$27M settlement is early focus today in Derek Chauvin murder trial, one seated juror dismissed

  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.
Paul Walsh, Star Tribune
·4 min read
  • Oops!
    Something went wrong.
    Please try again later.

The influence of extensive publicity again takes center stage at the murder trial of fired Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin on Wednesday, when the presiding judge quizzes most of the jurors seated so far about their ability to be fair to the defendant in the wake of an announcement that the city has agreed to pay George Floyd's survivors $27 million.

Hennepin County District Judge Peter Cahill intends to question remotely seven of the nine jurors about whether the record federal lawsuit settlement reached last week would impact their ability to assure Chauvin of his constitutional right to be presumed innocent during the course of the trial.

Before questioning, Cahill began the court session by warning reporters against reporting what is on notes and computers in courtroom, along with the security details on the 18th floor. He called it "extremely irresponsible" and said it would be met with sanctions if it continued.

Questioning of whether jurors knew about the settlement let to the dismissal of one, a Hispanic man in his 20s who said news of the settlement "kind of confirms opinions that I already have." Three others so far were not aware.

Upon the settlement's announcement, defense attorney Eric Nelson put before Cahill several requests. The judge said he will consider two: delaying the trial so attorneys can have time to reassess their strategies in the context of the settlement; moving the trial to a different Minnesota city, where the influence of publicity about the case might not be as ever-present.

Cahill rejected sequestering the jury any sooner than during deliberations and granting the defense more strikes to use for dismissing would-be jurors.

News of the settlement played a role Tuesday in the court's ability to seat any additional jurors. Also, as has happened throughout the first six days of jury selection, some of the prospective jurors questioned Tuesday said that seeing the viral video of Floyd's detention under Chauvin's knee prevented them from pledging they can be fair and impartial to the defendant.

Also on Cahill's plate for a ruling this week is whether he should allow details from Floyd's May 2019 arrest in Minneapolis. Cahill previously denied letting in testimony about the arrest, but opened the door Tuesday after hearing the defense's arguments. The judge said he would rule Thursday.

In May 2019 and again on May 25, 2020, the day he died, Floyd swallowed drugs during his police encounters. In the earlier incident, captured on police body camera video, the drugs led to a "hypertensive emergency" and the 46-year-old Floyd's hospitalization.

According to the evidence from the earlier arrest, Nelson said, a paramedic warned Floyd that his blood pressure was extremely high, and if he didn't calm down, he was at risk of a heart attack or stroke. The cause of Floyd's death will be a core issue at trial.

Race relations have come up consistently throughout jury selection. Chauvin is white, and Floyd was Black. Many potential jurors have been questioned about how police and the justice system treat Blacks vs. whites in this country. They've also been asked their opinions about the Black Lives Matter movement and the term Blue Lives Matter, which is a way to express support for law enforcement.

With five more jurors yet to be chosen before the livestreamed trial starts, the panel consists of four people of color and five people who are white. More specifically: one multiracial woman in her 20s, two Black men in their 30s, one Hispanic man in his 20s, two white women in their 50s, a white man in his 20s and two white men in their 30s.

Heading into Wednesday, the defense has used 11 of 15 strikes, which attorneys can employ to dismiss prospective jurors without explanation. Prosecutors have used five of their nine peremptory strikes.

Chauvin stands charged with second-degree murder, third-degree murder and manslaughter.

Three other fired officers who assisted in Floyd's 2020 arrest — J. Alexander Kueng, Thomas Lane and Tou Thao — are scheduled to be tried in August on charges of aiding and abetting murder and manslaughter.

Paul Walsh • 612-673-4482

Recommended Stories

  • S&P 500, Nasdaq drop as tech stocks slip ahead of Fed

    The S&P 500 and the Nasdaq dropped on Wednesday as U.S. bond yields spiked ahead of the Federal Reserve's policy statement which could provide hints on whether the central bank would raise interest rates sooner than expected. The benchmark 10-year yield ticked up to a new 13-month high of 1.676%, denting demand for some high-growth technology stocks and pressuring the tech-heavy Nasdaq by about 1%. The Fed is expected to issue a blowout GDP forecast for 2021 at the end of a two-day meeting on Wednesday at 2 p.m. ET (1800 GMT).

  • 'Why are people so mean to me?' My heartbreaking conversations with Caroline Flack

    We met on a hike in downtown Los Angeles. It was 2016, and Caroline Flack and I – introduced that day by a mutual friend – hit it off immediately. I felt like I’d known her forever. That was how she made you feel as soon as you started talking to her. Anyone who was lucky enough to know Carrie – as a lot of her friends called her – knew that when the cameras stopped rolling, she wasn’t far off that same person who lit up our TV screens each night. She was just as funny, kind, strong and vibrant in her everyday life, and around the people she loved. Grounded and down to earth, she worked hard and took note of every person she met along the way. Everyone mattered. When we first met, she was on holiday during a break from filming Love Island, the ITV reality show she presented. I was in LA for work. Working in music meant we mixed in similar circles. Carrie loved being in LA, and after that hike she invited me out every day and night for the rest of my stay. By the end of that trip we had created a solid bond.

  • Mayim Bialik says she's recovering from an eating disorder

    Mayim Bialik is opening up for the first time about her battle with eating disorders during an episode of her podcast "Mayim Bialik’s Breakdown."

  • CDC urges against spring break festivities as beachfront culture wars heat up

    Some conservatives are encouraging spring break travel to warm-weather states like Florida, while the Biden administration pleads with people to stay home until a greater share of the nation is vaccinated against the coronavirus.

  • 5 Things You Should Know About Eating Disorders (from People Who Have Had Them)

    1. “Just because I don’t look emaciated doesn’t mean I’m not struggling.”“When I was at the peak of my eating disorder, I didn’t look like a person you’d assume had an eating issue. You couldn’t see my ribs...

  • Republicans can’t win if all of us vote. So they’re trying hard to ‘fix’ that | Opinion

    On the issue of guns, John Kavanagh has a record unblemished by sanity.

  • Behavioral experts issues warning over serious post-pandemic condition plaguing pets

    Here's how you can prepare your dog for the transition to a post-pandemic world.

  • Derek Chauvin trial live: Judge cuts two jurors who said they can't be impartial after $27M settlement over George Floyd's death

    Two jurors said they couldn't be impartial in Derek Chauvin's murder trial after hearing about a $27 million settlement with George Floyd's family.

  • Antarctic seafloor exposed after 50 years of ice cover

    Research ship Polarstern samples Antarctic seafloor life uncovered by the calving of a big iceberg.

  • Biden team's China focus puts S.Korea on the spot

    For the first time in years there are liberal presidents in South Korea and the United States, but the change in U.S. administrations hasn't made it any easier for Seoul to balance its alliance with Washington and its economic reliance on China.The Americans' message has focused on marshaling their Asian alliances to counter potential "coercion and aggression" by Beijing. That represents a challenge for Seoul, which is not eager to provoke China - its largest economic partner.Austin, while meeting South Korea's Defense Minister Suk Wook, said that China and North Korea are presenting "unprecedented challenges," but the alliance is more important than ever.

  • UK PM Johnson says he will get Oxford/AstraZeneca COVID-19 vaccine very soon

    British Prime Minister Boris Johnson said on Wednesday he would get the Oxford/AstraZeneca COVID-19 shot very soon, voicing his confidence in a vaccine that has been suspended in some other European countries after reports of blood clots. Several European Union countries have suspended their roll out of the shot, developed by the University of Oxford and AstraZeneca, but Britain's regulator has said that there is no evidence of a causal link between reports of thrombo-embolic events and the vaccine. Asked if European countries had disregarded scientific evidence, Johnson said: "The best thing I can say about the Oxford/AstraZeneca vaccine programme is that I finally got news that I'm going to have my own jab ... very, very shortly."

  • Exclusive: Mexico plans push to contain migration near Guatemala border - sources

    Mexico is preparing to significantly reinforce efforts to detain migrants who illegally cross its border with Guatemala in response to a jump in people trying to enter the United States, according to four people familiar with the matter. The U.S. government said this week it is facing the biggest migrant surge on its border with Mexico in 20 years, presenting authorities a major challenge and sparking concerns inside the Mexican government. The people familiar with the plan said Mexico would deploy security forces to cut the flow of migrants, the bulk of whom come from three poor and often violent Central American countries whose economies have been battered in the coronavirus pandemic - the so-called Northern Triangle of Guatemala, El Salvador and Honduras.

  • ‘Don’t come’: Biden tells migrants to stay away from US-Mexico border

    ‘We’re in the process of getting set up,’ says president to potential migrants amid surge in crossings by unaccompanied minors

  • Biden vows Russia's Putin will 'pay a price' for election meddling -ABC News

    President Joe Biden said Russian President Vladimir Putin will face consequences for directing efforts to swing the 2020 U.S. presidential election to Donald Trump, and that they would come soon. "He will pay a price," Biden told ABC News in an interview that aired on Wednesday. Asked what the consequences would come, he said, "You'll see shortly."

  • Biden and Irish premier Micheal Martin to hold online talks marking St Patrick’s Day

    Topics of conversation could include Brexit, coronavirus and Ireland’s vaccine supply issues

  • Column: They may not admit it, but Republicans have accepted that Obamacare is here to stay

    The COVID relief bill significantly expanded the Affordable Care Act — and may have moved the country a step closer to Medicare for all.

  • Election looming, Iran's Rouhani says hardliners sabotage goal to lift sanctions

    Iran’s pragmatist president accused hardline opponents on Wednesday of obstructing efforts to lift U.S. sanctions, in remarks that demonstrate how an upcoming election in Iran is now looming over the new U.S. administration's plan for a thaw. “It is a great betrayal of the Iranian nation if any faction or person delays the end of the sanctions even for one hour,” Hassan Rouhani said in televised remarks. The new U.S. administration of President Joe Biden aims to revive an agreement abandoned by his predecessor Donald Trump, under which Iran accepted curbs to its nuclear programme in return for the lifting of international sanctions.

  • China protests over Japan, US statement on human rights

    China has protested to the United States and Japan over a joint statement it said “maliciously attacked” its foreign policy and seriously interfered in China’s internal affairs, the Foreign Ministry said Wednesday. Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson Zhao Lijian said China was “strongly dissatisfied and resolutely opposed” to the statement.

  • Biden marks St. Patrick's Day, to praise Good Friday accord

    President Joe Biden is marking St. Patrick’s Day as he recommits the U.S. to the Good Friday Agreement, which has come under increasing stress following the United Kingdom's exit from the European Union. Biden, the latest president of Irish decent, is set for a virtual meeting Wednesday with Ireland's prime minister, Taoiseach Micheál Martin. The president attended a morning Mass at the aptly named St. Patrick's Church near his family home in Wilmington, Delaware, before returning to the White House to partake in St. Patrick's Day celebrations toned down due to the coronavirus pandemic.

  • iPhone storage full? Here are 3 ways to save your photos and videos.

    Unlike Android smartphones, you can't expand iPhones memories, but here are three ways to back-up your precious memories from your phone or iPad.