- South African miners fear more lives could be lost to TB because healthcare systems are focusing on Covid-19.
- This is especially concerning because TB treatment has not always been available even under normal conditions.
- Miners often refuse to get tested for TB since they may lose their jobs if they are positive.
Vama Jele's heart dropped every time he heard another migrant miner home from South Africa had died from tuberculosis due to skipping treatment under the lockdown. In just four months, it happened 60 times.
When Covid-19 shut South Africa's mines, workers from Jele's homeland, eSwatini, and other neighbouring nations rushed home - disrupting TB care for thousands of miners at high risk from the disease due to weakened lungs after years working underground.
Jele - the secretary-general of a migrant mineworkers' association in eSwatini - said more lives could now be lost to TB as overstretched healthcare systems prioritise Covid-19.
"There's such a strong focus on Covid-19 that everyone is forgetting about TB and other non-communicable diseases, and this contributes to more deaths," he added.
Patients, who did not consistently take the full course of several months' medication, could spread drug-resistant TB, which was TB that was resistant to common medications, according to the World Bank.
Industry
Home to the world's third-largest mining industry, South Africa draws about 45 000 mineworkers from surrounding countries such as Botswana, eSwatini, Lesotho, Malawi, Mozambique, Namibia and Zimbabwe, making up about 10% of the workforce.
It was both an economy booster and a TB hotspot due to enclosed, dusty working conditions underground, said Cleopas Sibanda, the programme manager for the Wits Health Consortium, a health research unit in Johannesburg.
There were 2 500 to 3 000 TB cases reported per 100 000 mineworkers in Southern Africa, according to the World Bank, a rate 10 times higher than what the World Health Organisation (WHO) classifies as an epidemic emergency.
"Miners have a three times higher chance of getting TB than the average person," said Sibanda, a doctor.
"Those miners that made it home, like many from Swaziland, may not have access to proper treatment. And all this focus on stopping Covid-19 means we could lose more lives to TB," he added.
Swaziland is the former name for eSwatini, a nation bordered by South Africa and Mozambique that is home to 1.2 million people.
Lethal
The Minerals Council South Africa, which represents mining firms, said TB death estimates of miners from other southern African countries during lockdown were not known yet, but mines were doing regular screening for TB and the coronavirus.
By mid-October, 190 mining employees had died from Covid-19, the council said.
But echoing Jele's concerns, Sibanda said he feared TB sufferers could be overlooked as Covid-19 draws attention and funding by governments, charities and businesses.
"For example, in South Africa, government allocated R500 billion to the Covid response in six months. HIV and TB usually draw R30 billion per year," he told the Thomson Reuters Foundation.
"When you look at the morbidity of TB and HIV, they are more lethal than Covid, yet Covid-19 is getting the lion's share."
In South Africa, about 19 000 people have died from Covid-19. That compared with 58 000 deaths in the country from TB last year, according to the latest WHO data.
According to the WHO's 2020 Global Tuberculosis report, 43 countries have started using GeneXpert machines - typically used for rapidly diagnosing TB - for coronavirus testing instead.
The report said the Covid-19 pandemic "threatens to reverse recent progress in reducing the global burden of TB disease."
'Steals your oxygen'
Sibanda and Jele warned helping illegal, informal miners was an even bigger challenge.
An estimated 30 million people were involved in artisanal or small-scale mining globally and 30 to 40% of this took place in Africa, according to the African Minerals Development Centre, a mining research body run by the UN in Ethiopia.
In Mpumalanga, thousands of retrenched miners from different countries, or those seeking better pay, go underground nearly every day to mine coal.
Despite the lockdown, the informal miners kept working.
Bongizwe Madonsela, 67, current head of safety at an informal mine in the coal-mining town of Ermelo, has silicosis - lung scarring from inhaling silica dust.
"It feels like a bad flu, one that steals your oxygen," said Madonsela who added most of the miners he worked with have lung diseases such as asthma, TB and silicosis.
Like many others, he has been worried about going to the clinic for treatment, fearing he could catch Covid-19.
Informal
Many miners, both formal and informal, were scared to get tested as they might be removed from the workforce, resulting in a loss of income, Sibanda said.
"We are afraid to get sick at the mines too, but hunger got the best of us," Madonsela said, pointing out the absence of protective equipment such as facemasks as miners emerged from the shaft lugging sacks of coal.
But as lockdown restrictions are lifted, southern Africa's migrant miners are heading back to their former workplaces.
"Thus far, around 11 300 or 75% of foreign employees who left the country during the lockdown have returned to work. Around 3 800 foreign employees are outstanding," said Charmane Russell, a Minerals Council spokesperson
Mining companies were committed to screening all employees for TB and HIV at least once per year, Russell said, adding those infected with either receive comprehensive treatment.
Sibanda said universal screening for miners with TB, some of whom would not return to the workforce, was vital for stopping the disease's spread into communities, and for saving lives.