Israeli actress Gal Gadot, who became a household name across the world after she starred as Wonder Woman, is once again in news for reprising yet another historic role. Gadot is set to play the role of the Egyptian princess Cleopatra in the upcoming film set on her life.
Gadot is teaming up with her Wonder Woman director Patty Jenkins to play Cleopatra in a period biographical drama scripted by Laeta Kalogridis.
The news of her casting, however, has caused a tonne of outrage on social media. Many have since slammed the Israeli actress's decision to portray an Arab character.
But what is the outrage all about?
Critics claimed that it was unfair for Gadot, an Israeli, to play the role of an Arab historical figure, given the history of contention between Israelis and Arabs. The tensions stem from the Israel-Palestine conflict, the ongoing territorial conflict between the two nations which began in the mid-20th century and has caused immense death and destruction. Critics of Israel have in thep ast slammed the Israeli occupation of the West Bank which has now been ongoing for 53 years now. Egypt, also an Arab country, has also chared contentious history with Israel, culminating in several wars including Yom Kippur War in 1973. It was only after 1979 that the Israel-Egypt peace treaty was formed. Given the history, many have questioned Gadot's move to play the Arab princess instead of an Arab actress playing the role. Some have gone as far as to call her a "zionist".
Which Hollywood dumbass thought it would be a good idea to cast an Israeli actress as Cleopatra (a very bland looking one) instead of a stunning Arab actress like Nadine Njeim?And shame on you, Gal Gadot. Your country steals Arab land & you’re stealing their movie roles... smh. https://t.co/GY5tYEcl4K pic.twitter.com/JcrnM1RUQq
— sameera khan (@SameeraKhan) October 11, 2020
the level of disrespect is unbelievable. you are ISRAELI. portraying an ARAB figure. this is not going to end well.
— danyah ♌︎ 🎃 (@ddvniii) October 12, 2020
me digging up cleopatra so she can stop zionist gal gadot from portraying her pic.twitter.com/VARQ4Lqptv
— ً (@RVAINDROPS) October 11, 2020
1. there are so many talented arabs (or egyptians in that matter) hollywood could’ve at least searched for an egyptian actress for the role instead of handing it to a zionist and whitewashing one of the most powerful leaders in our history.
— ray 🍂 | pinned!! (@lustbarnes) October 11, 2020
Accusations of racism
But her Israeli ancestry was not the only bone of contention. Many on social media also claimed that choosing Gadot would lead to a historically inaccurate representation of Cleopatra. Many questioned why the role was not given to a woman of colour such as Zendaya or Lupita Nyongo.
the level of disrespect is unbelievable. you are ISRAELI. portraying an ARAB figure. this is not going to end well.
— danyah ♌︎ 🎃 (@ddvniii) October 12, 2020
How you gonna cast Gal Gadot to play Cleopatra when Lupita is RIGHT THERE?!?
— Justina Ireland (@justinaireland) October 11, 2020
Why we casting Gal Gadot as Cleopatra when we have a whole icon named Zendaya pic.twitter.com/4MlLDpINDr
— Joshua Chenault (@joshuachenault1) October 11, 2020
But was Cleaoptra really Arab?
Fans of Gadot and history buffs, however, pointed out that Cleopatra was not Arab at all but Greek. Cleopatra, the last ruling member of the Ptolemaic dynasty in Egypt, was indeed not Arab but of Macedonian descent. The Ptolemaic dynasty in Egypt descended from the Macedonian-Greek ruler Ptolemy. Macedonians were an ancient Greek tribe. This means Cleopatra was not Arab black, she was the Macedonian Greek ruler of an Arab country.
Is the outrage against Gal Gadot fair?
This is not the first time that Gadot, who became a beauty queen at age 18 in 2004 and then went on to join the Israeli Army, has caused controversy. Gadot joined the Israeli Defence Forces to finish her two years of mandatory military training. In 2014, right before the release of her new DC movie Batman v. Superman: Dawn of Justice, she had stirred controversy as being "pro-IDF" after she shared a post in support of the forces on her Facebook page. She also put up a photograph pf herself and her little daughter praying for the Israeli troops, weeks after Israel launched Operation Protective Edge.
Many on social media also supported Gadot, claiming that the criticism against her was slightly uninformed.
I'm going to say this once and I'm not going to say it again, Cleopatra was Greek.Yes, she was in Egyptian ruler but she was Greek with Persian and Syrian ancestry. The people who are reacting negatively that to this are uneducated and uninformed.Gal Gadot deserves this role. pic.twitter.com/7h1oYu9ClX
— The Moonlight Warrior 🌙 (@BlackMajikMan90) October 11, 2020
Whatever you think of her being cast as Cleopatra, never forget that Gal Gadot proudly served (and continues to support) a colonial army notorious for maiming and murdering civilians.
— Steven Salaita (@stevesalaita) October 11, 2020
Others, however, reminded the world that despite Cleopatra not being Arab, the support for Gadot must come with a pinch of salt as she does indeed support the IDF.
3. ancient egypt is more than you can ever imagine and it angers us when we see white people and americans or non-arabians/egyptians portray it. so many films have been made about our history and not a single arab has participated in it.
— ray 🍂 | pinned!! (@lustbarnes) October 11, 2020
Others also defended her Greek nationality, claiming that just because she was of Greek descent, made her no less Egyptian than anyone else."The fact that Hollywood keeps on producing movies about Arab history without casting ONE middle eastern actor is so offensive, disgusting and frustrating," a critic wrote on Twitter.