Top health official bursts into tears over claims dozens of passengers were left off Ruby Princess’ list of sick passengers before they strolled off into Sydney - and now at least 20 people linked to the ship have died

  • A NSW Health officials wept as she gave evidence at the Ruby Princess inquiry 
  • The cruise is linked to 21 COVID-19 deaths in Australia and more than 600 cases 
  • Senior epidemiologist Kelly-Anne Ressler about 'reprehensible shortcomings'
  • She broke down and told the inquiry she was 'very sorry' for the debacle 
  • Here’s how to help people impacted by Covid-19

A top NSW Health official was reduced to tears and admitted she would now 'do things 'very differently' after the Ruby Princess coronavirus fiasco. 

Senior epidemiologist Kelly-Anne Ressler was questioned on Tuesday during a special commission of inquiry hearing into the doomed cruise. 

Answering a question about 'reprehensible shortcomings' by NSW Health, she burst into tears and said she was 'very sorry' for her role in the tragedy. 

Border and health officials have been at loggerheads over who was to blame for the debacle, which saw 2,700 cruise passengers disembark in Sydney with no health checks.

Thousands of passengers, around 600 of whom later tested positive for COVID-19, were allowed to spill out into Sydney Harbour and travel across the country.

The incident on March 19 has since been linked to 21 of Australia's coronavirus deaths. 

Kelly-Anne Ressler from NSW Health (pictured) broke down into tears during the Ruby Princess inquiry on Tuesday

Kelly-Anne Ressler from NSW Health (pictured) broke down into tears during the Ruby Princess inquiry on Tuesday

Ms Ressler - coordinator of the department's cruise ship health program - told the commission an expert health panel had been created to specifically look into the risks of COVID-19 earlier in 2020.

Commissioner Bret Walker SC on Tuesday asked Ms Ressler why he 'should not draw the conclusion that there has been a reprehensible shortcoming from NSW Health'.

'All I can say is that I'm very sorry it turned out the way it did, it was not our intention,' she replied as she fought back tears.  

'Myself and my colleagues at the public health unit were working very hard on this. 

'We did what we could and if we could do it again it would be very different.'

 Although not part of the panel, she was involved in providing 'assistance and suggestions' towards a draft protocol document, which was released on February 19.

The doomed Ruby Princess cruise ship (pictured) is seen leaving Port Kembla in Wollongong on April 23, with a banner draped over the back saying 'Thank You Illawarra'

The doomed Ruby Princess cruise ship (pictured) is seen leaving Port Kembla in Wollongong on April 23, with a banner draped over the back saying 'Thank You Illawarra'

Kelly-Anne Ressler from NSW Health (pictured) admitted things would be done 'very differently' now

Kelly-Anne Ressler from NSW Health (pictured) admitted things would be done 'very differently' now

Some local residents came to wave off the Ruby Princess on April 23 (pictured) in Woolongong, as it finally set sail for the Philippines

Some local residents came to wave off the Ruby Princess on April 23 (pictured) in Woolongong, as it finally set sail for the Philippines

The protocol suggested all passengers visit a ship's medical centre if they had respiratory symptoms or a fever, with isolation to follow.

But, Ms Ressler said, while a ship was at sea she had 'no jurisdiction' to control what actions were taken.

The federal department overseeing biosecurity arrangement has said NSW Health 'advised there were no issues preventing disembarkation'. 

Counsel assisting Richard Beasley SC said there were only 25 COVID-19 test kits available on board the cruise ship, with only 13 people swabbed by the time the ship docked.

Mr Walker asked if Ms Ressler thought it was strange more people were tested for influenza than for coronavirus.

'I wasn't part of the decision-making for developing the testing criteria and until you raise it with me now I wasn't aware it was so unsatisfactory,' Ms Ressler said.

Kelly-Anne Ressler (pictured) is a senior epidemiologist for NSW Health and gave evidence at the inquiry on Tuesday

Kelly-Anne Ressler (pictured) is a senior epidemiologist for NSW Health and gave evidence at the inquiry on Tuesday

Crew members are seen waving as the Ruby Princess left Australian waters on April 23 (pictured), with one displaying a banner reading 'Thank you Australia'

Crew members are seen waving as the Ruby Princess left Australian waters on April 23 (pictured), with one displaying a banner reading 'Thank you Australia'

The special commission is required to deliver its final report by mid-August.

A separate Senate inquiry into the Ruby Princess began on Tuesday in Canberra, while a NSW Police criminal probe is also underway.

On Tuesday, the Ruby Princess was off the east coast of the southern Philippine island of Mindanao en route to Manila.

The ship departed Port Kembla in Wollongong almost a fortnight ago.

On Tuesday afternoon, the head of the powerful Home Affairs department will also be quizzed over the Ruby Princess debacle.

Kelly-Anne Ressler (pictured) is a senior epidemiologist for NSW Health and gave evidence at the inquiry on Tuesday

Kelly-Anne Ressler (pictured) is a senior epidemiologist for NSW Health and gave evidence at the inquiry on Tuesday

A crew member on board the Ruby Princess waved a flag from his room as the ship set sail for Manila on April 23 (pictured), draping a banner over his balcony reading 'Thank You Australia'

A crew member on board the Ruby Princess waved a flag from his room as the ship set sail for Manila on April 23 (pictured), draping a banner over his balcony reading 'Thank You Australia'

Hundreds of crew members from the Ruby Princess were taken by bus to be put on planes back to their home countries on April 23 (pictured) before the ship set sail

Hundreds of crew members from the Ruby Princess were taken by bus to be put on planes back to their home countries on April 23 (pictured) before the ship set sail

Michael Pezzullo will front a Senate committee examining the government's response to the coronavirus crisis, along with officials from Border Force and the agriculture and environment departments.

Labor's home affairs spokeswoman Kristina Keneally said the whole affair was an extraordinary lapse of border security.

'We cannot forget that allowing the Ruby Princess to dock in Sydney - and the way it was handled - is a human tragedy and over 30 Australians have lost their lives as a result of it,' she told AAP.   

'There are no less than four handbrakes the Morrison government could have applied to stop the Ruby Princess debacle and today we will ask why these weren't applied.'

The day before the ship arrived, Mr Morrison banned cruise ships from docking in Australia due to the fears of coronavirus, which has been shown to spread quickly on cruises. 

The Ruby Princess cruise ship (pictured) as she began her departure from Port Kembla on April 23

The Ruby Princess cruise ship (pictured) as she began her departure from Port Kembla on April 23

The Ruby Princess was given a water canon salute as it departed from Port Kembla on April 23 (pictured)

The Ruby Princess was given a water canon salute as it departed from Port Kembla on April 23 (pictured)

Timeline of Ruby Princess fiasco

March 18: The Ruby Princess issues an urgent mayday call for an ambulance for two of its passengers presenting with coronavirus-like symptoms 24 hours before the ship is allowed to dock in Sydney. 

March 19: The Ruby Princess arrives in Sydney Harbour. More than 2,700 guests are allowed to disembark without adequate health checks. 

March 25: Australian Border Force Commissioner Michael Outram says New South Wales Health is responsible for letting coronavirus patients disembark the ship.

March 29: Several crew members are evacuated and taken to hospital after being diagnosed with coronavirus.

April 2: A 66-year-old crew member is taken off the Ruby Princess for medical treatment. More than 200 crew members are sick and in self-isolation.

NSW Premier Gladys Berejiklian defends the actions of NSW Health and the Australian Border Force and points the finger at the Ruby Princess. She claims staff onboard may have misled NSW Health about the extent of illnesses in passengers.

April 3: Home Affairs Minister Peter Dutton alleges Ruby Princess' operators weren't transparent about the health of crew: 'It was 'clear that some of the companies have been lying about the health of passengers and crew on board'.

April 4: Leaked emails show NSW Health knew of the coronavirus risk on board the Ruby Princess before allowing its thousands of passengers to disembark. 

April 5: A criminal investigation is launched into how passengers were able to disembark without health checks 

April 8: A team of 30 detectives from state crime, counter terrorism and marine area command start investigating the handling of the Ruby Princess coronavirus scandal. The first briefing into the investigation is held.

April 9: NSW Police clad in PPE equipment raid the vessel, questioning its captain and searching for evidence in a rapid escalation of the criminal investigation.

April 11: NSW Health confirms that at least 46 crew members of the Ruby Princess cruise ship have contracted COVID-19

April 13: NSW Police Commissioner Mick Fuller says patient zero on board may have been a crew member serving meals to hundreds of passengers 

April 15: NSW premier Gladys Berejiklian announces an independent special commission to investigate the Ruby Princess fiasco

April 23: With 500 crew left on board, the Ruby Princess left Australian waters to sail to Manila in the Phillipines 

Advertisement

NSW Health official bursts into tears at Ruby Princess inquiry over its 21 deaths

No comments have so far been submitted. Why not be the first to send us your thoughts, or debate this issue live on our message boards.

What's This?

By posting your comment you agree to our house rules.