Sydney’s natural beauty holding city back: NSW Treasurer
NSW Treasurer Dominic Perrottet has said Sydney’s Harbour’s iconic beauty is holding the city back as he called on people to shun mediocrity in reshaping the metropolitan landscape.
In a speech to the Sydney Summit, hosted by the Committee for Sydney, Mr Perrottet said the series of crises endured in 2020 were a “wake-up call” and that the state’s prosperity meant more now than just getting back to normal.
NSW Treasurer Dominic Perrottet says Sydney’s tolerance for mediocrity is too high.Credit:Louise Kennerley
“As far as cities go, Sydney is on another level. So the question is, why do we put up with eyesores like the Cahill Expressway. Why is it controversial to even suggest that something has to be done about the White Bay precinct?” the Treasurer asked in a nod to the heritage debate he stirred in November by suggesting the White Bay power station should be torn down.
“The western harbour [the area around White Bay] is such a beautiful stretch of waterfront that in any other city in the world would be a major visitor attraction, so it’s ironic that, until recently, all you could ever do there was to get on a boat to go somewhere else - Tasmania, no less.”
He said successive governments had got away with leaving the site dormant for decades because, “even with those blemishes, Sydney is still a world-class city”.
“But our harbour is so beautiful, it is so iconic, that I believe it’s actually holding us back,” Mr Perrottet told the conference of planning industry figures on Monday morning, adding that other great cities around the world were not able to lean on their natural beauty.
“Melbourne’s grandest hotels are on the banks of a brown creek. London’s river Thames and the Seine in Paris have a similar ambience. The great city of New York is built on a swamp, yet without a harbour to fall back on, enormous efforts have gone into making their cities the great places to live, work and visit.”
The Treasurer named built heritage, as well as tax and regulation, as three examples of mediocrity holding the city back, promoting a recent recommendation by former prime minister Paul Keating and former Sydney lord mayor Lucy Turnbull to revitalise the underused heritage precinct of Macquarie Street into a cultural precinct.
Mr Perrottet said the existing area had “no vision”, acted as a “road block” to crowds using The Domain, and there was hardly anywhere to eat or drink.
“You almost think we don’t want people to appreciate these ... treasures right in our midst,” he said.
Sydney Harbour’s natural beauty is holding the city back, Mr Perrottet says.Credit:James Alcock
The prioritisation of open public and green spaces, and a focus on good design, have been among the keystones of the government’s planning agenda over the past 12 months, while a greater discussion has evolved around reinterpreting heritage and historic sites for greater public use.
The Treasurer also used his speech to promote the government’s push to reform stamp duty to a system of annual property tax, as well as its moves to strip red tape from the hospitality sector as part of the city’s outdoor dining revolution.
He said that, despite NSW’s comparative global success in controlling the spread and various economic and social effects of COVID-19, one of the most important lessons of the pandemic was that Sydney’s tolerance for mediocrity was “too high”.
“When it’s a matter of survival, though, mediocrity is not an option. Emerging from the pandemic, this is the mindset we must retain, so that our recovery is fast and strong and, over the long term, our state can fulfill its true potential, and this means more than just getting back to normal,” Mr Perrottet said.
Get our Morning & Evening Edition newsletters
The most important news, analysis and insights delivered to your inbox at the start and end of each day. Sign up here.
Angus Thompson is an Urban Affairs reporter for The Sydney Morning Herald.