• Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.

Death of California man who was pinned facedown by police draws comparisons to that of George Floyd

Janelle Griffith
·4 min read
  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.

Gerardo Gonzalez traveled home this month from North Carolina, where he attends college, to Oakland, California, to spend time with his two brothers and their mother for her 45th birthday.

But instead of cutting a birthday cake last Tuesday, he and his family were mourning the loss of his eldest brother, Mario, 26, who died in police custody April 19 after officers in Alameda County pinned him facedown on the ground for five minutes.

"From my point of view, it's heartbreaking to see my mother have to go through this," Gerardo Gonzalez said Wednesday. "She raised her firstborn and now she has to bury her firstborn."

Newly released body camera video shows police talking to Mario Gonzalez in a park after receiving 911 calls that he appeared to be disoriented or drunk. He struggled to answer questions.

"He seems like he's tweaking, but he's not doing anything wrong," a man told a 911 dispatcher, according to an audio recording released Tuesday. "He's just scaring my wife."

The Gonzalez family and its attorney, Julia Sherwin, said his death is eerily similar to that of George Floyd, who died in Minneapolis police custody May 25.

"These Alameda police officers killed Mario literally while the jury was debating Derek Chauvin's murder charges," Sherwin said Wednesday.

Mario Gonzalez died one day before Chauvin, a former Minneapolis police officer, was convicted of murdering Floyd by holding him to the pavement with his knee for 9 minutes, 29 seconds.

Chauvin's actions were widely rebuked by Minneapolis Police Chief Medaria Arradondo and several other veteran law enforcement officials who testified that police officers are trained to roll people on their sides as quickly as possible after they have been restrained in the prone position so as to not impair breathing.

Sherwin, a civil rights attorney experienced in cases in which people die in police custody, said she was sought out by Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison, whose office prosecuted Chauvin's case, and that she advised Ellison and special prosecutor Steve Schleicher for the trial.

She said there is an epidemic in America of police putting people prone on the ground and applying weight on their necks or their backs until they are unresponsive.

"What we're focused on is accountability for these officers and reform," she said, adding that Mario Gonzalez would still be alive had the officers been trained properly and not used excessive force.

"Horrible tactics grow out of horrible training," she said.

The initial police statement did not identify Mario Gonzalez by name. It said "a physical altercation ensued" when officers tried to detain him at the park in Alameda and that "the man had a medical emergency." The report said Gonzalez later died at a hospital. The language was similar to the Minneapolis Police Department's initial misleading and inaccurate description of what happened to Floyd, Sherwin said.

Without naming Floyd, a Minneapolis police news release posted on the police department's website and titled "Man Dies After Medical Incident During Police Interaction" had said he "physically resisted officers" on the scene who had ordered him out of his vehicle.

"Officers were able to get the suspect into handcuffs and noted he appeared to be suffering medical distress," the release said. It also said Floyd died "a short time later" at a hospital, which was refuted by the testimony of a world-renowned pulmonologist and other prosecution witnesses during the trial.

At a news conference Tuesday outside the Alameda Police Department, Gerardo Gonzalez said: "The police killed my brother in the same manner that they killed George Floyd."

"When we were first notified, we were told one story," he told NBC News on Wednesday. "Once we saw the actual footage, we reaffirmed that what they told us was not at all accurate."

What was shown in the video, he said, was that the officers' actions "could have been avoided if there was proper training or supervision."

Sherwin agreed, saying: "Mario was handcuffed for a long time and they're still pressing him to the ground as he's squirming lightly. That's totally inappropriate."

Mario Gonzalez's death is under investigation by the Alameda County Sheriff's Department, the county district attorney's office and a former San Francisco city attorney hired by the city to lead an independent probe, the city said in a statement.

The three officers involved in the arrest have been placed on paid leave during the investigation.

Gerardo Gonzalez said his brother had a 4-year-old son, whom he liked to play Fortnite with, and was the main caretaker of their brother, Efraim, who has autism and turned 23 this week.

"Mario was a humorous guy," he said. "He loved to crack jokes and have a good time."

Their mother, Edith Arenales, had already lost another son, Frank, who died at age 20 from undisclosed causes, Gerardo Gonzalez said.

"The fact that it's her second child, it makes the weight 10 times harder," he said.

Recommended Stories

  • Man dies after being pinned to the ground for five minutes by California police

    City of Alameda release 911 audio and body camera footage of police altercation

  • American Axle & Manufacturing (AXL) Gains As Market Dips: What You Should Know

    American Axle & Manufacturing (AXL) closed at $10.25 in the latest trading session, marking a +1.38% move from the prior day.

  • The Solutions Project's Mark Ruffalo and Gloria Walton on climate justice, focus on frontline

    In the “CBS This Morning” series “Eye on Earth: Our Planet in Peril" The Solution Project's Mark Ruffalo and Glora Walton speak about climate justice and why they are focusing on community organizations to solve the global challenge of climate change.

  • 4 Questions to Ask Before Applying for a New Credit Card

    If you fall into the latter camp and are thinking of adding another credit card to your collection, be sure to answer these important questions first. Applying for too many new credit cards within a short period of time can actually hurt your credit score, making it harder for you to borrow money when you need to. If it's only been a few weeks since you last applied for a credit card, you may want to sit tight for a while, as too many applications at once could be a red flag on your credit report.

  • Supreme Court wary of giving schools broad power to punish students' off-campus speech

    With technology changing the way teens communicate, the Supreme Court revisited a Vietnam-era First Amendment case about student speech.

  • In-custody death of Texas man ruled a homicide

    The medical examiner said Scott's death was caused by "fatal acute stress response in an individual with previously diagnosed schizophrenia during restraint struggle with law enforcement."

  • Letters to the Editor: L.A. handed over Union Station for the Oscars, and this is the thanks we get?

    The Oscars telecast should have given more of a shoutout to Metro and L.A. commuters for taking over the transit hub.

  • High Court to rule on Boris Johnson's decision to back Priti Patel in bullying row

    The High Court will rule on Boris Johnson’s decision to back Priti Patel for her alleged breach of ministerial rules over bullying claims. The court has decided to allow a full judicial review of Mr Johnson’s decision to disregard the findings of his adviser on ministerial standards to back the Home Secretary in the bullying row. Sir Alex Allan left his advisory role in Downing Street after Mr Johnson contradicted his advice by judging that Ms Patel did not breach the rules, despite being found to have bullied staff. At a hearing in London on Tuesday, the High Court’s Mr Justice Linden granted the civil service union, the First Division Association (FDA), permission for a full hearing of its judicial review claim. The FDA is challenging Mr Johnson's decision that Ms Patel's conduct did not breach the ministerial code. The case dates back to February last year when her permanent secretary Sir Philip Rutnam resigned and accused her of a "vicious and orchestrated" briefing campaign against him.

  • Rep. Karen Bass expects ‘uplifting message’ from Biden on policing in joint address to Congress

    President Joe Biden’s first joint address to members of Congress Wednesday evening is expected to focus on policing, climate change, racial equity and his whole of government approach to stimulate the economy — the American Rescue Plan. Don’t expect the same visuals as previous presidential addresses with President Biden’s speech to the joint session of Congress in the Well of the House.

  • The family of Mario Gonzalez says his death mirrors George Floyd's. Body camera footage of his arrest contradicts an initial police statement.

    Mario Gonzalez died on April 19 after officers held him to the ground for around five minutes. His family is comparing his death to George Floyd's.

  • Idaho lawmaker accused of sexual misconduct, his accuser testify at House ethics committee

    Rep. Aaron von Ehlinger refused to answer questions about the night of an alleged sexual assault under the Fifth Amendment.

  • Australian who filmed 4 dead and dying police sent to prison

    A speeding driver in Australia was sentenced to 10 months in prison on Wednesday for offenses including what a judge described as the ”heartless, cruel and disgraceful” filming of four dead and dying police officers who had just been hit by a truck on a freeway. Richard Pusey, a 42-year-old mortgage broker, had earlier pleaded guilty in the Victoria state County Court to a rarely-prosecuted charge of outraging public decency over his commentary in crash scene videos shot with his phone. The most serious charge he admitted was reckless conduct endangering persons, which carries a potential maximum of five years in prison.

  • US officer beaten by rioters condemns effort to ‘whitewash’ Capitol attack

    Police officer Michael Fanone injured in 6 January attack‘Very difficult seeing elected officials whitewash events’ More than three months on, the Capitol insurrection still casts a shadow over Washington. Photograph: Shannon Stapleton/Reuters A Washington police officer who was attacked by Trump-supporting rioters during the Capitol attack on 6 January has decried the efforts of some politicians and other public figures to “whitewash” and downplay the insurrection. Michael Fanone, 40, gave an emotional interview with CNN on Tuesday night in which he laid bare the personal impact of having been engulfed in the baying crowd. He was beaten with sticks and stun-gunned, and in the aftermath has struggled with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and what he called “psychological injuries”. Fanone said that since the riot, it had been “very difficult seeing elected officials and other individuals whitewash the events of that day or downplay what happened. Some of the terminology that has been used, like ‘hugs and kisses’ and ‘very fine people’ – very different from what I experienced and what my co-workers experienced on the 6th.” Though he did not mention the former president by name, Fanone was making a clear reference to Trump’s interview with Fox News last month in which he said the conflagration posed “zero threat”. Attempting an extreme makeover of history, Trump said of the rioters that “some of them went in, and they’re hugging and kissing the police and the guards, you know? They had great relationships.” Asked what he thought of Trump’s remarks, Fanone said: “I think it’s dangerous. It’s very much not the experience I had on the 6th. I experienced a group of individuals that were trying to kill me to accomplish their goals.” More than three months on, the Capitol insurrection still casts a shadow over Washington. Joe Biden is expected to discuss the attack and its lasting impact when he addresses a joint session of Congress for the first time as president on Wednesday, standing at the same podium in the House of Representatives that was defiled by rioters. The assault, and Trump’s efforts to diminish its anti-democratic and violent nature, where he encouraged supporters at a rally immediately prior to “fight” to stop Congress certifying Biden’s election victory, also continue to distort American politics. Kevin McCarthy, the House Republican leader, this week clung to his support for Trump and the lie that the 2020 election was stolen from him – rhetoric that directly instigated the insurrection. Adam Kinzinger, a congressman from Illinois who was one of only 10 Republicans who voted to impeach Trump in February for “incitement of insurrection”, challenged McCarthy. Kinzinger posted on Twitter a clip of Fanone on CNN, along with the barbed comment that he was curious whether the Republican leader had “an opinion about this interview”. Fanone was among a cordon of District of Columbia and Capitol police who were defending the edifice, where members of Congress were in session in both chambers, when Trump supporters ran amok. Photos from 6 January show the officer entirely surrounded by protesters lunging at him with wooden clubs. A video also captured him being pulled out of the building by the rioters and dragged down stairs. “I thought it was a distinct possibility I would die,” he told Lemon. “They started attacking me from all directions. Guys ripped my badge off, ripped my radio off, started grabbing at my firearm. It was overwhelming.”

  • Police respond to controversy over NC officer’s hand gesture in photo

    An image of a Graham, North Carolina, police officer’s hand gesture while speaking with Black Lives Matter protesters sparks controversy. But police dispute the interpretation.

  • Twilio (TWLO) Dips More Than Broader Markets: What You Should Know

    In the latest trading session, Twilio (TWLO) closed at $393.80, marking a -0.53% move from the previous day.

  • Biden's speech to pitch universal preschool, $4 trillion in economic spending

    The president is expected to unveil another part of his sweeping "Build Back Better" agenda that he campaigned on.

  • The Central Park Conservancy Heads to the Tennis Court

    Patrick McEnroe came out to support the charitable tournament, which raised over $155K for the park's 21 Playgrounds program.

  • Russian minister: US-Russia ties worse than during Cold War

    Russia's top diplomat said Wednesday that relations with the United States are now even worse than during Cold War times because of a lack of mutual respect. Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov said Moscow stands ready to normalize ties with Washington but that the U.S. should stop posturing like a “sovereign” while rallying its allies against Russia and China. Lavrov said if the U.S. shuns a mutually respectful dialogue on the basis of a balance of interests, “we would live in conditions of a Cold War or worse."

  • Columbia, USC police search for person who sexually assaulted a woman near campus

    Have you seen this person? Police are asking for any tips and information on the sexual assault that happened near USC’s campus and Five Points.

  • 3 men charged with federal hate crimes in killing of Ahmaud Arbery in Georgia

    Arbery was killed while jogging during an encounter with Travis McMichael, 35, his father, Gregory McMichael, 65, and William "Roddie" Bryan, 51, last year.