'I don't want to see more people lose jobs': Incredible war of words between Gladys Berejiklian and Annastacia Palaszczuk continues as NSW premier says border closure is 'ridiculous'

  • A war of words has erupted between the two state leaders over interstate travel 
  • Queensland is taking a very cautious approach to stop the spread of coronavirus 
  • Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk says its her priority to protect Queenslanders 
  • Gladys Berejiklian says the closure is 'ridiculous' and hurting the economy
  • Here’s how to help people impacted by Covid-19

Gladys Berejiklian has called Queensland's border closure 'ridiculous' as her ongoing dispute with Annastacia Palaszczuk continues.

The Sunshine State leader is under pressure to reopen inter-state tourism after it shut down travel in April to slow the spread of the coronavirus

But Ms Palaszczuk is standing firm on her decision, telling reporters she will not bow down to the pleas of southerners. 

'Let me be very clear, we are reviewing this every month. Nothing has changed,' she said.

'We are not going to be lectured to by a state that has the highest number of cases in Australia.

'If you look at the federal government's road map, they do not talk about inter-state travel until July if things are going well.'  

Ms Berejiklian was quick to hit back, telling Triple M Sydney’s Moonman in the Morning the ongoing ban was impacting employment rates.

New South Wales Premier Gladys Berejiklian is calling for other Australian states to open their borders for tourism

Annastacia Palaszczuk (pictured) has hit back at New South Wales Premier Gladys Berjiklian declaring Queenslanders will not be 'lectured to' about opening up their borders

Annastacia Palaszczuk (pictured) has hit back at New South Wales Premier Gladys Berjiklian declaring Queenslanders will not be 'lectured to' about opening up their borders

'I just think it's a bit ridiculous not having people travel a few kilometres over the border to see a loved one and support the tourism industry,' the NSW Premier said.

'In all seriousness we can have these little takes at each other but at the end of the day it comes down to people and what it means for our citizens, we also know trade relations will be disrupted so why can't we look at this as an opportunity for Australia to flourish. 

'I don't want to see more people lose jobs, it's just depressing and that's happening across Australia. 

'A lot of people are worried about losing jobs or have lost their jobs and we've got a chance to get those jobs back if we do it sensibly.'

The war of words began when Ms Berejiklian told the ABC that given the declining rate of infection it does not make sense to keep state borders closed.

'I don't think it's logical to maintain the border closures for a prolonged period of time,' she said.

The refusal of some Australian states to reopen domestic borders to outsiders has highlighted a dilemma set to face the world, as cities, regions or countries emerge from the pandemic at different speeds

The refusal of some Australian states to reopen domestic borders to outsiders has highlighted a dilemma set to face the world, as cities, regions or countries emerge from the pandemic at different speeds

Ms Berejiklian told Triple M Sydney’s Moonman in the Morning (pictureds) the ongoing ban was impacting employment rates

Ms Berejiklian told Triple M Sydney’s Moonman in the Morning (pictureds) the ongoing ban was impacting employment rates

'For Australia to really move forward as a nation during this very difficult economic time, as well as difficult health time, we do need our borders down.'

New South Wales will relax travel rules within the state from June 1 with regional travel allowed for interstate visitors and residents.

But Queensland is still holding firm despite only having 12 active cases of COVID-19, telling its tourism industry to prepare for a likely September reopening of its state borders.

'Unfortunately New South Wales and Victoria have community transmission and they have to get that under control before we allow visitors to come here,' Ms Palaszczuk said.

'We are not the only state, Western Australia has a border closure, Northern Territory has a border closure, South Australia has a border closure and Tasmania has a Border closure. This is not unique to Queensland.'

One Nation leader Pauline Hanson joined the debate on Thursday by threatening to take the Queensland premier to court over the state's controversial decision to keep the borders shut.

Barriers are seen in Coolangatta on the Gold Coast (pictured) on April 7, reinforcing the border separation between Queensland and New South Wales

Barriers are seen in Coolangatta on the Gold Coast (pictured) on April 7, reinforcing the border separation between Queensland and New South Wales

A police officer stops a driver at a checkpoint at Coolangatta on the Queensland New South Wales border on April 9 (pictured)

A police officer stops a driver at a checkpoint at Coolangatta on the Queensland New South Wales border on April 9 (pictured)

'I raised last week that I think it's unconstitutional what the premier of Queensland is doing keeping borders closed for trade and commerce under section 92 of the Australian constitution', Ms Hanson told Sky News.

CORONAVIRUS CASES IN AUSTRALIA: 7,083

New South Wales: 3,084

Victoria: 1,581

Queensland: 1,058

Western Australia: 557

South Australia: 439

Tasmania: 228

Australian Capital Territory: 107

Northern Territory: 29

TOTAL CASES: 7,083

RECOVERED: 6,472

DEATHS: 101

Advertisement

'Speaking to other people, they totally agree with me. 

'I'm calling on Queenslanders who've been affected by either their families being destroyed, or inconvenience or trade.

'Those tourist operators who rely on tourists coming there have had their businesses affected. 

'It's unconstitutional to do what they're doing, it's important to hold her to account and I think it's a political move what she's doing.

'In Queensland, when we've had 1,058 cases, 12 active cases at the moment and four hospitalised, there's no reason to keep the borders closed.

'And they can't give you a timeline on it, they're saying possibly it could be September - that's not good enough.

'When I see my state in dire straits, you've got communities that are dying, we need the tourists from down south coming up through Queensland.

Pauline Hanson (pictured) told Sky News she 'wanted to take the premier on' over her decision to keep the Queensland border shut

Pauline Hanson (pictured) told Sky News she 'wanted to take the premier on' over her decision to keep the Queensland border shut

'I want to take her on.' 

Whereas Western Australian Premier Mark McGowan is backing Ms Palaszczuk, calling Ms Berejiklian a 'bully'.

'New South Wales had the Ruby Princess - I mean, seriously? And they are trying to give us advice on our borders, seriously?' he told reporters.

'We're not going to give in to that sort of bullying by the New South Wales Premier or anyone else - we are going to protect the health and the economy of Western Australia.'

But Australia's deputy chief medical officer disagrees with the cautious approach being taken by the states.

'From a medical point of view, I can't see why the borders are still closed,' Paul Kelly told reporters.

Professor Kelly said there would almost certainly be more cases found as the nation's economy and society began reopening, but the system was designed to find them quickly and minimise transmissions. 

WHICH STATES AND TERRITORIES ARE EASING CORONAVIRUS RESTRICTIONS?

WESTERN AUSTRALIA

* Western Australia is going further than any other state in relaxing coronavirus rules, the government says, amid a mixed reaction to the state's economic roadmap.

* Locals will be encouraged to return to work and take regional holidays, the limit on group gatherings will be doubled to 20 people, and hospitality businesses will be allowed to serve diners under phase two of WA's recovery plan starting next Monday.

* But with just one new case of coronavirus recorded in the past 12 days, the government has faced a backlash for not going further in unwinding restrictions.

* Like restaurants and cafes, pubs will be allowed to reopen but a limit of 20 patrons will apply as well as the one person per four square metres rule, and a requirement for customers to buy a meal if they want to have a drink.

* Students will return to the classroom from May 29.

* WA Premier Mark McGowan said it was a 'cautious relaxation' of restrictions.

NORTHERN TERRITORY

* Parks and reserves have reopened. 

* Weddings, funerals, playgrounds, parks and public swimming pools re-opened from May 1.

* Outdoor sports where people can be physically distant, such as golf and tennis, are allowed.

* Pubs, cafes and restaurants will re-open from May 15. People will be allowed in for two hours.  

QUEENSLAND

* From Saturday 16 May, restaurants, pubs and clubs can have up to 10 patrons at a time

* Stay-at-home restrictions to ease from Saturday, May 2.

* Up to five members from a single household can visit another home from May 10. 

* Family picnics and weekend drives allowed, national parks will reopen and people can shop for clothing and shoes, and go for haircuts

* You can let your dog off the leash as 131 dog parks will gradually reopen

* Citizens must stay within 50km of their homes, and social distancing will still be enforced.

* People from the same household can go out together, while those who live alone can spend time with one other person.

* No change to schools until at least May 15 with students continuing to learn remotely where they can.

* 'We recognise that Queenslanders have done a great job in trying to flatten that curve. So we also know it's having a big impact on people's mental health. We thought we could lift some stay-at-home restrictions,' Queensland Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk says.

VICTORIA 

* Victorians will soon be able to have five family and friends in their home but Premier Daniel Andrews has warned it's far from party time.

* Visiting loved ones will officially be a new reason for people in the state to leave home under eased coronavirus restrictions, which will be in place from 11:59pm on Tuesday until May 31.

* Gatherings of 10 people outdoors will also be allowed as long as social distancing is observed.

* The premier's beloved game of golf, walking groups, fishing and hiking are among the outdoor activities allowed again.

* People won't be allowed to stay at their family and friends' homes overnight or camp overnight in national parks, some of which are being reopened.

* Professional sport teams including AFL and rugby league will be able to get back to training from just before midnight on Tuesday.

* Students are expected to be able to get back in the classroom by the end of term two, but more details are yet to be revealed.

TASMANIA 

* Tasmanians will soon be able to exercise in close-by national parks and reserves as the state begins a cautious lifting of coronavirus restrictions.

* The island on Friday unveiled its plan for a staggered lifting of restrictions but has decided to hold firm on hard border measures until at least July.

* A 10-person limit on mourners at funerals was be lifted to 20 on Monday, while residents will be able to return to parks within 30km of their home.

* The state's ban on aged care visits will be eased, but no more than two visitors will be allowed once a week.

* While there is some relief for locals, non-essential travellers arriving in Tasmania will still be required to quarantine in government facilities until at least July.

* Limits on public gatherings will ease from May 18 when stage one of the plan is slated to begin.

* Restaurants, cafes, playgrounds, pools and boot camps will be able to resume for up to 10 people at a time.

* Border restrictions, however, are still expected to be in place when stage three of the plan begins in mid-July.

NEW SOUTH WALES

* Cafes and restaurants will re-open from May 15 but may only seat 10 people at a time.  

* From Friday 1 May, two adults and their children were allowed to visit friends in their home

* The state government is encouraging shops to re-open with social distancing in place

*Pupils went back back to school on May 11 on a roster basis. State government wants full-time classroom teaching sooner rather than later  

SOUTH AUSTRALIA

* Cafes and restaurants re-opened from May 11 but may only seat 10 people at a time. 

* 'Our restrictions are actually not as severe in some respects as other states and territories,' South Australian Health Minister Stephen Wade said.

ACT

* The territory has slightly relaxed restrictions to allow adult children to visit their parents

* 'This is not a race or a contest between jurisdictions. We are in a great position here in the ACT, largely thanks to the great community effort in complying with the rules around physical distancing. However, we have seen around the world what can happen when restrictions are imposed too late or taken away too early,' ACT Chief Minister Andrew Barr said.

Advertisement

Gladys Berejiklian slams Queensland border closure as 'ridiculous' 

No comments have so far been submitted. Why not be the first to send us your thoughts, or debate this issue live on our message boards.

What's This?

By posting your comment you agree to our house rules.