All of the legal action filed in the East Palestine train derailment ... so far
EAST PALESTINE – The number of federal lawsuits over the Feb. 3 Norfolk Southern train derailment in East Palestine continues to grow.
At least 19 suits have been filed in the U.S. District Court's Northern District of Ohio since Feb. 7.
The train was carrying hazardous materials to Conway, Pennsylvania, when it wrecked and caught fire, forcing evacuations. A controlled release of vinyl chloride, a toxic and flammable gas, in five cars was conducted Feb. 6 to prevent a possible explosion.
The lawsuits filed seek class-action status, compensatory and punitive damages and other actions. Most of them target Norfolk Southern.
Norfolk Southern's safety record:In the aftermath of the Ohio train derailment, what is Norfolk Southern's safety record?
Here's a look at each one by plaintiffs, defendants, filing date and notable information in the claims (latest to oldest):
Competition & Luxury Vehicle Club suit
Plaintiffs: Jon Luke Affeltranger and Competition & Luxury Vehicle Club of Darlington LLC
Plaintiffs: Norfolk Southern Railway and Norfolk Southern Corp.
Filing date: March 3
Notable: Affeltranger, a Pennsylvania resident, owns Competition & Luxury Vehicle Club of Darlington. The suit alleges accidents on Norfolk's rail lines have increased in each of the last four years.
The suit also claims Norfolk has a history of serious train derailments in and around eastern Ohio and western Pennsylvania and provides examples going back as far as 2006.
Competition & Luxury Vehicle Club of Darlington suit by Benjamin Duer on Scribd
Smith, Pugar & Donaldson suit
Plaintiffs: Brenda Smith, Debbie Pugar, John Pugar and Alvin Donaldson
Defendants: Norfolk Southern Railway and Norfolk Southern Corp.
Filing date: March 2
Notable: None of the plaintiffs in this case live or work in the East Palestine area. They are from East Liverpool, Beaver Falls, Pa., and Wellsville within 30 miles of the crash site.
Smith, Pugar & Donaldson suit by Benjamin Duer on Scribd
Mozuch, Saling & Daugherty suit
Plaintiffs: Rosemary Mozuch, Charles Mozuch, James Saling, Jerrie Daugherty, Charlotte Bowers and William Bowers
Defendants: Norfolk Southern Railway and Norfolk Southern Corp.
Filing date: March 1
Notable: The plaintiffs in this lawsuit are from Darlington, Pennsylvania, East Liverpool and East Palestine. They allege the railroad company failed to explore other options to release the chemical before it went with a "vent-and-burn" plan.
As a result, they claim the derailment and chemical release has hurt market value on their properties and lead to health concerns.
Mozuch, Saling & Daughe... by Benjamin Duer
Patriots USA and Fish suit
Plaintiffs: We the Patriots USA Inc. and Courtney Fish
Defendants: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, EPA Administrator Michael Regan, Ohio EPA Director Anne Vogel and Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine
Filing date: Feb. 27
Notable: This lawsuit is filed against federal and state government officials, not Norfolk Southern. It claims officials provided residents with false assurance over air and water quality.
We the Patriots USA, Courtn... by Benjamin Duer
Bodnar, Manley & Samek suit
Plaintiffs: Christina Bodnar, Terry Manely, Joseph Samek and Samek Automotive Repair LLC; Norfolk Southern
Defendants: Norfolk Southern Railway and Norfolk Southern Corp.
Filing date: Feb. 24
Notable: This lawsuit involves an automotive repair shop and several individuals. The derailed train was operated by two Norfolk Southern rail workers and a trainee.
The suit alleges the controlled release of vinyl chloride from five train cars more than tripled air pollution on Feb. 6, and five times higher on Feb. 9, citing EPA monitors in Youngstown.
Bodnar, Manley and Samek suit by Benjamin Duer on Scribd
Atkinson & Atkinson suit
Plaintiffs: Robert Atkinson and April Atkinson
Defendants: Norfolk Southern Railway and Norfolk Southern Corp.
Filing date: Feb. 23
Notable: This lawsuit involves a couple who live in the Youngstown area about 15 miles north of East Palestine. The claims include exposure to the couple and their children from chemical release.
Atkinson & Atkinson suit by Benjamin Duer on Scribd
Fisher, Gould & Holzer suit
Plaintiffs: William Lee Fisher, Helen Gould, Donna Holzer, Robert Holzer, Taylor Holzer, Melinda Hutton, Jennifer Kidder, Joseph Kidder, Julie Richael, Keith Richael and George A. Psomas
Defendants: Norfolk Southern Railway and Norfolk Southern Corp.
Filing date: Feb. 23
Notable: This lawsuit alleges numerous rescue animals suffered swollen faces, weeping eyes and stomach ailments. Also, one of the plaintiffs, a truck driver by trade, says he lost work due to illness and exhaustion.
Fisher, Gould & Holzer suit by Benjamin Duer on Scribd
Dettmer & Boyer suit
Plaintiffs: Amy Dettmer and Melissa Boyer
Defendants: Norfolk Southern Railway and Norfolk Southern Corp.
Filing date: Feb. 22
Notable: The suit alleges Norfolk Southern prioritized profits over safety with an outdated brake system, and that the company lacks signalmen who install, repair and maintain signal systems.
Dettmer & Boyer suit by Benjamin Duer on Scribd
Snyder & Velez suit
Plaintiffs: Scott Snyder and Nathen Velez
Defendants: Norfolk Southern Railway and Norfolk Southern Corp.
Filing date: Feb. 22
Notable: Filed by same law firm in Dettmer & Boyer suit, the suit makes the same accusations against Norfolk Southern.
Snyder and Velez suit by Benjamin Duer on Scribd
Baker & Davis suit
Plaintiffs: Kayla Baker, Christen Davis, Neely Jack, William Jack, Marie Gordon-Coontz, John Jurjavic, Shelby Vollnogle and Dalqan Holdings LLC
Defendants: Norfolk Southern Railway and Norfolk Southern Corp.
Filing date: Feb. 20
Notable: This suit involves individuals and a Dairy Queen franchise on South Market Street in East Palestine. It claims an inversion layer at around 3,000 feet trapped smoke in the atmosphere. The result was toxic fumes spread out and winds blew them up to 30 miles north of the wreck.
Baker & Davis suit by Benjamin Duer on Scribd
Ibel & Tomor suit
Plaintiffs: Tina Ibel and Sheryl Tomor
Defendants: Norfolk Southern Railway and Norfolk Southern Corp.
Filing date: Feb. 17
Notable: The suits says the derailment occurred within 200 feet of Ibel's property and exposure from the chemicals left her with headaches, irritations and a sore throat. Tomor, who lives a mile away, claims same symptoms.
Ibel & Tomor suit by Benjamin Duer on Scribd
Davis & Heaton suit
Plaintiffs: Jessica Davis, Gerald Heaton, Christopher Ammon, Anita Ammon, Chase Ammon, Todd Hart and unnamed minors
Defendants: Norfolk Southern Railway and Norfolk Southern Corp.
Filing date: Feb. 16
Notable: The suit claims a couple and their children received an alert to evacuate Feb. 3 but they were not given a reason. After a few hours, they returned home and thought it was safe.
Then they heard a loud explosion, saw "the night sky erupt with fire," and learned a train derailed. The family claimed "experiencing headaches and sore throats," and left for a friend's house in Leetonia.
Davis & Heaton suit by Benjamin Duer on Scribd
Battaglia & Baughman suit
Who: Kristin Battaglia, Laura Zuch-Battaglia, Dawn Baughman and unnamed minors
Defendants: Norfolk Southern Railway and Norfolk Southern Corp.
Filing date: Feb. 16
Notable: This suit claims the controlled release of toxic and flammable vinyl chloride and other chemicals harmed waterways and wildlife. It also said the train used traditional air brakes and not electronically controlled pneumatic ones.
Battaglia & Baughman suit by Benjamin Duer on Scribd
Kinder, Bird Dog Hill Kennels, Stonybrook Kennel and Taas suit
Plaintiffs: Chase Kinder, Cheri Kinder, Pamela Taas, Bird Dog Hill Kennels, Stonybrook Kennel
Defendants: Norfolk Southern Railway and Norfolk Southern Corp.
Filing date: Feb. 15
Notable: The lawsuit involves two dog kennels and several individuals. It was originally filed in Columbiana County Common Pleas Court and then moved to federal court.
Kinder Lawsuit by Benjamin Duer on Scribd
Canterbury & Sodergen suit
Plaintiffs: Aysia Canterbury and Lisa Sodergen
Defendants: Norfolk Southern Railway and Norfolk Southern Corp.
Filing date: Feb. 15
Notable: The first suit to allege 1.1 million pounds of vinyl chloride were released into the environment when officials conducted the controlled release to prevent an explosion.
Canterbury & Sodergen suit by Benjamin Duer on Scribd
Hall & Hall suit
Plaintiffs: Ray E. Hall and Judith E. Hall
Defendants: Norfolk Southern Railway and Norfolk Southern Corp.
Filing date: Feb. 9
Notable: This suit claims the railroad company handled and transported volatile chemicals in an ultra-hazardous manner, violating government regulations.
Hall & Hall suit by Benjamin Duer on Scribd
Erdos, Anderson & Valley View suit
Plaintiffs: Andrew Erdos, David Anderson and Valley View MPH LLC (Pennsylvania)
Defendants: Norfolk Southern Railway and Norfolk Southern Corp.
Filing date: Feb. 9
Notable: The first lawsuit to detail the travel route for the train from Madison County, Illinois, to Conway, Pennsylvania, with the lightest cars loaded between heavy rear tankers and the front engine. It also claimed fire and smoke from the accident could be seen on weather radar.
Erdos, Anderson and Valley View suit by Benjamin Duer on Scribd
Eisley & Zalick suit
Plaintiffs: Gracye Eisley and Jeffrey Zalick
Defendants: Norfolk Southern Railway and Norfolk Southern Corp.
Filing date: Feb. 8
Notable: It was the first lawsuit to demand — among other things — the railroad company provide regular medical monitoring.
Eisel and Zalick lawsuit by Benjamin Duer on Scribd
Feezle & Scheufele suit
Plaintiffs: Harold R. Feezle, Susan E. Scheufele and David J. .Scheufele
Defendants: Norfolk Southern Railway and Norfolk Southern Corp.
Filing date: Feb. 7
Notable: It was the first lawsuit filed against the railroad company for the derailment and controlled release of hazardous chemicals, providing a timeline of events. The release involved toxic and flammable vinyl chloride that can increase cancer risks, it said.
Feezle and Scheufele lawsuit by Benjamin Duer on Scribd
(Note: Most of the same allegations and details can be found in all lawsuits against Norfolk Southern. The notable information is to distinguish one suit from another.)
Reach Benjamin Duer at 330-580-8567 or ben.duer@cantonrep.com.
Follow on Twitter @bduerREP
This article originally appeared on The Repository: Ohio train derailment lawsuits target Norfolk Southern, government