Kansas City police officer fatally shot ‘defenseless and fleeing’ dog, lawsuit says

Bill Lukitsch, Luke Nozicka
·2 min read

A Northland couple is suing the Kansas City Police Department in federal court, alleging an officer fatally shot their dog and caused a minor injury to one of its owners with a ricocheting bullet.

The lawsuit, filed last week by Brandee Buschmann and William Morrison, claims Officer John Beck “executed a defenseless and fleeing animal” without just cause.

The police department, they allege, “rubber-stamped” his actions as justified without a proper review.

Capt. Leslie Foreman, a police spokeswoman, said the department generally does not comment on pending litigation “to ensure fairness on all sides.” Department policy allows officers to kill animals that are a threat to public safety or department members.

On July 30, 2016, two officers were dispatched to the couple’s home after a neighbor reported hearing screaming and yelling, according to the lawsuit.

The officers approached a door to the couple’s home, as shown on a home surveillance camera, and saw the back door cracked open. They knocked and backed away. Soon after, the dog ran out of the door toward Beck, who fired and missed.

After the missed shot, the owners said, the dog turned and ran back toward the house. The officer fired again as the dog, named Sierra, was retreating and struck her fatally, the lawsuit claims.

The officers “simply left the scene” as the owners grieved over their dog’s body, according to the lawsuit. The pair is also suing the second officer, who is identified in the lawsuit without a first name as Officer Lagud.

The lawsuit also claims the noises reported by the neighbor likely came from a nearby walking trail. Media reports at the time said the shooting occurred near the 3800 block of North Cleveland Avenue.

In the days that followed, police “failed to conduct” any probe into the shooting, the couple alleges. They said shell casings were “left untouched” in their yard for months “in hopes that somebody from the Kansas City Police Department would come to investigate.”

The couple is seeking financial compensation for the loss of their dog as well as a personal injury. Their attorney did not return messages seeking comment this week.

In March, the owner of a tow lot filed a federal lawsuit against the department over a separate incident, alleging that officers violated his civil rights and fatally shot his dog in March 2019 while executing a search warrant on his property.

Recommended Stories

  • Hero Great Dane Named Mia Saves Owner From Rattlesnake

    “I should have been bit. I don’t know how I wasn’t bit!”

  • Laughing Cops Charged for Violent Arrest of Woman With Dementia

    YouTubeTwo former Colorado police officers face charges after they violently arrested a 73-year-old woman with dementia last summer—and then laughed while watching gruesome body-cam footage of the incident back at the police station.Ex-Loveland Police officer Austin Hopp, 26, has been charged with second-degree assault causing serious bodily injury, attempting to influence a public servant, and official misconduct in relation to the June 26, 2020, arrest of Karen Garner, who was tackled and handcuffed for leaving a Walmart with unpaid goods.The other cop who assisted in Garner’s arrest, 27-year-old Daria Jalali, was charged with failure to report the use of force by a peace officer, failure to intervene, and first-degree official misconduct, according to online court records.Surveillance footage released last month revealed that after the arrest—in which Hopp tackled Garner to the ground and handcuffed her against his cruiser—the officers went back to the station and watched their body-cam footage of the incident as Garner sat in a cell for hours.“Ready for the pop?” Hopp said to Jalali and other officers as they gathered to watch. “What popped?” another officer asked.“I think it was her shoulder,” Hopp replied, before later adding: “I can’t believe I threw a 73-year-old on the ground.”Mollie Tibbetts’ Killer Recalled ‘Covering Her With Corn Stalks,’ Prosecutor Says in Trial OpeningWhile warrants have been issued for both officers, it was not immediately clear if they were in custody as of Wednesday morning. The charges come after the 8th Judicial District Critical Response Team completed a review of the arrest, which elicited national attention. Gordan McLaughlin, the 8th Judicial district attorney, is expected to hold a press conference about the results of the review.In April, Garner filed a federal lawsuit against the city and the officers who arrested her, claiming they broke her arm and dislocated her shoulder during an excessively violent assault.According to the lawsuit, the incident began after Garner left a Walmart without paying for $13 worth of items. While store employees had stopped her at the exit and retrieved the items, they “refused to let her pay” and she began to walk home. Hopp, however, caught up to Garner to arrest her, calling out for her to stop.When she indicated she could not understand him—which is a common side effect of dementia and sensory aphasia—Hopp “violently assaulted her by twisting her arms behind her back, throwing her to the ground and handcuffing her” while Jalali assisted, the lawsuit alleges.“In their efforts to repeatedly and needlessly injure and subdue the terrified Ms. Garner, Officers Hopp and Jalali fractured and dislocated her shoulder in addition to other injuries (scrapes to face, bloody nose, contusions to knees),” the lawsuit states, adding that a concerned citizen even stopped to question the officers’ “aggression” during the arrest.Colorado Hubby Charged With Killing Suzanne Morphew Tried to Influence FBI Agent: Docs“Despite the visible dislocation of her arm from her shoulder, and her repeated cries of pain while on scene and in the several hours she remained in their care and control that followed, neither the defendant officers nor anyone else at the Loveland Police Department sought medical care for Ms. Garner—instead keeping her in extreme pain, in handcuffs, and actively preventing her from access to medical treatment for over six hours,” the suit added.The surveillance footage from the police station showed that the officers were seemingly too preoccupied reliving the assault to help Garner.“It’s like live TV... Body-cams are my favorite thing to watch, I could watch livestream body-cams all day,” Jalali said in the footage.Jalali and Hopp resigned from the Loveland Police Department on April 30 amid an internal investigation. Another officer who was seen watching the footage at the police station also resigned.Read more at The Daily Beast.Got a tip? Send it to The Daily Beast hereGet our top stories in your inbox every day. Sign up now!Daily Beast Membership: Beast Inside goes deeper on the stories that matter to you. Learn more.

  • Texas man accused of torturing kittens had worked as teacher

    A Texas man accused of torturing and killing four kittens had worked as a geometry teacher at a Houston-area high school before his arrest, the school district said. Graham Reid, 29, of Sugar Land, faces four counts of felony cruelty to non-livestock animals. An arrest warrant says Reid told investigators he “felt powerful” when he tortured his four cats, ranging in age from 4 months to 1 year.

  • New Jersey Shelter Dog Lands Dream Job as Police K-9 Officer

    This shelter dog came in as an “owner surrender” but is now paying it forward—proving there are second chances in life.

  • Naked woman found tied to ‘heavy equipment’ after sexual assault, Illinois police say

    An Illinois man tied a woman to equipment at his workplace and sexually assaulted her, officials say.

  • Boyfriend denies role in Iowa college student's 2018 slaying

    The boyfriend of a University of Iowa student testified Wednesday that he had nothing to do with her 2018 abduction and stabbing death, saying he had been out of town for work and was heartbroken by her slaying. Dalton Jack, the longtime boyfriend of Mollie Tibbetts, was a key witness on the first day of the first-degree murder trial of Cristhian Bahena Rivera, the Mexican national charged in her killing. Prosecutor Bart Klaver said in his opening statement Wednesday that video evidence, DNA analysis and a partial confession by Bahena Rivera, a dairy farm worker, will be crucial to proving his guilt.

  • Livestock or pet? Chapel Hill family wants town rules changed to allow miniature pigs.

    “Pigs are really intelligent, they are house trainable, and they can be really good pets if they are taken care of properly,” Chapel Hill homeowner Stephanie Freeman said.

  • 2 ex-cops accused of breaking an elderly woman's arm during an arrest and later laughing about it are facing charges

    Austin Hopp and Daria Jalali resigned from the Loveland Police Department last month over the 2020 arrest of Karen Garner.

  • Monkey business: Researchers find origins of Florida colony

    A colony of monkeys has lived for about 70 years in urban South Florida, near jets taking off from a nearby airport and fuel storage tanks. Researchers at Florida Atlantic University say they have traced the colony's origins to the Dania Chimpanzee Farm. The South Florida SunSentinel reported Wednesday there was a monkey escape from the farm in 1948, with most of the monkeys recaptured.

  • N.C. judge accused of trying to hit activist with car during police brutality protest

    The judge faces a misdemeanor charge of assault with a deadly weapon and has been summoned to appear in court next month.

  • ABC News exclusive: Teacher says she hugged school shooter after disarming her

    Krista Gneiting, a math teacher at Rigby Middle School in the small town of Rigby, about 15 miles northeast of Idaho Falls, was preparing her students for their final exams on the morning of May 6 when she said she heard a gunshot from down the hall. "So I just told my students, 'We are going to leave, we're going to run to the high school, you're going to run hard, you're not going to look back and now is the time to get up and go,'" Gneiting recalled during an exclusive interview with ABC News that aired Wednesday on "Good Morning America." Gneiting told ABC News she was helping one of the students who had been shot when she saw a girl holding a gun.

  • D-backs vs. Dodgers Highlights

    Betts, Taylor, Lux hit homers for the 9-1 win

  • Now that Joel Greenberg has pleaded guilty to sex trafficking, what's going to happen to Matt Gaetz?

    Florida Rep. Matt Gaetz is said to be tied to former politician Joel Greenberg, who pleaded guilty to federal sex trafficking and other charges.

  • The WNBA's Seattle Storm included a hidden message in their championship rings: 'Say Her Name'

    The Storm's new rings reference WNBA players' efforts to spotlight Breonna Taylor and the "Say Her Name" campaign throughout the 2020 season.

  • Prosecutor: Fatal police shooting of Andrew Brown Jr. was "justified"

    A North Carolina prosecutor said Tuesday that the death of Andrew Brown Jr., a Black man fatally shot by sheriff's deputies last month, was "tragic" but "justified," due to the immediate threat officers believed Brown posed.Why it matters: The FBI has opened a civil rights investigation into Brown's death. Police in Elizabeth City shot him five times, including in the back of his head, according to an independent autopsy report released by family attorneys last month.Stay on top of the latest market trends and economic insights with Axios Markets. Subscribe for freeDriving the news: District Attorney Andrew Womble shared four body camera videos at Tuesday's press conference. He said Brown ignored commands and put his car in drive, turning it "directly at law enforcement officers" who had surrounded the vehicle after attempting to serve drug-related search and arrest warrants.Womble said officers fired the first shot, which entered the front windshield, after Brown drove directly at Sgt. Joel Lunsford. "In this case the deputies used the amount of force deemed reasonably appropriate by them to neutralize a perceived threat," Womble said.Womble was repeatedly pressed about his conclusions during a Q&A session with reporters."The speed at which the car was moving ... was not relevant in my determination," Womble said, when asked by a reporter how the vehicle's acceleration or deceleration affected his decision. "You're not allowed to drive over police officers.""If the first shot is justified, the last shot is justified until the threat is extinguished," he said.Womble said Brown's car was deemed a threat regardless of which way he was driving, after reporters pressed him on whether Brown was attempting to drive away from officers instead of towards them.Lawyers for Brown's family said in a statement later Tuesday, “Andrew Brown Jr., his grieving family, and this community deserve answers. And they received anything but from D.A. Womble’s attempt to whitewash this unjustified killing.""To say this shooting was justified, despite the known facts, is both an insult and a slap in the face to Andrew’s family, the Elizabeth City community, and to rational people everywhere," they added. “We demand that the court release the full video and State Bureau of Investigation report that will help shed some much needed daylight on this case and bring a small measure of justice to this family and this community. Because we certainly got neither transparency nor justice today.""We request that the Federal Department of Justice intervene immediately.”Where it stands: Pasquotank County Sheriff Tommy Wooten II said Tuesday that the deputies involved will keep their jobs but will be "disciplined and retrained," per AP. Brown's death prompted protests in Elizabeth City, North Carolina, and elsewhere over several weeks, with many calling for the release of body camera footage.Editor's note: This story has been updated with the statement from the lawyers for Brown's family and additional information on the deputies. Like this article? Get more from Axios and subscribe to Axios Markets for free.

  • An accused Capitol rioter asked for a separate trial after the 'QAnon Shaman' lawyer said insurrectionists have 'brain damage'

    An accused member of the Proud Boys argued the lawyer's offensive comments will "directly impact" his right to a fair trial.

  • UFOs are about to make their way to the U.S. Senate. Here's what to know.

    U.S. intelligence agencies are expected to deliver a report on “unidentified aerial phenomena” to Congress next month, sparking renewed interest in UFOs.

  • Fox News says it was covering 'both sides' of Trump's election-fraud conspiracy theory in its motion to dismiss Dominion's defamation lawsuit

    Dominion Voting Systems said Fox News pushed debunked theories that the company flipped the 2020 election.

  • Do you know what happened to the bells that used to play in Kansas City Plaza tower?

    After 1981, the trail mostly runs cold. So we need your help.

  • Suspect in Iowa girl's murder had been paroled weeks earlier

    Iowa granted an early release from prison to a repeat offender just months before he allegedly kidnapped and killed a 10-year-old girl, according to parole documents released Tuesday. The Iowa Board of Parole granted Henry Dinkins parole from a Davenport minimum-security residential facility in March 2020, determining he was “able and willing to fulfill the obligations of a law abiding citizen.” “There is a reasonable probability that you can be released without detriment to the community or yourself," according to the parole order signed by the board's chair, Helen Miller, that The Associated Press obtained under the open records law.