Hong Kong: Defiant Hong Kong opposition condemned by China

Published
Related Topics
media captionWu Chi-wai, Hong Kong pro-democracy lawmaker 'announces mass resignations'

The Chinese government has condemned the mass resignation of most of Hong Kong's opposition from parliament as an "open challenge" to its authority.

Nearly all pro-democracy lawmakers have resigned in protest after four of their colleagues were deemed threats to national security and dismissed.

Many see Hong Kong's limited democracy as now being in its death throes.

The former British colony became part of China in 1997 but was promised it could keep some unique freedoms.

But the mainland authorities in Beijing have taken increasingly repressive measures since mass protests rocked the city last year, with regular scenes of violence in the streets.

Activists have fled and political parties have disbanded following Beijing's passing of a new National Security Law in June, which criminalises vague acts including "subversion" and "collusion with foreign or external forces".

The move on Wednesday to remove the four lawmakers has been internationally condemned, with the US calling it a move towards "one-party dictatorship".

The resignation of 15 of their colleagues in response will leave a once-vibrant legislature filled with politicians seen as loyal to the Chinese authorities.

In a last act of defiance, one opposition lawmaker unfurled a banner in the assembly building on Thursday saying the city's leader, Carrie Lam, was hurting Hong Kong.

"She will stink for 10,000 years," it read.

image copyrightReuters
image captionA last act of defiance from Hong Kong's opposition

China's Hong Kong and Macau Affairs Office on Thursday said the mass walk-out openly challenged the Chinese government's authority and the Basic Law, Hong Kong's mini-constitution.

It also said the move showed pro-democracy lawmakers' "stance of stubborn resistance" against the central government.

"If these lawmakers hope to make use of their resignation to provoke radical opposition and beg for foreign interference, they have miscalculated," a spokesperson said.

Ms Lam has defended the disqualifications as being lawful.

What led to this?

On Wednesday, a resolution passed by China's National People's Congress Standing Committee said lawmakers should be disqualified if they support Hong Kong independence, refuse to acknowledge China's sovereignty, ask foreign forces to interfere in the city's affairs, or in other ways threaten national security.

Immediately afterwards, Hong Kong dismissed four opposition members of the city's Legislative Council (LegCo).

Later, another 15 pro-democracy lawmakers announced they would resign en masse in solidarity. On Thursday, they were absent from their seats in the LegCo.

media captionPro-democracy lawmaker Claudio Mo: "They are forcing us to quit"

One of the lawmakers who resigned, Wu Chi-wai, told reporters the developments made it clear that Beijing was undermining Hong Kong's autonomy.

"I can only say that, it is the [plot] that the Beijing government has been drawing for a long time and today they get to the end of the story and tell the whole world that 'one country, two systems' has come to an end," he said.

But pro-democracy activists, he said, "cannot give up" even if "it takes a long time, maybe generations".

The city's 70-seat legislature has 21 opposition members. Only two of those will now remain in the parliament.

Why were the four dismissed and who are they?

City officials said they had already been disqualified from running in the next election, originally scheduled for September 2020 but postponed to next year.

Beijing and Hong Kong officials have not given details on how exactly the four men had contravened the rules but here is what we know about them. All four are considered moderates and they have never supported Hong Kong independence.

image copyrightReuters
image captionAlvin Yeung Ngok-kiu, Kwok Ka-ki, Kenneth Leung and Dennis Kwok

Alvin Yeung: Leader of the pro-democracy Civic party and a practising barrister. He was banned from taking part in this year's election after he signed a joint letter to US senators calling for sanctions on Hong Kong

Dennis Kwok: The barrister is a founding member of the Civic Party. He was earlier accused of paralysing LegCo by using filibustering tactics, in a move the Chinese government called "malicious". He was banned from elections after signing the sanctions letter

Kenneth Leung: The senior tax consultant is a member of the pro-democracy parliamentary group, the Professionals Guild. According to news site SCMP, officials barred him from the elections after accusing him of indirectly appealing to the US government for sanctions

Kwok Ka-ki: The Civic Party member was also barred from contesting in this year's elections. However, the urologist did not sign the joint letter or attend a trip to the US. Officials said he had a "purported intention to call on foreign powers to sanction Hong Kong", according to SCMP

What does this mean for Hong Kong?

The developments underscore the rapid expansion of Beijing's influence in the territory, pushing for loyalty from all levels of power.

Observers say that without the pro-democracy lawmakers, there will be no effective opposition and LegCo will be reduced to a rubberstamp parliament.

The city's leader is already chosen by pro-Beijing committees, and only half of the LegCo seats are directly elected.

Under the terms of the handover between Britain and China, Hong was meant to have its own legal system, multiple political parties, and rights including freedom of assembly and free speech for 50 years.

The "one country, two systems" principle - named so because such rights do not exist elsewhere in China - is enshrined in the Basic Law.

image copyrightEPA
image captionHong Kong has seen waves of sometimes violent protests

What has been the reaction?

The US has warned it will impose further sanctions against China targeting those responsible for extinguishing Hong Kong's freedoms.

"'One country, two systems' is now merely a fig leaf covering for the Chinese Communist Party's expanding one party dictatorship in Hong Kong," US National Security Adviser Robert O'Brien said.

UK Foreign Secretary Dominic Raab said: "This campaign to harass, stifle and disqualify democratic opposition tarnishes China's international reputation and undermines Hong Kong's long-term stability."

image copyrightReuters
image captionHong Kong's LegCo - critics say it will now merely be a rubber-stamp legislature

Germany, current holder of the EU's rotating presidency, and Australia have also offered condemnations.

But Chinese foreign ministry spokesman Wang Wenbin on Wednesday said the disqualification of the four lawmakers was "rational, reasonable and in line with the constitution and laws".

Related Topics

More on this story