Daniel Andrews slams Scott Morrison's threat to tear up his controversial deal with China and insists the agreement does not pose a danger to Australia

  • Victoria made a deal with China under the country's Belt and Road Initiative 
  • Several government politicians fear it is harming Australia's national interest 
  • Prime minister wants to pass a new law that could lead to deal being scrapped
  • The proposed new law will require states to get permission for foreign deals
  • Premier Daniel Andrews slammed the laws and said the deal is not a threat  

Daniel Andrews has slammed Scott Morrison's plan to rip up deals that states have made with foreign powers.

In his press conference on Thursday, the Victoria Premier stood by his controversial deal with China and said it did not pose a national security threat. 

Mr Andrews said he was only told about the prime minister's plan last night and criticised him for not focusing on fighting coronavirus.

Victoria's Belt and Road deal will also be examined. Pictured: Premier Daniel Andrews and Chinese ambassador Jingye Cheng

Victoria's Belt and Road deal will also be examined. Pictured: Premier Daniel Andrews and Chinese ambassador Jingye Cheng

The prime minister wants new laws to stop states and territories signing deals with foreign powers that go against Australia's national interest

The prime minister wants new laws to stop states and territories signing deals with foreign powers that go against Australia's national interest

'Well, look, if the Prime Minister has time to be doing those things, that's fine for him,' he said.

'I don't. I'm exclusively focused on fighting this virus.'

The prime minister wants new laws to stop states and territories signing deals with foreign powers that go against Australia's foreign policy and damage the national interest.

If the laws pass, Victoria's 2018 agreement to increase Chinese participation in building projects, manufacturing and trade could be cancelled.

Mr Andrews demanded to know what alternatives Victoria would have if it was banned from making deals with China that he believes create local jobs.

Daniel Andrews (pictured in China's Tiananmen Square) signed a deal with China under the country's controversial Belt and Road Initiative in October 2018

Daniel Andrews (pictured in China's Tiananmen Square) signed a deal with China under the country's controversial Belt and Road Initiative in October 2018

Sydney's partnership with the Chinese city of Guangzhou will also come under scrutiny. Pictured: Sydney Lord Mayor Clover Moore welcomes Guangzhou Vice Mayor Mr Wang Dong

Sydney's partnership with the Chinese city of Guangzhou will also come under scrutiny. Pictured: Sydney Lord Mayor Clover Moore welcomes Guangzhou Vice Mayor Mr Wang Dong

'Given the announcements the Prime Minister has made today he will no doubt be able to list the full range of other free trade agreements and other markets that we'll be sending Victorian products to. I'll look forward to that,' Mr Andrews said.

'Presumably this approach will include quite soon a very detailed list of alternative trading arrangements, alternative free trade agreements, alternative markets. 

'I'll leave that to the PM to announce, but presumably that's coming and coming pretty quickly.'  

Asked if his deal with China threatens national security, Mr Andrews said: 'No, I would never concede that point.' 

Several federal politicians, fearing the expansion of Chinese power and influence, have urged the Victorian government to scrap its deal under China's Belt and Road Initiative - but it has refused. 

Under the proposed law, the foreign minister will be able to terminate the deal and any private contracts that are part of it. 

Once the law is in place, governments and universities will have six months to reveal their foreign deals to the foreign minister, who will then decide which ones must be stopped.

The Belt and Road Initiative is a Chinese plan to establish maritime trade routes and invest in infrastructure projects around the world, set up by President Xi Xinping (pictured) in 2013

The Belt and Road Initiative is a Chinese plan to establish maritime trade routes and invest in infrastructure projects around the world, set up by President Xi Xinping (pictured) in 2013

The Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (pictured) is an example of a project being financed by China under the country's Belt and Road Initiative

The Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (pictured) is an example of a project being financed by China under the country's Belt and Road Initiative

The law will cover dozens of deals with China and other nations including India and Israel in areas such as culture, education, health, science, tourism, infrastructure and even sister-city arrangements. 

It will also require states get approval from the federal government to start negotiating a foreign deal and seek approval again when the negotiations are done.

Under current laws, states can make a deal and not even tell the foreign minister for three months.

Daniel Andrews caused outrage by only telling the Morrison government about his Belt and Road agreement on the day it was signed. 

Home Affairs Minister Peter Dutton described the Belt and Road Initiative as 'a propaganda initiative from China' that could lead to an 'enormous amount of foreign interference'.

He said: 'Victoria needs to explain why it is the only state in the country that has entered into this agreement.'

Federal Liberal MP Andrew Hastie told Daily Mail Australia that Mr Andrews had 'gone off the reservation by conducting his own foreign policy with China'. 

In May Victoria Treasurer Tim Pallas told a parliamentary inquiry the state government would 'absolutely not' scrap the deal.

He then accused the federal government of 'vilifying' China by pushing for an inquiry into coronavirus. 

This graphic shows how the existing laws work.  Under current laws, the state can make a foreign deal and not even tell the foreign minister for three months

This graphic shows how the existing laws work.  Under current laws, the state can make a foreign deal and not even tell the foreign minister for three months

This graphic shows how the new law will require states get approval from the federal government to start negotiating a foreign deal and seek approval again when the negotiations are done

The Australia's Foreign Relations (State and Territory Arrangements) Bill 2020 will be put before federal parliament next week in the hope it will be signed off this year.

Scott Morrison said: 'Australia's foreign policies and relationships must always be set to serve Australia's interests. 

'Australians rightly expect the federal government they elect to set foreign policy. 

'These changes and new laws will ensure that every arrangement done by any Australian government at any level now lines up with how we are working to protect and promote Australia's national interest.

He added: 'Many agreements and partnerships are of a routine nature but it is important that the federal government is notified of all agreements.

'Where any of these agreements undermine how the federal government is protecting and promoting our national interests they can be cancelled.'    

Daniel Andrews' deal with China 

In October 2018, the Victorian Labor government signed a memo of understanding with China under the country's Belt and Road Initiative.

The BRI is a Chinese plan to establish maritime trade routes and invest in infrastructure projects around the world.

More than 170 memos of understanding have been signed with 125 countries. 

Premier Andrews said he wanted to increase Chinese participation in Victorian building projects, manufacturing, and trade. 

Pictured: Chinese President Xi Jinping (left) and Premier Li Keqiang on May 22

Pictured: Chinese President Xi Jinping (left) and Premier Li Keqiang on May 22

In October 2019, Mr Andrews reached a 'framework agreement' with China that vowed to make a roadmap for cooperation on specific initiatives.

So far the roadmap has not been published. 

Critics say the BRI is a tool to expand influence and power across the globe. 

Federal Liberal MP Andrew Hastie told Daily Mail Australia that Mr Andrews had 'gone off the reservation by conducting his own foreign policy with China'.  

As trade tensions with China mount, Mr Andrews has been urged to scrap the agreement, which he claims creates jobs for Victorians.  

Michael Schoebridge of the Australian Strategic Policy Institute, said: 'The Victorian government's BRI activities are simply out of step with the new international and economic environment, including the now openly coercive directions that Beijing is taking with Canberra over trade and in government relations.' 

Victorian Labor senator Kimberley Kitching, chair of the Senate Foreign Affairs Defence and Trade References Committee, said: 'The Victorian government should not have entered into an agreement with the Chinese government on the Belt and Road Initiative - it is bad policy and bad optics.'  

Advertisement

It comes amid increasing political and economic tensions between Australia and China. 

Beijing and Canberra have been at loggerheads after Australia led global calls for an inquiry into the origins of Covid-19.

Soon afterwards, China slapped an 80 per cent tariff on Australian barley, suspended beef imports and told students and tourists not to travel Down Under in an apparent attempt to damage the Australian economy.

On Tuesday Treasurer Josh Frydenberg blocked a $600million bid by Chinese company Mengniu Dairy to buy Aussie drinks company Lion, citing national security concerns.

Minister Wang Xining (pictured) poses for a photo at the National Press Club in Canberra

Minister Wang Xining (pictured) poses for a photo at the National Press Club in Canberra

On Wednesday Wang Xining, deputy head of mission at the Chinese embassy in Canberra, said Chinese people felt deeply betrayed by Mr Morrison's call for independent scientists to enter China and investigate coronavirus.

'All of a sudden, there was this shocking proposal from Australia, supposed to be a good friend of China,' he said.

'It is approximately identical to Julius Caesar on his final day when he saw Brutus approaching him and said et tu, Brute?' 

Minister Wang admitted the virus was 'first identified' in China but said 'we should leave the work to scientists' to find out where patient zero came from.    

ScoMo's crackdown: Some of the China deals under threat 

States

2011 Memo of understanding (MOU) between the Government of Western Australia and the National Development and Reform Commission of China on Promotion of Investment Cooperation 

2013 MOU between NSW and Beijing on Trade and Economy, Culture, Education, Science and Technology, Tourism and Sport 

2014 MOU between Queensland Department of Environment and Science and Chinese Ministry of Science and Technology 

2016 Shandong-South Australia Science and Technology Commercialisation Cooperation Platform 

2017 MOU on Antarctic Gateway Cooperation between the Government of Tasmania and the State Oceanic Administration of China

2018 MOU between Victoria and China's National Development and Reform Commission within the Belt and Road Initiative 

Local governments

2014 MOU between the city of Sydney and Guangzhou, relating to education, trade, culture, business and sustainability 

2018 MOU between Mildura City Council and the Wuhan Institute of Technology

2019 MOU of establishing strategic partnership of cooperation for trade and investment between Nanjing Bureau of Commerce and City of Melbourne 

2015 MOU for the establishment of a Shandong-South Australian Local Government Economic Development Cooperation Forum 

Universities 

2017 MOU between ANU and the University of South China on research collaboration on fusion energy technology

2019 MOU between UNSW and Qingdoa City to establish the Qingdao International Academician Park (QIAP)

2019 Agreement to establishing the Monash Technology Transformation Institute in the Pingshan District of Shenzhen

2019 University of Queensland agreement with the Confucius Institute on its Headquaters in China 

Advertisement

Daniel Andrews slams Scott Morrison over China deal

No comments have so far been submitted. Why not be the first to send us your thoughts, or debate this issue live on our message boards.

What's This?

By posting your comment you agree to our house rules.