Prashant Kishor, Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee's election strategist, has said in a Clubhouse chat that the Bharatiya Janata Party is winning in the West Bengal Assembly election. Prashant Kishor is also heard saying that PM Narendra Modi is hugely popular in West Bengal. According to Prashant Kishor, this is one of the three factors which would decide which party sweeps the state.
Amit Malviya, BJP IT cell head, shared the purported conversation of Prashant Kishor in an open Clubhouse organised by a journalist where the poll strategist is purportedly heard discussing a TMC survey that shows the BJP is winning Bengal in the 2021 West Bengal Assembly election.
The audio bomb was released by the BJP as the state is voting in the fourth phase of the West Bengal Assembly election, triggering several from the saffron party going ballistic over the comment. The TMC's election has just been thrown away, Amit Malviya said. West Bengal Phase 4 Voting LIVE Updates
Tweeting several excerpts of the audio, Amit Malviya tweeted saying Prashant Kishor has conceded TMC's defeat in the West Bengal polls, according to TMC's internal survey.
DALITS, MATHUAS VOTING FOR BJP: PRASHANT KISHOR IN LEAKED AUDIO
In the leaked audio, tweeted by Amit Malviya and Tajinder Singh Bagga and several other BJP leaders, Prashant Kishor is heard saying that PM Modi is as popular in West Bengal as CM Mamata Banerjee.
"Agar vote hain toh Modi ke naam par vote hai, Hindu hone ke naam par vote hai, polarisation, Modi, Hindibhasi, SC, yeh factors hain [If there are votes, they are in the name of Modi [PM], and being a Hiindu; the factors in this election are polarisation, Modi, SC [votes]"
Prashant Kishor is also heard saying that factors such as Suvendu Adhikari's exit from the Trinamool Congress and him advising Mamata Banerjee for the West Bengal polls will have little impact in this election. Rather, Dalits and the Mathua communities specifically voting for the BJP is a very important factor," Prashant Kishor said.
"Suvendu [Adhikari] chale gaye ya Prashant chale aaye, uska koie mudda nahi hai. Modi yahan popular hai...Dalit yahan par 27% hai, aur woh poori tarah se BJP ke saath khada hai. [The state has 27 per cent Dalits and they are all voting for the BJP]. Plus, there's polarisation," Prashant Kishor is heard saying in the leaked audio.
In a public chat on Club House, Mamata Banerjee's election strategist concedes that even in TMC's internal surveys, BJP is winning.
— Amit Malviya (@amitmalviya) April 10, 2021
The vote is for Modi, polarisation is a reality, the SCs (27% of WB's population), Matuas are all voting for the BJP!
BJP has cadre on ground. pic.twitter.com/3ToYuvWfRm
MODI, MAMATA EQUALLY POPULAR: PRASHANT KISHOR
Prashant Kishor also goes on to concede that the BJP has cadre on the ground who are dedicated to the saffron party and "PM Narendra Modi and CM Mamata Banerjee are equally popular" in West Bengal.
When asked why is PM Modi popular in West Bengal, Prashant Kishor says: "There's a cult around Modi across the country. There is a certain percentage of people who see God in Modi. In Bengal, the Hindi-speaking population is the core of Modi's support base. The anti-incumbency is against the state government, not the Centre."
ANGER TOWARDS TMC, MODI POPULAR, SAYS PRASHANT KISHOR
"Modi is also popular because Bengal has not yet had a taste of the BJP. That's a factor. People think that BJP will do something that they haven't seen in the past 30 years. There's anger towards Trinamool Congress, that's a factor," Prashant Kishor said in the audio tweeted by Tajinder Singh Bagga.
Didi's Political Campaign Head PK accepting Defeat here pic.twitter.com/yFwudPjJbD
— Tajinder Pal Singh Bagga (@TajinderBagga) April 10, 2021
The session called ‘Bright Wing’ took place on Clubhouse late Friday. Notably, the Clubhouse app does not allow recording of conversations. Since it was an open forum, the conversation between the journalists and Prashant Kishor was recorded on another phone. The BJP released the audio on Saturday morning.
ECSTATIC BJP LEADERS REACT
Tweeting the content of the audio, senior BJP leader Amit Malviya claimed that Prashant Kishor has conceded even TMC's internal surveys show that the saffron party was winning West Bengal.
"...Mamata Banerjee's election strategist concedes that even in TMC's internal surveys, BJP is winning. The vote is for Modi, polarisation is a reality, the SCs (27% of WB's population), Matuas are all voting for the BJP! BJP has cadre on ground. Another candid admission by Mamata Banerjee's election strategist - all that the Left, Congress and TMC ecosystem have done in the last 20 years is Muslim appeasement. Implication? It has resulted in resentment on ground. The speakers had not realised that the chat was public!" Amit Malviya said.
Another candid admission by Mamata Banerjee's election strategist - all that the Left, Congress and TMC ecosystem have done in the last 20 years is Muslim appeasement.
— Amit Malviya (@amitmalviya) April 10, 2021
Implication? It has resulted to resentment on ground. The speakers had not realised that the chat was public! pic.twitter.com/2kyLsQXYyi
Modi is hugely popular in Bengal and there is no doubt about it. There is a cult around him across the country.
— Amit Malviya (@amitmalviya) April 10, 2021
There is anti-incumbency against TMC, polarisation is a reality, SC votes is a factor plus BJP's election machinery, says Mamata Banerjee's strategist in an open chat. pic.twitter.com/Vrl8vl231b
"Narendra Modi ji is famous throughout the world. Prashant Kishor has done the work of putting the last nail in the coffin, finishing TMC," said BJP Cooch Behar MP Nisith Pramanik.
BJP leader Locket Chatterjee said, "Prashant Kishor also knows that Modi ji is the best and a 'sonar Bangla' will be made under his leadership. But to fool the people he got associated with TMC."
"Prashant Kishor's strategy will not work in Bengal, his strategy has failed. TMC has finished here. In Bengal, only Narendra Modi's strategy will work," said West Bengal BJP leader Rajib Banerjee.
Amit Malviya said Prashant Kishor did not know it was an open platform and as soon as the poll strategist realised it, "deafening silence followed".
Is it open?
— Amit Malviya (@amitmalviya) April 10, 2021
That moment when Mamata Banerjee's strategiest realised that the Club House room was open and his admissions were being heard by the public at large and not just a handful of Lutyens journalist.
Deafening silence followed...
TMC's election was just thrown away! pic.twitter.com/2XJ4RWbv3K
Prashant Kishor has, however, said that he knew it was a public platform and challenged the BJP to release the full transcript of the conversation. Prashant Kishor gave a nuanced explanation of his words, saying they were in response to a question on “how BJP is getting 40 per cent of the vote and why there is a perception the BJP is winning”.
PRASHANT KISHOR CLARIFIES...
Responding to BJP's claims, Prashant Kishor took to Twitter to say that the BJP released only a selective part of it. Reiterating that the BJP will not cross more than 100 seats on West Bengal, Prashant Kishor took a dig at the BJP saying the party takes his words more seriously than its own leaders.
"I am glad BJP is taking my chat more seriously than words of their own leaders!? They should show courage & share the full chat instead of getting excited with selective use of parts of it. I have said this before & repeating again - BJP will not to CROSS 100 in WB. Period," Prashant Kishor tweeted.
Speaking with India Today TV, Prashant Kishor challenged the BJP to release the entire clip. He said there was nothing wrong in what he said. "I also said BJP won't cross 100, why aren't they playing that? I had full knowledge it was a public platform."
He said, "With regards to the selective and distorted use of part of the conversation, I urge them to release the full conversation. For example, this was said in response to the question - ..."how BJP is getting about 40% vote and why there is a perception that BJP is winning."