India has been locked down for two more weeks. However, a maze of regulations, restrictions on movement of people and unbridled powers to local administration mean a vast segment of economy will still stay shut, amplifying the stress. Agree?
In a scenario like this, the pandemic, invariably the comments and opinions are driven by the limited knowledge/ inflated bias due to self interest or knowledge of specific domain only. To top it when we add shreds of politics or ideological beliefs, that gives rise to numerous options. In such an environment it is difficult to identify the best option for the country/ region. Going by the outcomes of the exercise carried out till now, there is no doubt, the situation has been handled by the govt of the day in most meticulous manner. The accolades pouring in from every quarter and the stats bear testimony to that. The first priority of govt was to save lives, under extreme circumstances, when the knowledge about COVID19 itself was scanty besides the wherewithal/ infra to handle it. But it has been managed wonderfully till date. Having gained the knowledge and equipped itself to take the Covid19 head on, as also having created the mass awareness, it is absolutely justified for the govt to shift focus towards livelihood i.e. economics. After a 54 days complete lockdown, it is obvious the economy will take time to gallop, which was already under stress before Covid, due to global slowdown. The battle against Covid is not yet over, and it may show spikes in case of insane rush for business activities, hence a graduated response is the best, with enough leeway for state/ local administration to keep things under control. it will be foolhardy to expect immediate returns.
excellent comment.the media and opposition are having a jaundiced eye.just telling something is wrong is easy; suggesting what is good is necessary.
tommorws relaxations in Delhi by Cm will be counter productive and BJP netas will blame Kejrival for his relaxation which is not genuine.Delhi is not ready for that now. Every body has got the experience of Kerala's relaxation and reversing the same.
we are beating around the bush as our policy makers have no clue about how much of our population is healthy . It is like saying what the govt gives is the final truth . Suggest first determine how much of your workforce is healthy and make the healthy population start economical activities while you treat the unhealthy workforce . This is doable and logical should use mathematical models for forecasting and decision making in this way we would save both lives and livelihood .
Hi , Please tell me about EMI bank , please extend to 2 - 3 months permission with out interest .i am sincere request
Instead of speculating , focus on how to use the resources on which movement is allowed and making profits is what's required. Like improving process to get higher quality and quantity at lower cost that is direct cost in the main and the indirect too
The Central Govt. should realise that Lockdowns are not working as the rising figures tell us.The lockdown is only killing our Economy and rendering millions of people jobless. The bureaucrats are having a field day by prescribing funny and bizarre rules and restrictions to enforce the lockdown.GOD save India.
Well begun is half work done. Lets see how things unfold in the coming week and then depending on feedback, Centre & States / UT shall decide which zones colour to be changed/ retained and what relaxations to be given to which districts, respectively. Highest contribution in the above decision making process shall depend on how people maintain social distancing. Cross your fingers and wish people do not cross limits. Jai Hind !
it would have been a good idea to make containment zones and concentrate resources in these zones instead of making entire cities as red zones . the way people are not following distancing norms and the inability of the police force to curb this due to being overstretched and fatigued , it is proving counterproductive . after all the police are also human , they too will get tired . INCREASE CONTAINMENT ZONES AND FOLLOW ALL NORMS RELIGIOUSLY IN THESE ZONES , open the economy in places relatively unaffected by COVID
You arm critics,can comment anything,it is because of Modiji that we are somewhat safe!,Imagine if a full blown out break out of the virus had happened,we are in the last leg of the crisis,be patient!
We got to come out of such lock downs whether soft or hard. It's not that the the Government should decide on lock downs but it will be the virus who will have a final say. We must face the reality and come out to restore BAU. Such lockdowns will only trigger timidity and apprehension .
Let offices work with 25%-50% staff in office. Even different offices may work in different shifts starting from 6 AM to 10 AM and ending from 2 PM onward.
Impasse will continue even after 3.0 lock down. Another one year we have to wear masks and social distance to save our lifes. Government totally clueless and worried about crony corporates bottom line. Inflation dizzy heights but interest rates downturn killing senior citizens and middle class livelihoods. Life saving drugs panic buying and short supply in the market. Even branded calcium tablets scarce commodity. People hardships day by day worsening.
The lockdown in India is not successful as the daily increase in numbers tell us. So it would have been better to lift the lockdown with adequate restrictions, otherwise, more people will die of hunger and our Economy will be destroyed. The Government must give a roadmap as to when normal economic activity will be allowed to carry on as millions of people are suffering as the Govt. is only extending the lockdown without extending any support to the people as Governments in other countries doing.
The lockdown would have proved more effective if, as just before removing article 370 all tourist were asked to leave J&K and even Amarnath Yatra was stopped midway,same way all migrants,tourists students and Markas participants should have been given 3 days time and asked to go back to their native places before declaring Lockdown.This would have reduced the number of Covid-19 cases to a great extent.Now running special trains for the migrant workers and students may not have much impact in containing Covid-19.But a good move though late.
Better the lock down of the country is lifted at the earliest . India was expecting additional aid and that is also sanctioned by us. Waiting for what reason's are not known. covid cannot be controlled until and unless the slums are kept clean .Many other deceases are going to crop in even after lifting the lockdown.
BULLET tRAIN IS TO RUN INBETWEEN MUMBAI AND AMEDABAD .Then Cenral gov has plan to extend bullet train facility to other metropolitan center.so no one should create unrest
Mr. Modi has blood on his hands. There is no future for this country. Any extension of lockdown is now going to push us back to the time we raised ourselves after our independence. We will be back to being a poor nation with no global standing.
Goa has come out successfully. Why small state like Goa should TEACH LESSON TO MAHARASHTRA. PEOPLE OF MAHARASHTRA AND GUJARAT MUST FOLLOW THE LOCK OUT RULES STRICTLY. HOSPITALS, MUNICIPALITIES, HEALTH EXPERTS AND OTHER PEOPLE CAN MAKE MORE EFFORTS TO PREVENT CASES. WHY CASES INCREASING??? CAN MAH. LEARN LESSON FROM GOA??? LEARNING FROM OTHER IS THE BEST WAY FOR IMPROVEMENT. PREVENTION IS BETTER THAN CURE. TAKE ALL PRECAUTIONARY MEASURES IN SLUMS TO REDUCE NUMBERS. THANKS A LOT.
it is trade off to save few disposable lives why risk lakhs of lives
There is bound to be impact well said something is better than nothing
When the economy was fully open it could not take off, now this lockdown has ensured further dowward spiral which is irreversible.
(1) Guidelines are being changed every day and confusing. Some shops are allowed to open at each zone. But there are restrictions on private vehicles and cabs use. How does this help shopkeeper or buyer? (2) People are being asked to stay at home. How do they earn money? Employer cannot pay without work. Everyone cannot work remotely. Govt has not no scheme or means to transfer direct benefit to every household unlike advanced countries.
Bahar niklo toh har bande aur surface se darr lagta hai, never know what is infected. Lockdown extend karna zaruri hai, but making it easier is equally important. We should be able to order things online and get it delivered.
Implementation of guidelines rests on district collectors. Districts are used to classify them into red,orange and green except in the case of metropolitan cities. Present guidelines allow industrial activities in rural areas and consumer demand is initiated in green and to some extent in orange zones. This would nudge the needle of industrial activities and economy. the graded response to open up lock down is welcome from the point of view of controlling mortlit. The contra example is the case of US and some European countries.
More the number of zones more will be the difficulty in implementing them. There should be only two zones, Red and Green.
Since Center is making a hash of opening the economy, they could have at least done it colorfully. Why use only 3 colours. More specific details could have been added, creating less confusion. (eg: whole Mumbai district cannot be ‘RED’ just because of some slum area cases). But it seems like Govt. doesn’t have much vision. They are obviously Colour Blind
Lockdown extension is not a solution, we need ghar ka samaan also, but we are afraid to go out and get them. Eagerly waiting for ecommerce to start delivering so that we can order everything we need without going out.
could have been thoda clearer. but people need to be able to stay home poore time without any problem. Fully enabling support functions like e-commerce can probably help the situation
It is indeed confusing, could have been simpler. for example, ecommerce could have been started full fledgedly in all zones which could allow people to get what they want without having to step out of their homes.
If you (the writer of this article) are intelligent enough, than give some suggestions, just do not try to sell something which even you do not have.
Let the full lockdown continue for till Aug.
By looking at lockdown conditions, that is, the country's red, orange & green zones, this lockdown will easily continue till August 2020,
after a very long time our Babu are in charge.... politicians have taken a back seat. ..our Babu will draft letters & press release in such a way which will confuse practically everybody....
Objective of lockdown is more to save lives even at the cost of economic growth. With hardly 50,000 ventillators and limited ICUs, treating Corona patients in large numbers may lead to a dangerous situation where patients may have to be chosen and treated. Lockdown has been lifted to a great extent in green and orange zones. This may be extended to red zones excluding containment areas. People dying due to starvation as it is made out is not true as our godowns are full and we are expecting good harvest and good monsoon as well.
Economists have their own priorities and Health officials have their own. The terms and conditions of lockdown is getting complicated and government officials are not capable of implementing the restrictions/relaxations. Police could not release the seized vehicles in Bangalore. A dead body was shifted from Mumbai to a village Karnataka and has spread the infection to four family members.Migrant workers, neither can live in shelter homes nor can afford to travel to their homes.
It is very typical of Modi to do funny tinkering and administrative delight..well said..grass level confusion equals corruption chaos confusion..nightmare of living dead.. ..Just like income tax laws now a messy cocktail of all wrong ideas of Modi..easing out economic disaster is just not his cup of tea..No babu understands supply chain and that is abc of economy..The plight of skilled workers, I will call them technicians of city life ..electronic, electrical, plumbing gadgetry courier, masonry transportation. .. is a catastrophe beyond repair .much beyond corona fooling fear..it was fun for stressed young generation to clap , light Diya’s and app score like 2020 match fir sometime..a nightmare fir elders with regular visits to doctors otherwise ease now lockdown..It is now mockdown.Every one in house complex looks at every other as a yamdooth.Time to delegate to LOCAL BODIES.. GENERAL PHYSICIANS...
It is widely expressed opinion by experts that Corona Virus shall stay for a long time.Hence Govt i requested to chalk out strategies which should revive economy as well as which give less pain to public.Otherwise consequences are worst
With hundred deaths a day the death rate is way below normal which is 40000 a day. Why destroy the economy and lives when death rate is way below normal?
its below normal now see when lockdown is lifted idiot
It is less due to lock down Human lives are of prime importance and cannot be weighed in gold
Instead of the naming the Lockdown-3 an extension,we could say it is an experiment before our exit from the total lockdown. Transport of migrant labourers by special train and bus,trains to main pilgrim centers and truck movements are of the few trials before lifting the total lockdown.My request to PM,Modiji and CMs of states/UTs to workout a feasibility for issuing a face mask along with ticket to the passengers of all modes of transport from May,18,2020 to Dec,31,2020.The people who do online reservation could collect the face mask at their boarding station.The subsidized cost of the face mask could be collected from the passengers of A/c coach passengers of train,luxury bus, air andwater ways.Mandatory wearing of mask for a period of six months could make a tangible achievement in India's battle against Covid19.
Author view is preposterous and looks away from reality. India is able to control virus outbreak with timely lockdown. Lockdown will remain in some or other form in the times to come as any carelessness will result in increasing the nos exponentially.
Majority more than 80% as per Survey have supported extension of lock down.
Unreported corona cases that got cured or death is hidden since data quality depends on data management..It is no number game like cricket score.Social distancing is a good and sufficient advisory..Shutting down clubs or discos is fair too.Rest of activity is panic and fear now..Corona is Art of the air each breath like tb r any ..it boils down to oral hygiene ..steam inhalation. As first level like brushing teeth.Economists, politicians and babus or police can only go as far ..they have no expertise. Leave it to local physician and health minister.
The author suggestion to remove lockdown indicted that he is high on marijuana.
Considering the daily rise in infected cases this is correct and strong decision by the Government of India. Please look what is happening in Brazil where they were reluctant to implement lockdown..Number of death have gone past 5k..Do you want same for India. ?
An idiot has written this article. When you stop a moving machine and allow it to lie unused for sometime, you always need time to restart it and make it run as per previous standard. Same holds good for this lockdown.
Good comparison as re-starting is not so easy. Overall, the focus is on Containment Zones which will increase or decrease while the zones keep changing colours at the local level - simply put, the mantra is buying more time & leaving the decision to states - a clever ploy!
Mr Rob, Pakistan you mentioned in your comment has performed 10,000 tests till date in the whole country. Same is the issue with all neighbors. What you need is more education and GK which you get by reading newspapers regularly and actually use your brain cells instead of just relying on numbers. Approx 2000 cases are coming everyday and you say it's contained?
Back to Inspector Raj days, Modi has taken us back to 70s of Indira.
Govt is taking its que from the pandemic situation in the west. The third lockdown is not at all warranted because now we can see thae death rates in india and the virulence of covid in India. It is not alarming. The deaths are not alarming. The vast areas inthe country and neighbouring Pakistan and Bangladesh are low and is an indicator. Even if the figures are five tomes as much, it is not alarming given the population.India cannot afford such extended lockdowns and we will be saddled with this lameduck Govt which will only be making the corona excuse for its remaining term. They think the people will forget the mismanagement!
The article is biased and prejudiced against the govt. The lockdown can not be opened suddenly. There will be chaos. Care has been taken of most stakeholders very sensibly.
Copyright © 2020 Bennett, Coleman & Co. Ltd. All rights reserved. For reprint rights: Times Syndication Service