The U.S. Can’t Wait Half a Decade for a Jobs Recovery

(Bloomberg Opinion) -- With Congress set to tackle the next phase of economic relief this month, Thursday's jobs report provided more evidence of how much permanent damage is being done to the labor market by the coronavirus pandemic. The number of workers being permanently laid off continues to grow even as millions of Americans who were furloughed have gone back to work.Expectations for how long it will take to get the labor market back to where it was at the beginning of the year are fluid, but some, such as San Francisco Federal Reserve President Mary Daly, are saying it could take the economy a half-decade to recover even after the public-health crisis ends. If it does take that long, that would represent a failure by Congress and fiscal policy makers to learn the hard lessons of the past decade. In an environment of low inflation and low interest rates, fiscal stimulus can and should be used much more aggressively to support workers and the economy..The job of economic policy makers during the next year should be twofold. First, to keep households, businesses, and state and local governments afloat for the duration of the crisis. Thanks to the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (Cares) Act the U.S. has done a good job of that so far for households. The results are more mixed for businesses, while state and local governments need much more support than they've gotten so far. After the pandemic is over and it's safe to fully reopen the economy, which may be during the next presidential term, more aggressive fiscal policy will be crucial..The end of the Covid-19crisis, which is at best an early 2021 story, might sound like a long way off, but we're at the point in the election cycle when both political parties are coming up with their agendas. The country's 17 million unemployed workers deserve to know that this president or his successor and Congress will mount a robust response to unacceptably high levels of unemployment..That's why it's dangerous and wrong for Daly and others to put forth the low expectations of a prolonged multiyear recovery for the jobs market. If there's one lesson we should have learned from the Great Recession and the slow expansion that followed, it's that budget deficits, growth in the national debt and monetary expansion undertaken by the Fed did not create runaway inflation or dollar debasement as the pessimists feared. There was scope for both fiscal and monetary policy to be used more assertively to support the labor market and the economy..The Fed does seem to have learned its lesson. Unlike in 2009, when the yield on 10-year Treasuries was more than 3% as investors anticipated an eventual tightening of monetary policy, there's no such expectation today. Fed Chairman Powell said last month that the central bank isn't "even thinking about thinking about raising rates." Fed policy makers have also talked about the value of using fiscal policy to support the labor market, recognizing that monetary stimulus has its limits..Fiscal policy doesn't have the same limits. An extreme example would be World War II, when the U.S. government increased its headcount by 50% between 1940 and 1942. We've seen with the Cares Act that when Congress is sufficiently motivated it can approve trillions of dollars in spending, send checks to households and supplement the income of workers who have been furloughed or laid off as a result of the pandemic. The constraints are political, not economic..Assuming there's a vaccine sometime between the end of the year and the spring of 2021, which still seems plausible, a goal for the next administration should be to restore employment to early 2020 levels by the 2022 midterm elections through payments to households, government spending and hiring directly. Since the onset of the pandemic we've seen companies such as grocery chains, Target, Walmart and Amazon recruit tens or hundreds of thousands of workers quickly, driven by rising demand. There's no reason other employers wouldn't do the same in amid a strong economic rebound..It's possible the U.S. will fall short: maybe too many small businesses will fail during the next six months or inflation makes an unexpected return that calls aggressive stimulus plans into question. But the reason for falling short shouldn't be that Congress didn't try hard enough or didn't appropriate enough money. There's no moral hazard here that demands a cautious approach by policy makers. This should be about the government pumping as much money into the economy as it takes to make workers whole for a crisis that wasn't their fault. Resigning the U.S. to a recovery that eats up a half-decade isn't acceptable..This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners..Conor Sen is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist. He has been a contributor to the Atlantic and Business Insider..©2020 Bloomberg L.P.

Bloomberg

Company

Financial Products

Enterprise Products

Media

Customer Support

Communications

Industry Products

Media Services

Follow Us

Bloomberg Customers

BloombergQuint

BloombergQuint

The U.S. Can’t Wait Half a Decade for a Jobs Recovery

Bloomberg Quint