Recently on NXT, Indi Hartwell has been vying for the attention of a fellow star of the brand, Dexter Lumis. The infatuation seemed to start during Lumis' feud with Johnny Gargano, and the kidnap of another member of The Way, Austin Theory.
Indi Hartwell recently took to social media to drop further hints about her feelings for Lumis. On her Twitter page, Hartwell posted a series of tweets on the matter.
Hartwell, who has also changed her Twitter name to Mrs Indi Wrestling Lumis, posted a picture of her admiring Lumis, captioned with lyrics from the song "Daydreamin'" by Ariana Grande.
The final tweet in the series which Hartwell posted about her love interest was a GIF of Dexter Lumis stroking the face of Kushida, captioned: "#goals."
NXT stable The Way was formed by Johnny Gargano and Candice LeRae, who began portraying themselves as a power couple on-screen in Spring 2020. The duo began working together more on television and feuded with another real-life wrestling couple, Mia Yim and Keith Lee.
At NXT Halloween Havoc, a cloaked figure wearing a Ghostface mask attempted to help Candice LeRae in her title match against Io Shirai.
A few weeks later, it was revealed that this mysterious person was, in fact, Indi Hartwell. Similarly, a mystery man helped Johnny Gargano in his matches and was later unveiled to be Austin Theory.
In December 2020, the foursome officially called themselves The Way and have appeared on NXT as a stable ever since.