LETTERS TO THE EDIOR

0

How ‘East Indians’ Got Their Name

The Portuguese arrived in India in 1498  and began  evangelizing the local population.  They converted the people of north Konkan—-Bombay,  Bassein , Thane etc   and called them : “Portuguese Christians”. Later, the East India Co came to India in 1600 as traders , mainly in spices. Spices were important since they were used as preservatives, especially for meat, as there were no refrigerators. In 1661 the  Portuguese gave Bombay  as dowry to the British after King Charles II of England married princess Catherine  of Portugal. A little later, in 1668 Bombay was given to the East India Co for an annual rent of £10.  By virtue of being Catholics,  the local converts in Bombay who were known as Portuguese Christians,  were given preference in jobs by the British.  With the advent of the railways and steam ships, immigrants from Goa began coming to Bombay for jobs. They lived in clubs known as kudds.  At one time there were around 450 kudds , one for each village in Goa. These kudds were situated mainly in Dhobi Talao, Mazagoan  and Chira  Bazaar. These immigrants from Goa  were also called ‘Portuguese Christians’. They too got preferential treatment for jobs. 

Robert Castellino, Calangute

Official Covid-19  Toll Much Higher

The  official  Covid-19  toll   so  far  in  India  is  around  4,00,000 lives.  However,  experts  are  of  the  opinion  that  this is  not  an  accurate  figure.  It  is  assumed  that  over  a  million people  may  have  lost their  lives  due  to Covid-19.  It  is  worrisome  that  Covid related  data,  whether  it  is  deaths,  number  of  infections  or  tests  is  not  properly collected  and  maintained.  Recording of accurate data  related  to  Covid  helps to understand  the  enormity  of  the  disease and  the steps  to  be  taken  to  combat  it.  Further, demographic  and  geographical  data will help  to  combat  the  third  wave.  As any kind  of  death is a great loss  to the  families concerned, the families of Covid  victims too deserve to be fairly treated  by  the  government. However, unlike  railway  accidents or industrial disasters, the  families of Covid victims are not compensated. Just as the government holds the responsibility to compensate those  rendered  jobless or destitute, it has the  responsibility to compensate the  families  of  Covid victims. Realising the  importance of collecting  accurate data of  covid deaths, many  states have revised  their death count. Courts prodded state  governments  into action and accordingly they have  started revising data related to Covid deaths. As  per the directions of courts, states  such  as  Bihar,  Uttarakhand,  Maharashtra,  Telangana,  Tamil  Nadu,  Delhi  and  so  on  have  recounted  their  death  figures.

VENU  G S,  Kollam

  Given  that  the  Central  government  and  some  state  governments  have  announced  some  relief  measures  such  as  financial  assistance  to  orphan  children of  Covid  victims,  inaccurate  reporting  of  Covid  death  data  will  deprive  the  families  of  Covid  victims  of  their  right  to  government  benefits.  Some  state  governments  try  to  suppress  accurate  Covid  death  data  to  create  an  impression  that  they  have  succeeded  in  combating  the  pandemic.  They  assume  that  reporting  a  data  that  shows  high  rate  of  Covid  deaths  would  adversely  affect  governance  in  the  respective  state  and  consequently  affect  the  reputation  of  the  government.  Further,  absence  of  systems  to  ascertain  the  real  cause  of  deaths  have  proved  to  be  an  impediment  to  reporting  of  accurate  Covid  death  data. All  these  factors  have  contributed  to  India’s  underreporting  of  Covid  death  data.  As  a  consequence,  it  has  raised  doubts  about  India’s  real  Covid  related  death  toll.  In  fact,  many  countries  have  not  reported  accurate  Covid  death  toll.  Hence,  India  alone  cannot  be  blamed  for  this.  Each country  has  its  own  reasons  for  underreporting  Covid  death  toll.  Notwithstanding  this,   India  has  woken  up  to  the  reality  and  started  acting  to  overcome  this  difficulty. 

Yours  etc,