Covid: What’s the problem with the EU vaccine rollout?

Published
Related Topics
image copyrightEPA

The European Union has been criticised for the slow pace of coronavirus vaccinations in member states.

It has introduced export controls on vaccines produced in the EU after its rollout was hit by supply problems and delays.

How does the EU vaccine scheme work?

The scheme, set up in June 2020, allows the EU to negotiate the purchase of vaccines on behalf of its member states. It says this can help reduce costs and avoid competition between them.

Member states do not have to join the scheme, but all 27 EU countries chose to do so.

They are still allowed to make separate deals with vaccine makers which the EU does not have an agreement with. Hungary has agreed to buy two million doses of the Russian Sputnik-V vaccine.

What is the row over the AstraZeneca vaccine?

The Oxford-AstraZeneca vaccine was approved for use in the EU on 29 January.

The EU signed a deal for 300 million doses in August, while the UK ordered 100 million doses and signed its deal in May.

But supply problems have been announced by AstraZeneca, which blamed manufacturing problems on one plant in Belgium and another in the Netherlands.

Reports suggested deliveries to the EU would be reduced to 31 million - a cut of 60% - in the first quarter of 2021.

This prompted criticism from the EU which says it should not receive fewer doses just because the UK signed a contract earlier. It said AstraZeneca's UK plants "had to deliver".

It said its agreement with the EU allowed the option of supplying Europe from UK sites, but only once the UK had sufficient supplies. "As soon as we can, we'll help the EU," chief executive Pascal Soriot said.

UK government minister Michael Gove said there would be "no interruption" to UK supplies, which had been "planned, paid for and scheduled".

The EU announced on 29 January that it was introducing export controls on vaccines made in the bloc.

It said this would also apply to vaccines moving between the Republic of Ireland (which is in the EU) and Northern Ireland, overriding part of the Brexit deal for Northern Ireland. After widespread criticism, the EU reversed this decision.

The EU previously placed export controls on personal protective equipment, to make sure member states had enough.

What about the Pfizer vaccine?

The EU approved the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine in December, having signed a deal for 300 million doses. But the company was unable to supply the 12.5 million doses it had promised by the end of 2020.

The head of BioNTech, Uğur Şahin, said "the process in Europe certainly didn't proceed as quickly and straightforwardly as with other countries". He said the company was ramping up manufacturing capacity.

The EU approved the Moderna jab in January and has doubled its order of the Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine to 600m doses.

But vaccinations in parts of Europe were paused after Pfizer temporarily cut deliveries, to increase capacity at its processing plant in Belgium.

French pharmaceutical company Sanofi has announced it will help manufacture 125 million doses of the vaccine for the EU, starting in the summer.

There have been supply problems with the Moderna vaccine too, with Italy and France both announcing a reduction in supplies.

How many people have been vaccinated?

In Germany, where 2.6 million peoplehad been vaccinated by 1 February, the government has been criticised for lagging behind other countries, despite BioNTech being a German company.

In France, just over one and a half million people have had the jab with a similar number vaccinated in Spain.

Italy has administered just over two million doses.

The government says the UK - by contrast - has given 10 million doses.

Which other vaccines is the EU buying?

The European Commission says it has reached agreements with five other pharmaceutical companies to purchase hundreds of millions of vaccines, once they pass clinical trials:

  • AstraZeneca: 400 million doses
  • Sanofi-GSK: 300 million doses
  • Johnson & Johnson: 400 million doses
  • CureVac: 405 million doses
  • Moderna: 160 million doses

The Commission concluded initial talks with another company, Novavax, for up to 200 million doses.

A European Commission spokesperson told BBC News the strategy of ordering vaccines from several suppliers was "fundamentally sound" and could "ensure almost two billion doses for European citizens".

What part did Brexit play?

After the UK approved the Pfizer vaccine in November (nearly three weeks before the EU regulators), some argued that it was only able to move this quickly because of Brexit.

Reality Check looked into this claim and found that the UK's approval of the jab was actually permitted under EU law - a point made by the head of the UK medicines regulator.

The government said that being outside the EU did allow it to be more nimble in this area.

image copyrightAFP

So, what about the EU vaccine scheme?

The UK could have joined it last year, while it was still in a transition phase with the EU (and following its rules), but it chose not to.

If it had, the UK might not have been able to do as many deals with vaccine companies.

The terms of EU scheme state that participating countries must, "agree not to launch their own procedures for advance purchase of [a] vaccine with the same manufacturers", that the EU has an agreement with.

However, the German government - a participant - signed its own side deal with Pfizer for 30 million extra doses in September.

In January, the European Commission refused to say whether this had broken the terms of the EU scheme.

Related Topics

More on this story