Tucker Carlson is uncancelable

  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.
Bonnie Kristian
·2 min read
  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.

Fox News host Tucker Carlson isn't going anywhere.

You might expect him to, given his sudden, strange laughs mid-broadcast — the sort of thing that could have taken him off air for a while in the "Dean scream" era. Or you might think he'd resign over a college yearbook image circulating in which a much younger Carlson appears to make an inside joke about the assassinations of San Francisco Mayor George Macone and Supervisor Harvey Milk, the latter of whom was California's first openly gay elected official.

You'd be wrong. We're in a weird space, culturally, with public shaming and what used to be called "gaffes." I think there's something real to the charge of "cancel culture," though the concept is much abused. Yet, as New York Times columnist Ross Douthat observed in 10 theses on the subject, its threat "is most effective against people who are still rising in their fields." For those who have reached the top, particularly in politics, the threat is increasingly empty.

Indeed, in that elite realm — which obviously includes Carlson, for all his railing against the elite — we're rapidly approaching a point where anything short of tattooing Nazi symbols on your face on live television is not disqualifying for anyone willing and able to ignore the haters for a few weeks or months. Memories are short. Forced resignations aren't what they once were. Now, you can just refuse to be embarrassed and keep on trucking. Former President Donald Trump was a big part of this shift, but so are Democratic Govs. Ralph Northam (Va.) and Andrew Cuomo (N.Y.), who have steadfastly refused to resign after major public scandals.

Carlson, who last year had the highest-rated program in cable news history and is a rumored 2024 GOP contender (he denies interest), will do the same. The playbook is very simple. He's already using it, just as he has with scandals past. When his show's lead writer resigned after getting caught writing pseudonymous, racist posts online, Carlson took a vacation he said was "long-planned," then simply moved on from the subject. This month, he walked up to the line of advocating "replacement theory," then doubled down, with network support.

This is just opposition research, he'll tell his fans of the yearbook. Our shared enemies are attacking me because I'm telling the truth, and because they hate you. It's all tribal. It's all dishonest. It's all games. It's all irrelevant. And it will be.

More stories from theweek.com
7 cartoons about Derek Chauvin being found guilty
CNN's Dr. Sanjay Gupta says vaccinated people can generally go maskless outdoors, with some caveats
Joe Manchin lives on a boat in Washington — and protesters are reportedly headed there

Recommended Stories

  • Tucker Carlson’s College Yearbook Says He Belonged to Club for Harvey Milk’s Murderer

    He also referenced the Jesse Helms Foundation, named for the staunchly anti-gay conservative senator Fox News host Tucker Carlson identified himself as being part of the “Dan White Society” in his 1991 Trinity College yearbook entry. Dan White was the name of the man who killed San Francisco Mayor George Moscone and Supervisor Harvey Milk, California’s first openly gay elected official, in 1978. A representative for Trinity College confirmed the veracity of the yearbook entry to TheWrap after a screenshot of it went viral on Twitter. The spokesperson pointed to a digitized version of the yearbook, which features the entry on page 186, and added that the so-called “society” didn’t seem to exist at the school and was only mentioned in Carlson’s entry. A review of the yearbook by TheWrap found no other mentions of a “Dan White Society.” “While I cannot speak to the yearbook process in 1991, current practice is that only a student’s name, home state and/or country, and the student’s major are listed with their photos,” the Trinity College representative said when asked whether Carlson submitted the identifier himself. Also Read: Tucker Carlson: Jurors Only Convicted Chauvin Because They Were Scared (Video) A Fox News representative did not immediately return a request for comment. Among the other affiliations listed in Carlson’s entry are “Christian Fellowship” and the Jesse Helms Foundation, which bills itself as “a non-profit, non-political foundation which provides quality educational lectures, training schools and events focused on the principles of our founding fathers, traditional American values and the causes which United States Senator Jesse Helms championed throughout his 30-year career.” Helms was a leader in the conservative movement and, according to a 2008 obituary, was staunchly opposed to homosexuality. For much of his career, Helms opposed federal spending on AIDS on the grounds that he believed the disease was the result of homosexual behavior. Helms’ legacy also included opposition to the civil rights movement and abortion rights, and a 16-day filibuster against establishing Martin Luther King Jr. Day as a federal holiday. On Tuesday night, Carlson accused The Washington Post’s owner, Jeff Bezos, of conducting “opposition research” and said the Post’s media columnist, Erik Wemple, was pulling out his old college yearbook to see if Carlson had “done anything naughty at the age of 19.” Also Read: Lachlan Murdoch Stands by Tucker Carlson After Anti-Defamation League Calls for His Firing “Jeff Bezos had one of his minions, a mentally unbalanced middle-aged man called Erik Wemple, pull our dusty college yearbook and call around and see if we’d done anything naughty at the age of 19,” Carlson said on “Tucker Carlson Tonight.” “That sounds like fun. Let us know if you hear any good stories. But before Bezos drops any more of his billions on opposition research, he should know that it will not affect any election outcome. This is a news show, not a political campaign. No one here is running for anything or plans to.” A spokesperson for the Post declined to comment. It’s not yet clear what exactly the Dan White Society was or whether Carlson will address this latest controversy during his 8 p.m. ET show Wednesday night. What is clear, however, is that Carlson believes inappropriate old yearbook content is fair game for criticism: In 2020, he called Virginia Governor Ralph Northam “Governor Klan Robes Blackface,” referring to a previously uncovered set of yearbook photos showing the then-student in a Ku Klux Klan costume and blackface. Read original story Tucker Carlson’s College Yearbook Says He Belonged to Club for Harvey Milk’s Murderer At TheWrap

  • ‘What The Hell Was That?’ Jimmy Kimmel Spots Tucker Carlson's Most Unsettling Habit

    The late-night host noticed that the Fox News personality has a disturbing on-air tic.

  • Perpetual pandemic? COVID rules remain in some states despite vaccinations

    Fox News medical contributor Dr. Marc Siegel reports on the pace of vaccinations and some states keeping restrictions in effect.

  • Tucker Carlson sardonically claims Democrats will 'allow children to stab each other'

    Tucker Carlson went on a lengthy, sarcastic diatribe to kick off Tucker Carlson Tonight Thursday, mischaracterizing Democrats and the media as showing anti-police bias following the shooting death of 16-year-old Ma’Khia Bryant in Columbus, Ohio on Tuesday. Not long before guilty verdicts were handed down in the Derek Chauvin trial for the murder of George Floyd, a Columbus police officer shot and killed Bryant, who was attacking another young woman with a knife. The Columbus Police Department quickly released body camera footage showing as much. While some prominent Democrats and media personalities condemned the officer, many more have come to his defense. Carlson failed to mention those who came to the officer’s defense at any point in the diatribe. “At a triumphant press conference yesterday, leading Democrats unveiled their findings which are now a plank in the party's platform. They are going to allow children to stab each other,” Carlson said, with a graphic reading “Let The Kids Knife Fight” over his shoulder. “Now, stabbing people has long been taboo in this country, especially for those under the age of 18. For decades young Americans have hidden their switchblades, their stilettos, their Ka-Bars, their machetes. Kids were forced to live as if plunging blades into strangers was something to be ashamed of, instead of a normal, healthy part of childhood, but no more.”

  • White House responds to Thursday's stock-market drop: 'It went back up this morning'

    White House press secretary Jen Psaki on Friday offered a response to the U.S. stock market's drop on Thursday, which was widely attributed to reports that the Biden administration was considering a hike in capital-gains taxes. "I've been doing this long enough not to comment on movements in the stock market, but I did see just data factually that it went back up this morning," Psaki told reporters, following a question on the decline.

  • Putin foe Navalny to end prison hunger strike on 24th day

    Imprisoned opposition leader Alexei Navalny said Friday he is ending his hunger strike after getting medical attention and being warned by his doctors that continuing it would put his life at risk. In an Instagram post on the 24th day of his hunger strike, Navalny said he will continue to demand a visit from his doctor to address numbness in his legs and arms -– his main demand. “Thanks to the huge support of good people across the country and around the world, we have made huge progress,” Navalny said in his message from behind bars.

  • U.S. govt stops funding for late-stage study of Inovio's COVID-19 vaccine

    Inovio Pharmaceuticals said on Friday the U.S. government had stopped funding for a late-stage study testing its COVID-19 vaccine candidate, due to the increasing availability of authorized shots in the country. "This decision is not a reflection of the awardee or product, rather a fast-moving environment associated with the former Operation Warp Speed on decisions related to future products," the U.S. Department of Defense told Inovio, according to a company statement. The department will continue to fund an ongoing mid-stage study testing its vaccine candidate INO-4800, Inovio said.

  • Bill to purge early voting list unexpectedly fails in GOP-controlled Arizona Senate

    A bill designed to change how Arizona's early voting list works was voted down in the Republican-led state Senate where it was originally expected to pass. SB 1485, would have dissolved the word "permanent" from references to the state's early voting list, ultimately removing people from the list if they did not use it to vote within a certain time period. It failed in the Republican-controlled Senate Thursday on a vote of 14-16.

  • Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene Admits She Hasn't Even Read The Proposal She Keeps Attacking

    Greene was ridiculed online for saying she would read "all 14 pages" of the Green New Deal.

  • The clumsy punishment of a high-ranking NC Republican woman

    For a party that has some problems with women, it wasn’t a good look.

  • Late night hosts preview Biden's climate summit, mock Tucker Carlson's Chauvin meltdown, tackle deer cloning

    "Tomorrow, President Biden and 40 other world leaders are kicking off a big virtual climate summit," Jimmy Fallon said on Wednesday's Tonight Show. "They're meeting virtually because of the pandemic, otherwise they would have flown 40 different private jets to a meeting about the climate. The guest list includes Vladimir Putin, Bill Gates, Pope Francis, and one very stressed-out IT guy." The Late Late Show's James Corden, after wishing the queen a happy birthday, tried to make a joke about Biden cutting hot air emissions, and it mostly went nowhere. Los Angeles once again has the dirtiest air in the country, Jimmy Kimmel said on Kimmel Live. "All the benefits of us not driving during the pandemic were wiped out by the wildfires caused by climate change, which was caused by all the driving we did before the pandemic. It's what you call a Catch 2022." Lots of people spoke out after a Minneapolis jury convicted Derek Chauvin of murdering George Floyd, Kimmel said, "but none spoke less eloquently than Tucker Carlson of Fox News," who "had a little explosion in his head" when a guest unexpectedly criticized Chauvin. MyPillow guy Mike Lindell, a Kimmel Live guest next week, "he's bananas all the time, he's consistent," Kimmel said. "Tucker Carlson just lets little bursts of it slip out, like the Joker or something. Meanwhile, the Penguin, Chris Christie, may be throwing his top hat in the ring." Christie "thinks he might do well in the polls, as long as None of the Above doesn't run again," Seth Meyers joked at Late Night. After the Chauvin denouement, "Tucker Carlson claimed the jury was intimidated into the guilty verdict by the protests and the Black Lives Matter movement — which is frustrating for Carlson, because he put a lot of work into intimidating that jury." Meanwhile, "there's big science news out of Texas, where a Republican state legislator wants to legalize deer cloning," so ranchers can breed bigger hunting prey, Stephen Colbert noted at The Late Show. "One Texas rancher says he's cloned somewhere between 35 and 40 deer over the past decade. So, there are a bunch of deer clones out there already? You know what this means? Texas is about to open Deerasic Park. 'Don't move, or they'll nibble your hydrangeas!'" The Late Show also turned that story into an animated Bambi Returns: The Clone Wars. Watch below. More stories from theweek.com7 cartoons about Derek Chauvin being found guiltyCNN's Dr. Sanjay Gupta says vaccinated people can generally go maskless outdoors, with some caveatsJoe Manchin lives on a boat in Washington — and protesters are reportedly headed there

  • Internal Facebook report highlights shortcomings ahead of Capitol riot

    Despite public comments from executives downplaying Facebook's role in the planning for the Jan. 6 insurrection, an internal report leaked to BuzzFeed News concluded that the company failed to adequately deal with extremists who gathered online and planned the assault on the Capitol.Why it matters: Social networks continue to be both a significant source of misinformation as well as a gathering place for advocates of violence.Stay on top of the latest market trends and economic insights with Axios Markets. Subscribe for freeThe report, which was authored by an internal task force and shared with Facebook employees, concluded that a number of groups involved in the planning of the Capitol assault gathered on Facebook, continuing to coordinate their plans even after Facebook banned the official Stop the Steal group.Between the lines: The findings contrast with statements made by CEO Mark Zuckerberg and COO Sheryl Sandberg, which have suggested that most of the significant planning for the uprisings took place on other platforms."Hindsight is 20/20, at the time, it was very difficult to know whether what we were seeing was a coordinated effort to delegitimize the election, or whether it was free expression by users who were afraid and confused and deserved our empathy. But hindsight being 20/20 makes it all the more important to look back to learn what we can about the growth of the election delegitimizing movements that grew, spread conspiracy, and helped incite the Capitol insurrection."Facebook's internal report, per BuzzFeedWhat they're saying: Facebook confirmed the report is genuine but said it doesn't represent the company's "definitive post-mortem report." The company also maintains that the report doesn't contradict Sandberg or Zuckerberg since both acknowledged that Facebook's systems weren't perfect."As we’ve said previously, we still saw problematic content on our platform during this period and we know that we didn’t catch everything," Facebook said.Our thought bubble: In the wake of foreign interference in the 2016 election, Facebook and other social networks centered many of their safety efforts around "coordinated inauthentic behavior" — manipulation of content on their platforms by people who hid or falsified their identities. However, in this case, the threat was real people spreading misinformation and planning violence.More from Axios: Sign up to get the latest market trends with Axios Markets. Subscribe for free

  • Penei Sewell on draft expectations

    Sports Pulse: Penei Sewell on Justin Herbert and the noise going into the draft

  • Noise concerns or ‘anti-Muslim’ bias? Mississippi city mosque rejection raises eyebrows

    “This is what this country was built on, freedom of religion.”

  • 14 Oscar-winning movies that haven't stood the test of time

    The 93rd annual Academy Awards will take place on Sunday, April 25. We took a look back at the most glaring missteps in Oscars history.

  • ‘We tried to stop it’: Trump officials reveal what really happened with bleach-gate on its year anniversary

    ‘I lost, and it went how it did,’ says one former aide

  • Cop seen punching teen with autism in California video. ‘Disturbing,’ boy’s dad says

    “He said he always thought they were there to help and he doesn’t feel like that anymore,” the boy’s father said.

  • Biden will unveil eye-popping new tax rates for wealthiest Americans

    President Biden in the next few days will unveil eye-popping new tax rates for the wealthiest Americans —a top marginal income tax rate of 39.6% and a capital gains rate of 43.4%.Why it matters: The proposal, to be announced ahead of Biden's address to Congress next Wednesday, is an opening bid for Hill negotiations.Get market news worthy of your time with Axios Markets. Subscribe for free."For New Yorkers, the combined state and federal capital gains rate could be as high as 52.22%. For Californians, it could be 56.7%," Bloomberg News reported.The Dow closed down more than 300 points after the plans leaked.Practically and politically, the White House needs buy-in from Congress to pay for social spending in the next phase of his plan to reshape the American economy, the American Families Plan.Between the lines: Democrats close to the White House believe that the amount of revenue that the IRS can collect on capital gains actually decreases past a certain point, probably in the low 30% range. That means the ultimate capital gains rate could be well below 43.4%Officials haven't yet made clear whether the capital gains rate would apply in 2022 — or in 2021, which would allow the IRS to harness some of this year's massive equities earnings.Goldman Sachs sent out a research note last evening entitled, “No Surprises in President Biden’s Reported Capital Gains Proposal.": "We expect Congress will pass a scaled back version of this tax increase." What we're watching: Biden also is likely to raise more revenue from the wealthy by making changes to estate taxes.Biden wants to change the so-called "stepped up basis" for accounting purposes, and value assets when they are passed on to an heir, not at their original cost.The White House thinks that change could lead more individuals to liquidate assets before they die, allowing the IRS to tax them then instead of encouraging families to keep passing on them for more favorable tax treatment. Editor's note: This story has been corrected to reflect that Biden wants to value estates at how much they are worth when they change hands and remove the so-called "stepped up basis."More from Axios: Sign up to get the latest market trends with Axios Markets. Subscribe for free

  • A deadly fight 33 years ago shows just how destructive a war between the US and Iran could get

    Operation Praying Mantis, the largest US naval action since World War II, offers a glimpse of what a US-Iran war could look like now.

  • The ex-convict's tale: Germany's role in Wirecard scandal under microscope

    In February 2019, after a steep drop in Wirecard's share price, German authorities launched criminal probes into short-sellers and journalists who had accused the company of fraud, and banned investors from betting against the company. Documents seen by Reuters show for the first time that the only independent information - beyond Wirecard's representations - received by Munich prosecutors who launched the criminal probes was a third-hand account of events from a convicted money launderer, Daniel James Harris. The rationale that led to the decisions of prosecutors and regulators to launch the criminal probes and short-selling ban, and whether they were overzealous in supporting Wirecard, are central issues being investigated by a parliamentary inquiry into the company's collapse in Germany's biggest post-war fraud scandal.