Supreme Court stays telecast of show on UPSC exam that tries to vilify particular community

The Supreme Court on Tuesday stayed the telecast of the remaining episodes of a TV channel's programme which claimed to expose the 'infiltration of a particular community' in Union Public Service Commission (UPSC), till further orders.


Supreme Court

Share

Written By

Source

ANI

Updated: Sep 15, 2020, 09:32 PM IST

The Supreme Court on Tuesday stayed the telecast of the remaining episodes of a TV channel's programme which claimed to expose the 'infiltration of a particular community' in Union Public Service Commission (UPSC), till further orders.

A two-judge bench of the apex court, headed by Justice DY Chandrahud, ordered the stay after hearing submissions on a public interest litigation (PIL) filed by Firoz Iqbal Khan against the telecast of the programme and slated it for further hearing on Thursday. “Here is one anchor who says one particular community is trying to infiltrate UPSC. Can anything be more insidious (than such claims). Such allegations affect the stability of the country and also cast aspersions on the credibility of the UPSC exam,” Justice Chandrachud remarked.

Senior lawyer Anoop George Chaudhari, appearing for the petitioner, said this is a prima facie case of violation of law adding that the Delhi High Court had earlier issued a notice after hearing the plea challenging the go-ahead given by the Information and Broadcasting (I&B) Ministry.

"If you read and hear the transcript, you will see that they say Muslims are infiltrating the civil services. They say how Muslim, OBCs are eating the share of other OBCs," Chaudhari said.

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta said that so far as pre-publication restraint is concerned, there is a law laid down in some case way back in 1891. The bench said that it needs to look at the ownership of the visual media.

"Most of the electronic media and channels are based on TRP and revenue model, so many things may be seen to be beamed on the name of popularity," Justice Kurian Joseph, one of the judges in the bench, observed.

Advocate Sadan Farasat, the lawyer for one of the parties, submitted that it is a clear vilification of the Muslim community. "Hate speech is what? It demeans one's individuals dignity and respect. It is demeaning one`s dignity," Farasat said.

Accusing the channel of targeting a particular community, he said that the show starts with ISIS face shots and added that this is nothing but hate speech and communalising something, which is not communal."The show basically means all Muslims coming to the UPSC are Jihadis. This is incorrect. This may be done under the guise of investigative journalism," Farasat said.

Senior lawyer Shyam Diwan, appearing for the channel, said that this is a case of foreign funding and "we have evidence to show that".

Diwan further said that the petitioner, who is a lawyer, has instituted this petition and claimed that the show is an insult to a particular community. "The airing of the show is a violation of Cable TV Act, the petitioner has alleged," Diwan argued.

The top court had earlier declined to stay the telecast but agreed to examine the larger issue of balancing of free speech, with other constitutional values, including the fundamental right to equality and fair treatment for every segment of citizens.

Supreme Court stays telecast of show on UPSC exam that tries to vilify particular community

Madhya Pradesh Foodgrain Crackdown Faces Selective Action Allegations

Madhya Pradesh Foodgrain Crackdown Faces "Selective Action" Allegations

The Mhow racket diverted food grain and kerosene from targeted PDS into the open market, while in Anuppur, over 2,200 quintals of rice had disappeared from a warehouse rented by the by food and civil supplies corporation

Madhya Pradesh Foodgrain Crackdown Faces 'Selective Action' Allegations

Madhya Pradesh is investigating a public distribution system scam (Representational)

Bhopal:

The Madhya Pradesh government has launched a crackdown after the Prime Minister's Office sought a report on allegations that poor quality rice was sent to the state's tribal heartland via a compromised public distribution system amid the coronavirus lockdown.

NDTV had reported about poor quality rice being given to tribes in Balaghat and Mandla through the public distribution system or PDS.

The state government's action, however, was seen as "selective" as a syndicate comprising transporters, food grain traders and government employees in Mhow was busted, but another one in Anuppur was left unscathed.

Anuppur is the constituency of Food and Civil Supplies Minister Bishaulal Singh. This constituency is among 27 in the state where by-elections are due.

The Mhow racket diverted food grain and kerosene from targeted PDS into the open market, while in Anuppur, over 2,200 quintals of rice had disappeared from a warehouse rented by the by food and civil supplies corporation. No police complaint has been filed even a year after the incident came to light.

According to Indore district administration sources, following a complaint in Mhow sub-division, a warehouse named Harshit Traders, owned by Mohit Agrawal, was raided. Mohit Agrawal is the son of Mhow Congress unit executive president Mohanlal Agrawal, who is also a registered transporter of the state civil supplies corporation.

The raid found over 600 bags of rice meant for supply under the targeted PDS and the bills for those rice bags were found to be forged.

Investigators say the food grain meant for PDS were first sent to fair-price shops. Some of these shops then signed receipts acknowledging they have got the entire quantity of food grain. But 8 to 10 quintals would be taken out of the sealed bags and given to Mr Agrawal's men, who paid the fair-price shop owners, sources said. The fair-price shop owners would then distribute less food grain and kerosene to targeted PDS beneficiaries than what was actually allotted to them.

Initial findings suggest the "stolen" food grain and kerosene could be worth Rs 50 crore, Indore District Collector Manish Singh said.

But since Mohanlal Agrawal has been a registered transporter under targeted PDS for over 15 years, the actual volume of food grain diverted to the open market could be much higher, sources have said.

"A state civil supplies corporation employee and others involved in the scam have been charged," Mr Singh said.

In Anuppur, the constituency of the Food and Civil Supplies Minister, the managing director of the civil supplies corporation had written to the regional manager Ravi Singh instructing him to file a police complaint and recover the food grain. But a year has passed, and the First Information Report (FIR) has not been filed yet, sources said.

In July and August, the lab analysis of 32 samples of PDS rice collected from government depots and one fair-price shop in Balaghat and Mandla by teams of the Consumer Affairs Ministry had found that they were not fit for human consumption, but could be used as feed for livestock, cattle and poultry.

On September 3, after NDTV reported the lapses, Chief Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan handed over the probe in the entire matter to the Economic Offences Wing.

Supreme Court stays telecast of show on UPSC exam that tries to vilify particular community

Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny shares first photo from Berlin hospital

Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny shares first photo from Berlin hospital

"I still can’t do many things, but yesterday I could breathe by myself the whole day,” Navalny said in an Instagram post from a Berlin hospital.

Breaking News Emails

Get breaking news alerts and special reports. The news and stories that matter, delivered weekday mornings.
SUBSCRIBE
By Yuliya Talmazan

Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny on Tuesday released in his first photo since being poisoned last month, looking gaunt but alert from his hospital bed in Berlin.

Navalny posed with his wife, Yulia, and two children, who were wearing masks and hospital gowns.

Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny posing for a selfie picture with his family at Berlin's Charite hospital on Sept. 15, 2020.@navalny / AFP - Getty Images

“I still can’t do many things, but yesterday I could breathe by myself the whole day,” Navalny said in the Instagram post, which has been "liked" by more than 500,000 people. “I did not use any outside help, not even the simplest valve in my throat.”

“I liked it a lot,” he quipped, adding that he “misses everyone.”

Navalny, 44, a foe of Russian President Vladimir Putin's, fell ill on a flight from Tomsk, a Siberian city where he and his team were conducting a corruption investigation, to Moscow on Aug. 20.

The plane was forced to make an emergency landing, and Navalny was hospitalized and put in an induced coma and on a ventilator. Doctors in Russia speculated that he may have suffered from a metabolic disease.

On the insistence of his family, Navalny was later flown to Berlin, where the German government said he had been poisoned by a military-grade nerve agent similar to the one the British government said was used to poison former Russian spy Sergei Skripal and his daughter Yulia in the U.K. in 2018.

A German government spokesman, Steffen Seibert, said Monday that the initial findings had now been independently corroborated by laboratories in France and Sweden.

German Chancellor Angela Merkel called the findings “disturbing” and demanded that the Russian government explain the use of the nerve agent, raising international pressure on Moscow and further straining its already frail relationship with the West.

The Kremlin has said they have not seen the results of the German investigation and insisted there is no definitive proof that Navalny was poisoned.

Download the NBC News app for breaking news and politics

In Russia, the ruling United Russia party suffered setbacks in votes for two Siberian City Councils contested by supporters of Navalny despite securing landslide wins elsewhere at weekend regional elections.

Navalny had promoted a tactical voting strategy to challenge United Russia and disrupt a political system in which outspoken Kremlin critics are often barred from competing. His allies have pressed ahead with the strategy despite his illness.

Navalny rose to prominence in 2009 with investigations into official corruption and became a protest leader when hundreds of thousands took to the streets across Russia in 2011 to protest electoral fraud.

A few years later, and after several short-term spells in jail, Navalny faced two separate sets of fraud charges, which were viewed as political retribution aimed at stopping him from running for office.

Navalny’s anti-corruption foundation has conducted in-depth investigations into the highest ranks of the Russian political elite, including his most famous investigation into former Prime Minister and President Dmitry Medvedev.