Many Illinois residents getting COVID-19 vaccine envy as nearby states expand eligibility more quickly

Angie Leventis Lourgos, Joe Mahr and Lisa Schencker, Chicago Tribune
·10 min read

CHICAGO — Carolyn Kritzer of Munster, Indiana, recently booked an appointment for her first dose of COVID-19 vaccine and described the process as “seamless.”

Once eligible, the 58-year-old went to her state’s centralized online system, typed in her information and secured a time slot in a matter of minutes. In contrast, her co-worker Ruth Mares — a 60-year-old essential worker who lives just a few miles over the state border in south suburban Lansing, Illinois — has been constantly checking and refreshing a variety of local pharmacy and health care websites, with no luck in finding an appointment so far.

The women are roughly the same age, work in the same field and live minutes from one another. Yet they’re navigating entirely different state processes and rules, with disparate results.

Mares believes that if her home were a few miles east in Indiana ― which has a predominantly age-based approach and recently began vaccinating all residents 45 or older — she would be immunized by now.

“I would have already been done with it,” she said.

With potentially lifesaving vaccine still in short supply, many Illinois residents have looked longingly at nearby states ― some with a reportedly easier process for making appointments, others that expanded eligibility or lowered age restrictions at a more rapid pace.

Indiana in early March opened criteria to those 50 or older, and then on Tuesday dropped the age requirement to 45 and up. Iowa’s governor recently announced that all Iowans might be eligible to get the shot on April 5, if supply expectations are met.

And Ohio on Friday expanded eligibility to those 40 years old and up, as well as patients with some high-risk medical conditions; by the end of March, all residents over the age of 16 are expected to be eligible.

This may have induced some vaccine envy among Illinois residents, even as their own state plans to widen criteria, albeit not as quickly: Gov. J.B. Pritzker announced earlier this week that vaccination eligibility will be expanded to all Illinois residents outside of Chicago by April 12. Other professions like higher education staff, government workers and media will be vaccine-eligible on Monday as well, according to state officials.

Yet some public health experts caution that expanded eligibility doesn’t automatically equate to mass vaccination success because there are so many factors at play, from the overall number of doses administered to equity of distribution to care for the most vulnerable populations.

Just because different groups or more people are eligible, that doesn’t necessarily mean more individuals are getting immunized.

In fact, Illinois has been slightly faster at getting shots into arms than Indiana and Ohio ― two of the states that opened up age tiers sooner. The latest data shows Illinois administered nearly 36 shots for every 100 residents. Ohio’s rate is 34, and Indiana’s is 33, according to a Tribune analysis of data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

But there’s one notable difference between the states: who is getting prioritized for the shots. Ohio and Indiana have been among the fastest states in getting doses in the arms of senior citizens, a population at greater risk of contracting and dying from the virus.

Half of senior citizens in Indiana are fully vaccinated now, with Ohio at 41%. Illinois, in comparison, has just 36% of its seniors fully vaccinated, according to the latest CDC data.

Another way to look at it: In Indiana, senior citizens are nine times more likely to be fully vaccinated than a resident there under age 65. In Illinois, despite also being in an early priority group, seniors are just four times more likely be fully vaccinated than someone under 65. (The national median is five times.)

While older residents were prioritized in Indiana, some professions had earlier access to the shots in Illinois. For example, teachers have been getting immunized in Illinois for weeks now. Indiana just began vaccinating teachers and other school employees across the state in mid-March; before, they could only get shots at pharmacies participating in a federal program.

Illinois residents over 45 could assume Hoosiers get the better deal in terms of vaccine prioritization. But a younger educator in Indiana might disagree.

The perception that one state is doing better than another can be misleading, because leaders are trying to balance a variety of competing public health priorities, said Dr. Thomas Tsai, assistant professor in the Department of Health Policy and Management at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health.

There’s an urgency to get shots in arms as quickly as possible in a race against emerging COVID-19 variants, Tsai said. At the same time, immunizations need to go to those most at risk of contracting the virus and dying from it. Distributing should be equitable to all races and income levels, and shots have to get to rural and urban areas alike.

“It’s more complicated because we can’t boil it down to one single metric,” Tsai said. “There needs to be a dashboard of metrics. We need a grade-point average instead of just a grade.”

While vaccine rollout in Illinois was initially sluggish compared with most other states, the pace has since greatly improved.

As of Friday, Illinois was roughly in the middle of the pack, ranking 26th among all states for per capita doses administered, according to a Tribune analysis of CDC data. And it ranked first among the 10 most populated states.

Illinois is also slightly ahead of the national averages on three key metrics: percentage of the adult population with first doses, percentage with both doses, and the efficiency of administering the shots ― the ratio of doses administered compared with the doses available, said William Galston, senior fellow in governance studies at The Brookings Institution.

“States that are doing a good job of administering the doses have a high efficiency rate, and Illinois is now a couple points above the national average,” he said. “Which doesn’t put Illinois in the top tier, but it isn’t a disaster area either.”

This comparison can be complicated because each state has established its own hierarchy of priorities, rules and systems.

“Those are policy decisions that states have made in 50 different ways,” Galston said.

While it’s still too early to draw definitive conclusions, he said states that have had greater vaccination success tended to use a more simplified and centralized process. Galston added that mass inoculation centers also “can speed things up.”

“Statewide, single-point-of-entry websites work better than a bewildering variety of local, institution-specific sites,” he said.

Illinois health officials credit the recent catch-up in part to the launch of numerous state-supported mass vaccination sites, as well as dozens of mobile teams that vaccinate underserved communities.

“Illinois entered phase 1b after some other states because we have a large number of health care workers and long-term care facilities and we wanted to ensure those were fully covered before moving on,” said Melaney Arnold, spokeswoman for the Illinois Department of Public Health. “Once we entered phase 1b, our numbers improved.”

She added that the state also continues to monitor the number of doses providers have in their inventories to make sure they’re going into arms and not sitting on shelves.

Pritzker spokeswoman Jordan Abudayyeh said the state has largely been following guidelines from the CDC’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices in deciding who to include in each phase.

Beyond prioritizing senior citizens, the guidelines don’t make distinctions by age but instead by profession and medical history, she said.

“We’ve asked for federal frameworks for a year, and now that we have them, we’re following them as closely as possible,” Abudayyeh said.

While expanded eligibility might elicit hope for those eager to get vaccinated, some medical experts fear that widening criteria too quickly could leave behind the most vulnerable groups.

Many states were relatively slow to move past the first vaccination phase, which focused on health care workers and residents of long-term care facilities, said Dr. William Parker, assistant director of the MacLean Center for Clinical Medical Ethics at University of Chicago Medicine and an ICU doctor.

Now that vaccine distribution has picked up in Illinois and across the country, Parker worries about states moving too far in the other direction.

Alaska earlier this month expanded eligibility to anyone over 16 living or working in the state. Mississippi opened vaccinations to all residents on March 16. Anyone over 16 in Nevada will be eligible to get the shot as of April 5. All were well ahead of President Joe Biden’s May 1 deadline to have every adult nationwide vaccine-eligible.

But there could be unintended consequences if states simply give the vaccine to anyone in additional, younger age groups while supply is still limited, Parker said.

“You’ll end up prioritizing people who are quite low risk,” he said.

Policymakers should instead be prioritizing people in hard-hit neighborhoods, something Chicago has been doing through its Protect Chicago Plus plan, which targets high-risk communities in the city for vaccinations, he said.

Ensuring people in hard-hit areas get vaccinated before low-risk people is more equitable and it better helps to control the spread of the virus as well as prevent deaths and hospitalizations, he said.

“Pour water where the fire is burning,” he said.

It made sense for Illinois to first allow health care workers to be vaccinated, followed by seniors and people with health conditions, he said.

But Parker believes it’s been a “policy failure” that the Chicago area hasn’t received as many vaccines per person as some other areas of the state; Chicago has been vaccinating many people who don’t live in the city, and that should be taken into account when it’s decided how many doses the city should be getting.

“Before we open it up to everyone and make it first come, first served to all people across the state, the areas that are lagging behind need to get supply,” Parker said. “It would be really sad if we’re vaccinating healthy 19-year-olds in (Downstate) Adams County when my (patients with) high-risk conditions on the South Side of Chicago can’t get a shot.”

The CDC doesn’t publish data on race and ethnicity, and measuring that can be tricky because some states are better than others at collecting the race and ethnicity of those getting shots. That said, a look at each state’s website shows slightly more Black and Hispanic residents in Illinois have been vaccinated compared with some neighboring states that are expanding eligibility earlier.

In Illinois, as of Wednesday, 6.9% of Black residents had been fully vaccinated, based on a Tribune analysis of vaccination and census data. In Indiana, that rate is 6.5%, and in Ohio it’s 5.8%.

As for Hispanic residents, Illinois again leads both states, with 6.3% of Hispanics fully vaccinated, compared with 4.2% in Ohio and 4.0% in Indiana.

And, at least from what’s filled out in vaccination records, Illinois also leads those two states in white residents fully vaccinated: 16% of white residents in Illinois, compared with 15% in Indiana and 13% in Ohio.

Eligibility also only opens the possibility of getting immunized ― and those familiar with navigating access point out that just because more individuals meet criteria, that doesn’t necessarily ensure the process becomes any easier or supply will increase to meet demand.

On social media sites, the news that vaccine eligibility will be expanding to most residents of Illinois was met with both praise and skepticism.

“Yay!” one woman commented on Facebook. “Thank you Gov. Pritzker.”

Others suggested that opening up the process to more people doesn’t automatically equate to better access ― or more shots in arms.

“He can make everyone 16 and older eligible today, and it wouldn’t change a thing,” a local man posted on the same site. “Actually being able to get vaccine appointments will still be like looking for a needle in a haystack.”

———

(Chicago Tribune reporter Dan Petrella contributed.)

Recommended Stories

  • These 8 States Just Said Every Adult Can Get a Vaccine Now—Or ASAP

    With stages of eligibility for a COVID-19 vaccine differing state by state, you might be wondering, when can you get yours? So far, every adult in Alaska and Mississippi are already able to book appointments. Now, eight more states have said they’d open up eligibility for adults over 16, accelerating their timeframes. Read on—and to ensure your health and the health of others, don't miss these Sure Signs You've Already Had Coronavirus. 1 Ohio Anyone over 16 will be allowed to seek shots starting March 29. "This is an example of Ohio at its finest—citizens coming together to help ensure that all Ohioans, no matter where they live, have access to the vaccine," said Governor DeWine. "Today is a monumental day. With every shot, Ohio is moving closer to recovery." 2 Connecticut “Governor Ned Lamont today announced that he is accelerating Connecticut’s age-based rollout of the COVID-19 vaccine to proceed on a quicker schedule than was originally anticipated when it was announced last month,” according to a statement. “The revised schedule, which tentatively plans for the vaccine to expand to all adults over the age of 16 by April 5, comes as the state was informed by the Biden administration that it should anticipate receiving a significant increase in supplies of all three federally authorized vaccines over the next several weeks.” 3 Illinois “Governor Pritzker and Illinois Department of Public Health (IDPH) Director Dr. Ngozi Ezike today announced a metrics-based, vaccination-informed framework for Illinois to advance to Phase 5 of the state's Restore Illinois Plan, our new normal,” said a statement. “In recognition of an increasing national vaccine supply and the state now averaging 100,000 vaccine administrations per day, Governor Pritzker also announced that all Illinois residents age 16+ will be eligible for the COVID-19 vaccine starting April 12th, with additional announcements to come about populations who will be made eligible prior to universal eligibility.” 4 Kentucky “On Thursday, Gov. Andy Beshear announced all Kentuckian 50 and older can sign up for COVID-19 vaccination appointments on or after March 22. He said all Kentuckians ages 16 and older will be able to sign up for appointments by April 12,” according to the Governor’s office. “Kentuckians deemed most vulnerable should still get priority, and they will, but we can’t have these vaccines sitting in a freezer. We are in a race against the COVID-19 variants and we’ve got to get it out fast,” said Gov. Beshear. 5 Rhode Island Says Gov. Dan McKee on Twitter: “The good news is that this week we also received new information from the federal government about an increase in vaccine allocation to states. This allows us to announce that on 4/19, RI plans to open up vaccination eligibility to all adults age 16 and over.”RELATED: Doctor Warns “Do Not” Do This Before Your Vaccine 6 Maryland “Based on our accelerating vaccination rate and an anticipated increase in supply from the federal government, I’m pleased to announce that Maryland will enter Phase 2 of our vaccine distribution plan early next week,” tweeted Gov. Larry Hogan. “Pre-registration is now available for Marylanders age 60+ via http://covidvax.maryland.gov or 1-855-MD-GOVAX. Individuals currently eligible in Phase 1 will continue to be prioritized at the state’s mass vaccination sites….We have built the infrastructure and are being promised the supply to be able to vaccinate every Marylander in the next couple months. Our entire team will not rest until every single Marylander who wants a vaccine has received one. “ 7 Missouri “During today's briefing at the State Capitol, Governor Mike Parson announced that Missouri will activate Phase 2 of the state's COVID-19 Vaccination Plan on Monday, March 29, 2021, and Phase 3 on Friday, April 9, 2021,” said a statement from the Governor’s office. “With the progress we are currently seeing and vaccine supply expected to increase significantly in the coming weeks, we are well ahead of schedule with our vaccine plan,” Governor Parson said. “Supply projections are subject to change, but it is critical that we start preparing for this potential influx and ensure there is a consistent number of people who are eligible and interested in receiving a vaccine.” 8 Utah “On March 24, Utahns who are 16 and older will be eligible for the COVID-19 vaccine,” said Gov. Spencer J. Cox. “You can search for doses by your favorite provider at http://coronavirus.utah.gov. You can also search by vaccine type and for doses near you at http://vaccinefinder.org.” So get vaccinated when it becomes available to you, and to protect your life and the lives of others, don't visit any of these 35 Places You're Most Likely to Catch COVID.

  • Bank demand for Treasuries in focus after Fed ends regulatory break

    Investors will be closely watching demand for U.S. government securities in the coming months after the Federal Reserve declined to extend pandemic-related regulatory relief for big U.S. banks, which means they may need to raise capital against holdings of U.S. Treasuries and central bank deposits. The Fed said it would launch a review of the capital rule, known as the "supplementary leverage ratio," while letting the exemption given last year expire on March 31. Some analysts and investors are concerned that banks may need to pare bond purchases, sell assets and/or reduce lending in overnight funding markets backed by Treasuries as unprecedented growth in reserves threatens to push some banks close to their capital ratio limits.

  • Miami sets earlier curfew after spring break crowds, fights

    Officials are imposing an emergency 8 p.m.-6 a.m. curfew for Miami Beach, effective immediately after hard partying Spring Breakers trashed restaurants, brawled in the streets and gathered by the thousands without masks or social distancing, according to authorities. At a news conference, officials blamed overwhelming and out-of-control spring break crowds for the curfew, which was taking effect Saturday night in South Beach, one of the nation's top party spots. Tourists and hotel guests are being told to stay indoors during curfew hours.

  • Miami Beach Freaks Out Over Massive Spring Break Crowds, Declares State of Emergency

    Joe Raedle/GettyThe city of Miami Beach declared a state of emergency Saturday as huge, rowdy crowds of spring breakers wreaked havoc in the streets.Authorities will enforce an 8 p.m. curfew each night beginning Saturday, and major roads into the city will close from 9 p.m. to 5 a.m. but for one lane. Tourists are not being asked to leave, rather to stay at their hotels after hours.Universities throughout the country have canceled the usual weeklong spring holiday, but academic obligations have not stopped students from hitting vacation spots, especially in Florida where coronavirus precautions are more lax than in other states.8th and Ocean #SouthBeach pic.twitter.com/yRV4yVSKu0— Janine Stanwood (@JanineStanwood) March 20, 2021 Crowds of hundreds of partygoers have turned violent in recent days, brawling in the streets with the use of restaurants’ outdoor dining tables and chairs. A fight that started Thursday night at a restaurant on Ocean Drive, a popular party boulevard, ended in multiple arrests and anti-riot countermeasures from police, including firing pepper balls into the mob.A 29-year-old Miami Beach resident told The Daily Beast, “Time and time again during this pandemic, tourists are ruining everything.”Miami Beach Mayor Dan Gelber said at a Saturday press conference, “I love that this is a beautiful place, that people come here to gather and enjoy our weather and our beaches. But right now, it has become too challenging in the tourism industry to continue that way.”Gelber speculated that spring breakers have hit the destination city harder than usual because “there are very few places in the country that are open.”Spring Break Sends Late-Night Miami Club Scene Over the EdgeThe Clevelander hotel, a well-known destination on Ocean Drive, announced Saturday that it would close its restaurant and bar until March 24 as a safety precaution, though it would pay employees’ salaries throughout.“Recently, we have grown increasingly concerned with the safety of our dedicated employees and valued customers and the ability of the City to maintain a safe environment in the surrounding area,” a statement from the Clevelander read.How forceful crowds will be in their demands to party and how aggressive police will be in implementing the restrictions remains to be seen. Hotel staff who spoke to The Daily Beast were skeptical that any safety measures would control the revelers.“That is going to start trouble, isn’t it? 8 p.m. That’s never going to happen. That is just wild,” Patty, an employee at the Starlite Hotel on Ocean Drive, told The Daily Beast on Saturday.A 32-year-old Miami resident likewise scoffed at the emergency measures.“Honestly, closing down Miami Beach means nothing. People are just going to flock to Brickle and Wynwood. People just need to go,” he said.The tourists have locals staying home for a wide variety of reasons—the coronavirus, violence, and more mundane problems like road congestion. “I haven’t seen traffic this bad in years. It’s like Ultra traffic but worse,” another resident said, referring to the annual electronic music festival. “I am scared to walk down the street honestly.”Read more at The Daily Beast.Get our top stories in your inbox every day. Sign up now!Daily Beast Membership: Beast Inside goes deeper on the stories that matter to you. Learn more.

  • Ex-wife of Trump Org executive says she is cooperating with investigators

    Jennifer Weisselberg says she was asked about her use of rent-free Trump apartments

  • Cost concerns are driving COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy among seniors, study finds

    Public health officials have spent the last several months trying to combat COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy in the United States, often reiterating the safety and efficacy of the shots approved by the Food and Drug Administration. But a Medicare Advantage study conducted earlier this month found that, nationwide, 312,173 seniors are planning to avoid getting inoculated because of concerns they'll have to pay for the vaccines, WRIC in Richmond, Virginia, reports. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has tried to make it clear that coronavirus vaccinations are free to everyone regardless of insurance coverage, but the study notes "it's difficult to fault older adults for having concerns about the cost" because there have been numerous reports of clinics charging people for vaccine appointments, and a number of scams have surfaced, as well. People over 65 make up the age demographic most vulnerable to COVID-19. Medicare Advantage used data from the U.S. Census Bureau's Weekly Household Pulse Survey in the analysis. Read the full analysis here and more at WRIC. More stories from theweek.comSusan Collins is baffled as to why the White House 'would want to alienate' herMatthew McConaughey for governor?5 scorchingly funny cartoons about Mitch McConnell's filibuster threat

  • You can save more than $100 on our favorite Dyson cordless vacuum right now

    The Dyson V11 Torque Drive is our favorite Dyson cordless vacuum of all time, and right now, you can get it for more than $100 off—find out more.

  • Many Americans of color call for unity against white supremacy after Atlanta killings

    Many leaders of color are calling on Americans to unite against the common enemy of white supremacy after a wave of attacks on Asian Americans.

  • Susan Collins is baffled as to why the White House 'would want to alienate' her

    Sen. Susan Collins (R-Maine) is still frustrated by how COVID-19 relief bill negotiations went down, The Wall Street Journal reports. Specifically, Collins is not pleased about what she considers to have been a brusque dismissal when she and a group of other Republican senators sat down with President Biden in early February to try to reach consensus on a package. The senator, who has built a moderate reputation over the years, told the Journal that she's confused as to why the Biden administration, which ultimately saw its $1.9 trillion stimulus pass through Congress without Republican support in either chamber, "would want to alienate the Republican most likely to work with them to find common ground." It's "truly a mystery to me," she said. Collins doesn't really blame Biden, it seems. The two got along well when the latter was still in the Senate, and Collins said she trusts him when he says he wants to work with Republicans and build unity in Congress. But, she reportedly thinks White House Chief of Staff Ron Klain and Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.), with whom Collins has verbally sparred recently, are getting in the way of that. "I have been a bit concerned that perhaps some of these left groups, or perhaps members of [Biden's] staff, are tugging at him constantly to try to move him further to the left than I think is wise," she told the Journal. Read more at The Wall Street Journal. More stories from theweek.comMatthew McConaughey for governor?5 scorchingly funny cartoons about Mitch McConnell's filibuster threatIs Rand Paul a real doctor?

  • The Water on Mars Vanished. This Might Be Where It Went.

    Mars was once wet, with an ocean’s worth of water on its surface. Today, most of Mars is as dry as a desert except for ice deposits in its polar regions. Where did the rest of the water go? Some of it disappeared into space. Water molecules, pummeled by particles of solar wind, broke apart into hydrogen and oxygen atoms, and those, especially the lighter hydrogen atoms, sped out of the atmosphere, lost to outer space. Sign up for The Morning newsletter from the New York Times But most of the water, a new study concludes, went down, sucked into the red planet’s rocks. And there it remains, trapped within minerals and salts. Indeed, as much as 99% of the water that once flowed on Mars could still be there, the researchers estimated in a paper published this week in the journal Science. Data from the past two decades of robotic missions to Mars, including NASA’s Curiosity rover and the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter, showed a wide distribution of what geologists call hydrated minerals. “It became very, very clear that it was common and not rare to find evidence of water alteration,” said Bethany Ehlmann, a professor of planetary science at the California Institute of Technology and one of the authors of the paper. Ehlmann, speaking at a news briefing Tuesday at the Lunar and Planetary Science conference, said that as the rocks are altered by liquid water, water molecules become incorporated into minerals like clays. “Water is effectively trapped into the crust,” she said. To get a sense of the amount of water, planetary scientists talk about a “global equivalent layer” — that is, if Mars were smoothed out into a uniform, featureless ball, how deep would the water have been? The scientists estimated that the depth would have been 100 to 1,500 meters, or 330 to 5,000 feet. The most likely depth was about 2,000 feet, they said, or roughly one-fourth as much water as is in the Atlantic Ocean. The data and simulations also indicated that the water was almost all gone by 3 billion years ago, around the time on Earth when life consisted of single-cell microbes in the oceans. “This means that Mars has been dry for quite a long time,” said Eva Scheller, a Caltech graduate student who was the lead author of the Science paper. Today, there is still water equivalent to a global ocean 65 to 130 feet deep, but that is mostly frozen in the polar ice caps. Planetary scientists have long marveled at ancient evidence of flowing water carved in the Martian surface — gigantic canyons, tendrils of winding river channels and deltas where the rivers disgorged sediments into lakes. NASA’s latest robotic Mars explorer, Perseverance, which landed last month in the Jezero crater, will be headed to a river delta at its edge in hopes of finding signs of past life. Without a time machine, there is no way to observe directly how much water was on a younger Mars more than 3 billion years ago. But the hydrogen atoms floating today in the atmosphere of Mars preserve a ghostly hint of the ancient ocean. On Earth, about 1 in 5,000 hydrogen atoms is a version known as deuterium that is twice as heavy because its nucleus contains both a neutron and a proton. (The nucleus of a common-variety hydrogen atom has only a proton, no neutrons.) But on Mars, the concentration of deuterium is markedly higher, about 1 in 700. Scientists at the NASA Goddard Space Flight Center who reported this finding in 2015 said this could be used to calculate the amount of water Mars once had. Mars probably started with a similar ratio of deuterium to hydrogen as Earth, but the fraction of deuterium increased over time as the water evaporated and hydrogen was lost to space, because the heavier deuterium is less likely to escape the atmosphere. The problem with that story, said Renyu Hu, a scientist at NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory and another author of the current Science paper, is that Mars has not been losing hydrogen fast enough. Measurements by NASA’s Mars Atmosphere and Volatile Evolution orbiter, or MAVEN, have showed that the current rate, extrapolated over 4 billion years, “can only account for a small fraction of the water loss,” Hu said. “This is not enough to explain the great drying of Mars.” That led to the new research concluding that a great majority of water went into the rocks. “This is a very interesting new study in which many processes are combined to provide alternative scenarios for the fate of water on Mars,” Geronimo Villanueva, one of the NASA scientists who performed the earlier deuterium measurements, wrote in an email. “This opens the possibility for an even wetter past, and that rocks on Mars now hold more water than we initially thought.” The water, however, probably would not be of much use to settlers from Earth. “The amount of water that’s in a rock is very small,” Scheller said. To release water trapped in minerals requires heating them to high temperatures. “We would have to sort of cook a very large amount of rock to have anything that would be helpful,” Scheller said. Elon Musk, the founder of SpaceX who dreams of sending colonists to Mars one day, has mused about detonating nuclear bombs on Mars to melt the ice caps and warm the planet, making it more hospitable. Those explosions would also release some of the water in the hydrated minerals, although Scheller declined to speculate how much. Michael Meyer, the lead scientist for NASA’s Mars exploration program, said, “I’ll just mention that nuking a planet is usually not a good way to make it more habitable.” On Earth, water is also absorbed in rocks, but it does not stay there indefinitely. The movement of Earth’s crust pushes rocks down into the mantle, where they melt, and then the molten rock — and water — comes back up through volcanoes. On Mars, volcanism, like liquid water, appears to have gone away long ago. This article originally appeared in The New York Times. © 2021 The New York Times Company

  • A father dropped his 2-year-old daughter into the enclosure of an angry African bull elephant at San Diego Zoo

    The unidentified 25-year-old lost his grip on his 2-year-old daughter while trying to climb out of the enclosure, but both escaped uninjured.

  • Man who discovered world's only prehistoric underwater cave paintings breaks silence on Paris rivalry

    When French diver Henri Cosquer stumbled upon the world's only prehistoric cave paintings reached from under the sea in 1991 off Marseille, some Parisian experts laughed off his claims of caveman penguin art as Provence hyperbole. Those claims turned out to be entirely true and saw the Cosquer Cave - whose entrance lies 37 metres (120ft) under the waves - hailed France’s “undersea Lascaux”. Now Mr Cosquer, in his 70s, is about to have the last laugh as an exact copy of the fabulous discovery that bears his name will soon open to the public in Marseille. Experts around France are putting the finishing touches to a perfect facsimile of the Cosquer Cave - the only one in the world with an entrance below present-day sea level where cave art has been preserved from the flooding that occurred when the seas rose after the end of the last Ice Age. The original contains a bestiary of 500 drawings of 11 different species, including horses, bison, aurochs, ibex, chamois, saiga antelope, red and megaloceros deer and a cave lion. However, unique to the cave are sea animals including penguins, auks, seals and jellyfish-like creatures. The cave also contains a depiction of what some have dubbed the first prehistoric murder, showing a human with a seal's head shot through by a spear.

  • Royal Caribbean just announced 'fully vaccinated' cruises to the Bahamas and Mexico this summer

    Royal Caribbean has been dabbling with COVID-19 vaccine mandates, and previously announced a different 'fully vaccinated' cruise in Israel.

  • Spring break, no masks and cinemas: US reopening faster than UK despite lagging in vaccination race

    The US is rapidly casting off Covid restrictions despite trailing the UK in its race to vaccinate their population. As the UK remains in tight lockdown, wide swathes of America are now almost back to business as usual. Texas is "open 100 per cent" according to its governor, who has also done away with any requirement to wear a mask. In Florida this weekend thousands of students packed on to beaches during Spring Break, while families poured into Disney World. California, one of the most restrictive states during the pandemic, this week allowed restaurants to open for indoor dining, and permitted gyms and cinemas to operate with limited capacity. On Friday, Joe Biden celebrated reaching his goal of having 100 million vaccine doses administered in his first 100 days. The target was surpassed six weeks early. But the US still lags behind the UK in rolling out vaccines.

  • Mar-a-Lago: 'Covid outbreak' at Trump's Florida residence

    Parts of the Mar-a-Lago resort, where the former US president lives, have reportedly been closed.

  • Pakistan Prime Minister Imran Khan tests positive for Covid-19 a day after receiving vaccination

    Pakistan Prime Minister Imran Khan has tested positive for Covid-19, the country's health minister said on Saturday, a day after receiving his vaccination. Mr Khan is "self isolating at home," said minister Faisal Sultan in a tweet. The 67-year-old was inoculated on Friday as part of a nationwide campaign to encourage vaccinations. He appealed to Pakistanis to follow his lead and follow new restrictions introduced to prevent a surge in cases. Pakistan has historically seen high levels of vaccine hesitancy.

  • U.S., China conclude 'tough' talks in Alaska

    Top U.S. and Chinese officials concluded two days of what Washington called "tough and direct" talks on Friday in Alaska.It was the first high-level in-person meeting between the two sides under the new Biden administration, and put heightened tensions between the world's two largest economies on full display.But the talks appeared to yield no diplomatic breakthrough, and the two have yet to reset relations that have slumped to the lowest level in decades.U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken told reporters Friday it was clear the two countries remained "fundamentally at odds" on several issues, including Xinjiang, Hong Kong, Taiwan."And it's no surprise that when we raised those issues clearly and directly, we got a defensive response. But we were also able to have a very candid conversation... on Iran, on North Korea, on Afghanistan, on climate our interests intersect."The run-up to the talks in Anchorage followed high-profile visits by U.S. officials to allies Japan and South Korea, in Washington's attempt to show off a firm stance against China.Following fiery opening remarks in which Chinese officials lashed out against U.S. democracy and treatment of minorities, the United States accused China of quote "grandstanding" for its domestic audience, and both sides suggested the other had broken diplomatic protocol.Speaking to reporters Friday, China's State Councilor Wang Yi reiterated the importance of sovereignty and territorial integrity for the Chinese side, but said that the talks were quote "candid, constructive, and beneficial."U.S. President Joe Biden told reporters at the White House on Friday morning that he was quote "very proud" of the secretary of state when asked about the talks.

  • Thousands protest against Israel's Netanyahu ahead of vote

    The weekly protests against Netanyahu have taken place for nine months. Saturday's night's gathering in central Jerusalem was the largest protest in months. The grassroots protest movement believes Netanyahu cannot serve as prime minister while he is on trial for multiple corruption charges.

  • It took a pandemic to make me realize how much underwire bras suck, and I'm not the only one

    After many bra-wearers spent a year "unhooked," comfier styles like sports bras and bralettes may reign supreme for the foreseeable future.

  • Review: The $84,090 Porsche Macan GTS is the practical combination of a sports car and a luxury SUV

    Though it may look like an SUV and be shaped like an SUV, the 2020 Porsche Macan GTS actually drives like a hot hatchback. That's a good thing.