8 Best Stanley Cup Dupes You Can Buy, According to Testing
We tested 13 alternatives to the popular insulated tumbler to see which performed best.
We've been independently researching and testing products for over 120 years. If you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more about our review process.
By now you've probably heard of the Stanley Quencher H2.0 FlowState Tumbler a.k.a. the Stanley Cup, one of our 2023 Kitchen Gear Award winners. If you're not familiar, it's an insulated stainless steel tumbler with a handle that's slender enough to fit in a car's cupholder. It also has a dual mouthpiece so you have the option to sip from the lid or use a straw.
The Stanley Cup comes in five different sizes: 14-, 20-, 30-, 40- and 64-ounce and countless colorways. Stanley Cups are likely most popular for their new color launches from a Joanna Gaines's collab to their black chroma collection or the infamously hard-to-find Starbucks Stanley Cups. Because Stanley Cups have become so popular, numerous brands have taken notice, launching a wide range of Stanley Cup alternatives — which we couldn't wait to put to the test.
Our top picks:
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
In the Good Housekeeping Institute Kitchen Appliances and Innovation Lab, we've tested thousands of beverage-related products in the last couple of decades. In our recent side-by-side Lab test of Stanley Cup dupes (focusing on 40-ounce models), we tested 13 dupes, plus more than 26 tumblers were given to consumer testers for real-life feedback. Through our in-Lab and consumer testing, we were able to narrow down the Stanley Cup dupes available on the market to this group of tumblers that excelled in temperature retention, ease of use and cleaning and so much more.
You can read about how we evaluate Stanley cup dupes in our Lab — plus everything you need to know to shop for your perfect Stanley cup dupe — at the end of this guide. Prefer a water bottle instead? Check out our guides to the best insulated water bottles, filtered water bottles or even smart water bottles.
HydroJug Traveler
Pros
- Leak-proof design
- Non-slip rubber base
- Great temperature rentention
Cons
- Dented during drop testing
The HydroJug Traveler was the best-performing Stanley Cup dupe in our Lab tests. We love that you can fold the straw down when not drinking from this tumbler, and that it proved to be leak-proof in our tests when you do so.
It also didn't leak in our drop test, where we drop the tumbler from a height of three feet, but it did dent. Over the course of 24 hours, the temperature of this tumbler changed four degrees, from 39°F to 43°F, receiving a high temperature retention score as well. (One Stanley Cup dupe changed as little as one degree, while several changed more than 15º.)
"I prefer that the lid is see-through, so you can easily see what's inside the cup without unscrewing the top," said one tester who found this tumbler to be lighter than the Stanley Cup and appreciated the HydroJug's rubber base, which makes it less prone to falling over on certain surfaces. "I really think this Hydrojug is a remarkable upgrade to the Stanley."
| Capacities available | 40 oz |
|---|---|
| 40-oz tumbler weight | 20.7 oz |
| Dishwasher safe | Yes |
Simple Modern Trek Tumbler
Pros
- Wide variety of colorways
- Affordable price point
- Excellent temperature retention
Cons
- Bottom was dented and chipped after drop testing
The Stanley Cup and other dupes tend be pricey, but the Simple Modern tumbler is the most affordable model we tested. It's also our second best performing dupe on our list.
This $30 tumbler offers excellent temperature retention; it fluctuated by only one degree over 24 hours of testing. While this dupe leaked during our Lab tests, in which we knock it over, invert it and slide it side-to-side, it only created a small puddle of water. However, it did dent quite a bit on the bottom of the tumbler after drop testing — some paint chipped off and the tumbler was unable to stand up straight afterwards.
We love how many different colorways this dupe comes in, like Multi-Color Garden Symphony to Black Leopard, similar to the Stanley Cup. This model is also lightweight and slender, with minimal pieces to clean. It's dishwasher safe as well. One tester noted that the lid was unique compared to others they tested. It's made of one piece so you don't have to worry about removing any extra parts for cleaning.
| Capacities available | 24, 30, 40 and 50 oz |
|---|---|
| 40-oz tumbler weight | 19.6 oz |
| Dishwasher safe | Yes |
Yeti Rambler Straw Mug
Pros
- Consumer testers found it kept their beverages cold for hours
- Clear lid allows you to monitor water intake
- Available in multiple sizes and bold colorways
Cons
- Lid is difficult to remove
This Stanley Cup dupe by Yeti excelled in drop testing: while the straw fell out, there were no dents at all. "This is one of my favorites. It feels extra sturdy and I like that they offer a lot of different sizes," says Kitchen Appliances and Innovation Lab Director Nicole Papantoniou. A tester noted, "The cup can hold an ample amount of liquid and keeps my beverage cold for hours."
During leak testing, there was a small leak initially but then the tumbler stopped spilling for the remainder of the test; it scored higher than most Stanley Cup dupes we tested. We found the lid hard to remove — you have to tug on it to remove it from the cup — but that likely contributed to it leaking less than competitors. The lid is clear, making it easy to monitor your water intake.
| Capacities available | 25, 35 and 42 oz |
|---|---|
| 42-oz tumbler weight | 27.5 oz |
| Dishwasher safe | Yes |
RTIC Road Trip Tumbler
Pros
- Lid offers drinking versatility
- Excellent temperature retention
- Ceramic-lined tumbler
Cons
- After drop testing, it sat unevenly on the countertop
The RTIC Road Trip Tumbler is a ceramic-lined Stanley Cup dupe with a three-in-one lid that allows you to drink through the spout or use a straw and seals when you're on the go, which testers appreciated. Compared to any other dupe that we tested, this product looked the most like a Stanley Cup. We noticed, however, that it comes in less colors than its competitors, likely since it's new to the market.
Our tests found that this tumbler kept water ice cold for hours. Over the course of 24 hours, the water inside only elevated by 2 degrees and the water remained under 48°F after 30 hours of testing. Though after drop testing this model, there was a small dent on the side and a slight flaring on the bottom. which created a slight tilt to the tumbler.
| Capacities available | 30 and 40 oz |
|---|---|
| 40-oz tumbler weight | 20.9 oz |
| Dishwasher safe | Yes |
BrüMate Era Tumbler
Pros
- Comfortable-to-grip handle
- Rubber non-slip base
- Straw that locks, ensuring it's leak-proof
Cons
- Large dent after drop testing
The Stanley Cup can leak, so if that's a dealbreaker for you, the BrüMate Era Tumbler is an excellent alternative. It was one of the best-tested tumblers during leak testing — though it's important to make sure that the straw is properly positioned to prevent leakage. This Stanley Cup dupe boasts a comfortable handle with a rubber grip, a rubber non-slip base and a stainless steel and silicone straw.
This tumbler stayed cold during temperature-retention testing, although it did elevate by 7º during the 24-hour testing period, which was higher than some of the other models tested. During drop testing, this dupe was left with a large dent on the bottom. We also found the straw to be lower, much closer to the cup's lid compared to other models we tested. Some testers wanted a taller straw, while others were unbothered and simply appreciated that it was silicone and comfortable on their teeth.
| Capacities available | 30 and 40 oz |
|---|---|
| 40-oz tumbler weight | 25.4 oz |
| Dishwasher safe | Yes |
Owala Travel Tumbler
Owala Travel Tumbler
Pros
- Bold colorways
- Easy to hold
- Straw coordinates with cup, so it's easy to find
Cons
- Dented and paint peeled off after drop-testing
If you're a fan of the Owala FreeSip water bottle, the brand's Travel Tumbler may catch your eye as well. This Stanley Cup dupe comes in a variety of fun color combos just like the Freesip.
This was one of the most lightweight models we tested and our consumer testers liked it for multiple reasons. "The handle is easy to grip and carry, while the straw is comfortable to drink from, but I wish it wasn't so stiff," said a consumer tester who also remarked on the cup's gorgeous bold colors. Testers did note that there are quite a bit of pieces on the lid of the tumbler which require extra care because of the nooks and crannies.
After drop testing, there were no dents on the sides of this tumbler, however there was a dent on the bottom with paint that had peeled off. "I have noticed scratching on mine after many months of testing/using," says Papantoniou.
| Capacities available | 24 and 40 oz |
|---|---|
| 40-oz tumbler weight | 19.7 oz |
| Dishwasher safe | Dishwasher-safe lid and hand-washable cup |
Hydro Flask All Around Travel Tumbler
Hydro Flask All Around Travel Tumbler
Pros
- The lid is easy to push on and take off
- Many colorways
- Lightweight, easy-to-hold tumbler
Cons
- Temperature retention could be better
Hydro Flask All Around Travel Tumbler is a popular Stanley Cup dupe among many GH staffers.
"I really enjoy drinking out of this tumbler," says Papantoniou. "It feels lightweight and the lid is easy to push on and take off. The top part of the straw is made of silicone and is easy to drink out of, especially when you're lying down" she says. This Stanley Cup dupe also performed better in the drop testing compared to most of the tumblers we tested. There is a small dent on the side and a very slight tilt of the tumbler now, but we were impressed with how well the lid stayed on during the drop.
This tumbler comes in many colors to add a pop of color to your desk and it's even dishwasher-safe, unlike other Hydro Flask water bottles which are hand-wash only. We did find that this cup isn't as great at temperature retention compared to other picks on this list.
| Capacities available | 32 and 40 oz |
|---|---|
| 40-ounce tumbler weight | 20.1 oz |
| Dishwasher safe | Yes |
Corkcicle Cruiser Tumbler
Pros
- Numerous patterns and colorways to choose from
- Very durable tumbler
- Non-slip base
Cons
- Performed poorly in leak testing
The Corkcicle Cruiser Tumbler comes in a variety of fun patterns, colors and finishes, from a sparkly rainbow design (as shown here) to matte periwinkle.
We especially love how comfortable the handle is to grip with the help from soft silicone, which is also on the base of the dupe to protect your countertop. This model was also one the most durable, out of all the dupes we tested. It has no dents on the side or the bottom and is one of the only dupes still standing up straight, without a tilt.
This model features two ways to sip from it, through a straw and a small spout, but we don't recommend the spout since it's a bit cumbersome to sip out of especially if the cup is completely full. The lid also leaked more than most of the other models tested, so we suggest handling it cautiously.
| Capacities Available | 40 ounces |
|---|---|
| 40-ounce Tumbler Weight | 21.7 ounces |
| Dishwasher-safe | Yes, top rack dishwasher-safe |
How we tested Stanley Cup dupes
In the Good Housekeeping Institute Kitchen Appliances and Innovation Lab, we evaluate each piece of drinkware for leakage, temperature retention, durability and more. We've tested thousands of pieces of drinkware over the last couple of decades.
In our latest round, we tested 13 Stanley Cup dupes side-by-side to evaluate performance and ease of use.
To determine each model's durability, we use our drop-tester machine (pictured) to drop each cup at a height of three feet — twice with the cup standing upright and once with it on its side.
To test leakage, we fill each water bottle with the same amount of water and food dye. We knock over each tumbler and let it sit on its side for 30 seconds, then we check to see if any water seeps through its straw or lid.
To assess temperature retention, every tumbler is filled to maximum capacity with water. We then remove a specific amount of water from each tumbler, replacing it with a calculated amount of ice. The internal water temperature of each tumbler is documented eight times over 30 hours to determine which dupes retain temperature best.
To evaluate ease of use, we consider how each tumbler opens and closes. Using either a dishwasher or dish soap and a brush, we test how easy it is to clean each model. In addition to Lab tests, we send Stanley Cup dupes to consumer testers to get their opinions on how they fare in real life.
What to look for when buying a Stanley Cup dupe
✔️ Size: Stanley Cup dupes are primarily 40 ounces, but there are some brands that offer multiple sizes — from as small as 24 ounces to as large as 50 ounces. The 40-ounce size can be heavy once filled to maximum capacity, but it also reduces how often it needs to be refilled. While many of the 40-ounce water bottles we've tested won't fit in a car's cupholder, most Stanley Cup dupes are designed to have a tapered bottom to accommodate a car's cupholder.
✔️ Materials: All Stanley Cup dupes that we tested were made of insulated stainless steel, with some insulation being better than others. A few brands used a ceramic coating on the cups' interiors which, according to the manufacturers, was added for better tasting water, since some people can be sensitive to the taste that stainless steel imparts on water.
✔️ Ease of drinking: The majority of the tumblers that we tested had a singular way of drinking from the cup: lid on and through a straw. However, a few models had spouts that you could sip water through. If you don't like drinking through a straw, we recommend selecting one of the cups with this versatility.
✔️ Handle: Since Stanley Cup dupes tend to have a wide body, it's best to select a cup with a handle that is comfortable for you — especially if you intend on carrying it around from meeting to meeting or all over your house. In particular, our experts prefer a model with a silicone grip for added comfort.
✔️ Leak resistance: Like the original Stanley Cup, most Stanley Cup dupes are not leak resistant. If this is important to you, we recommend purchasing our best overall pick or our best leak-proof pick, which, according to our testing, are in fact leak-proof.
✔️ Cleanability: Most Stanley Cup dupes are dishwasher-safe for the most part, but we do recommend washing your straws by hand using a small straw brush. Some cups do have more pieces on the lid which require extra care when cleaning.
Why are Stanley tumblers so popular?
For one, Stanley Cups hold a lot of water in a slim footprint. They also keep water cold and feel sturdy in the hand. Papantoniou can attest — she uses several Stanleys and a few from other brands: "Even though they’re known to spill easily, they’re easy to take on the go if you hold them in your hand and they fit in a car's cupholders well. They’re easy to clean too."
Consumers have also been drawn to the numerous fun colors that Stanley has launched, which has turned the product into a collector's item. "Health and wellness practices should be something you look forward to and enjoy doing," says GH Nutrition and Wellness Lab Director Stefani Sassos. "If a funky color or cool design on a water bottle encourages you to drink more water, that may help the habit stick."
Another benefit of using a Stanley tumbler is how large it is, which means you don’t have to fill it up as many times as you would a smaller bottle. "That may make you more inclined to drink more water," says Sassos. "Drinking through a straw may also encourage you to consume more liquids."
Why trust Good Housekeeping?
Eva Bleyer has tested all kinds of kitchen gear for GH, including gas ranges, microwaves, kitchen scales and blenders. She holds a B.S. in Food Studies, Nutrition and Public Health from New York University, where she studied sustainability practices. Eva has tested the Stanley Cup, along with all the Stanley Cup dupes on this list. She has also tested numerous water bottles for the Kitchen Appliances Lab.
Eva (she/her) is a reviews analyst in the Kitchen Appliances and Innovation Lab, where she tests kitchen gear, home appliances and culinary innovations. She graduated from NYU with a bachelor of science in food studies, nutrition and public health and is a trained chef through the Natural Gourmet Institute. Eva has more than 10 years of experience in the food industry, working as a food stylist, personal chef and marketing manager.
Watch Next
