Troubles pension: Sinn Féin rejects revised draft guidelines

Victims of the Troubles in wheelchairs

The latest bid by NI Secretary Brandon Lewis to break the political deadlock over the Troubles pension has failed after Sinn Féin rejected the revised draft guidelines.

The guidelines were presented to the parties this week and were due to be published today.

But that plan has been shelved.

Sinn Féin told BBC News NI that the latest draft guidelines still discriminate against former prisoners and it cannot support them.

The party also said the guidelines go beyond what is in the legislation.

However, the Northern Ireland Office has disagreed.

Along with the DUP, it has accused Sinn Féin of blocking the pension payments by refusing to nominate the Justice Department to oversee the scheme.

Earlier, Prime Minister Boris Johnson said it is "very important" that a stalled pension for Troubles victims begins as soon as possible.

The draft guidelines on the Troubles pension will set out how a judge-led panel will decide who is entitled to payment.

During prime minister's questions, DUP MP Sir Jeffrey Donaldson called on the government to push for the scheme to begin immediately.

Image copyright Press Association
Image caption Boris Johnson was speaking in the House of Commons on Wednesday

In response, the prime minister said he believed the pension was a "fair, balanced and proportionate way" of helping all those who suffered in the Troubles.

"It's very important that Sinn Féin along with all other parties allow the scheme to go forward as soon as possible," he told the Commons.

Under previous draft guidelines leaked to BBC News NI, former prisoners who served more than 30 months could be refused a pension if there were no other mitigating factors.

The judge could use other "material evidence" to reject applications in "exceptional circumstances".

But the Northern Ireland Office (NIO) said only those injured by their own hand would be excluded.

Others with convictions can apply and the panel will assess their eligibility.

Media playback is unsupported on your device
Media captionThe roots of Northern Ireland’s Troubles lie deep in Irish history

Lawyers representing some people intending to make applications for payments, have written to the secretary of state seeking a number of clarifications, including:

Earlier this week, BBC News NI obtained the three-page "confidential" draft set of guidelines circulated to all the Stormont parties.

The document also detailed the "guiding principles" the judge-led panel should use when assessing applications from those with a "relevant conviction".

These are "generally convictions carrying longer than 30 months".

They apply to the most "serious crimes such as murder, actual bodily harm etc", the paper stated.

Under the guidelines, an application can also be rejected if the president of the board decides the "exceptional circumstances of the case having regard to material evidence" makes payment inappropriate.

That evidence includes:

The Ulster Unionists, SDLP and Alliance have called for the payment scheme to be implemented immediately.

There is also gridlock over whether London or Stormont pays for the scheme, which is estimated to cost much more than the £100m stated.