But most of the praise was reserved for Cruise.
"It’s a fresh-faced gloss on the original ... powered, like the original, by a star who’ll simply never stop being a star," wrote K. Austin Collins of Rolling Stone.
Leah Greenblatt of Entertainment Weekly said the movie "belongs in almost every scene to Cruise."
"At this point in his career, he's not really playing characters so much as variations on a theme — the theme being, perhaps, The Last Movie Star," she said. "And in the air up there, he stands alone."