sand Battery - Stores energy in form of Heat (there are other ways to store energy in the form of Heat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermal_energy_storage)

These are all that I can come up with, will edit if find more.
 
Back