Why Australians' path to the Premier League has never been tougher
A former Premier League head of recruitment believes it's now harder than ever for Australian soccer players to make it to the English top-flight. It's been more than a decade since the Socceroos' golden generation started to fade away and there's been few signs of a return to those halcyon days of the mid-to-late 2000s.
At the 2006 World Cup, nine of Australia's 23-man squad represented Premier League sides, with four others plying their trade in the Spanish La Liga and Serie A in Italy. In stark contrast, at last year's Asian Cup, Brighton goalkeeper Mat Ryan was the only player contracted to an EPL team, although Aaron Mooy, then of Huddersfield, would have been in the squad had it not been for injury.
Brighton and Socceroos goalkeeper Mat Ryan is an Australian rarity in the Premier League.Credit:AAP
There have been a string of theories put forward for the reason behind Australia's well of talent drying up. One is the decision of the FFA in 2017 to shut down the centre of excellence at the Australian Institute of Sport that produced the likes of Craig Moore, Vince Grella, Mark Viduka, Lucas Neill, Brett Emerton, Mark Bresciano, Vince Grella and John Aloisi.
Another is the replacement of home-grown coaches like Ron Smith and Steve O'Connor in Canberra more 10 years ago with ones from the Netherlands in a failed attempt to emulate the successful Dutch system.
Gary Penrice, former head of recruitment at Everton, Crystal Palace, Blackpool, QPR, Wigan and Stoke, who's just been appointed by Celtic, believes making the grade in England is tough, but not necessarily because of a lack of talent.
"Sometimes it just happens, a glut of really good players come through at once," Penrice said. "We're seeing it with Wales at the moment who have young kids like Daniel James now playing for Man United and Harry Wilson, who's on loan at Bournemouth from Liverpool.
"Who knows, in four years' time we could be talking about it happening again with Australia. But the football world is so vast nowadays. You now have players coming from so many different parts of the world to play in the Premier League."
There have been 51 Aussies who've played in the Premier League since its formation in 1992, which ranks only behind Brazil, Argentina and Nigeria for a non-European nation.
Mile Jedinak (right) during his days as Crystal Palace captain.Credit:Reuters
"There's always been lots of good players from Scandinavia and Australia but now you have players from countries like Liberia, Tanzania and Gabon, the net of talent is wider than ever," Penrice said. "I was at Palace when Mile Jedinak was there. A terrific guy, great pro and a real leader of men.
"You can say the same about Tim Cahill when I was at Everton. Both fantastic players, but also dependable, strong, good to have around your squad. That is always what Australian players have brought to a team."
Penrice said the progress of Mooy and Ryan shows good Aussies can still break through. "I first watched Mooy in a World Cup warm-up match against Czech Republic and he was the best player on the pitch," he said. "Clubs will always want to sign players like him and Ryan."
The improvement in young English talent has also hindered Aussie players in academy systems like Aiden O'Neill, on loan to Brisbane Roar from Burnley, making the grade like Kewell did at Leeds.
A change to the rules for overseas signings also means EPL clubs must now splash out to be guaranteed a work permit. Previously, a permit would be granted for any player who'd played 75 per cent of their country's international fixtures over three years. Now, only a player who costs STG10 million and earns STG30,000 a week will be given the green light under a points system.
"It's certainly made things harder," Penrice said. "It'll be interesting to see what happens with Australia. Young (Daniel) Arzani has been at Celtic, but he's not played much due to the injury he had. Arzani is Manchester City's player ... they obviously think he's got something to have signed him. But he needs to play games. I am guessing they'll loan him out again."
THE BEST XI AUSTRALIANS TO PLAY FOOTBALL IN ENGLAND
GOALKEEPER:
Mark Bosnich
Manchester United 1988-91, 1999-01, Aston Villa 1992-99, Chelsea 2001-02
Appearances: 273
Hard to split Bosnich and Mark Schwarzer, but the Sydneysider's brilliance during a six-year spell for teams competing for honours gives him the edge. Villa were a frequent top-four challenger with 'Bozza' between the sticks, won two cups and regularly played in Europe. He returned to United to win the EPL in 2000 before off-field dramas ultimately ended his career. Although it tainted his legacy, there's no disputing, at his pomp, Bosnich was among the finest keepers in Britain.
Mark Bosnich during his time at Manchester United.Credit:Reuters
DEFENDERS:
Brett Emerton
Blackburn Rovers 2003-2011
Appearances: 294
Goals: 20
The $A4.8 million spent by Blackburn on Emerton is regarded as one of the best value-for-money signings in the club's history. Marked his debut with a goal and an assist and became one of the EPL's best attacking full-backs. Respected for his low maintenance attitude off the field too, Emerton appeared in two FA Cups and a League Cup semi-final. He was also part of a squad that qualified twice for the Europa League.
Lucas Neill
Millwall 1995-2001, Blackburn '01-07, West Ham '07-'09, Everton, 09-10, Watford, Doncaster 2014.
Appearances: 514
Goals: 22
Confident, abrasive, consistent. Three words that best describe Neill's stellar 19-year career in England. After six seasons at Millwall he became a Premier League player with Blackburn in 2001. The right-back's good form often saw him linked with a move to a top-four club. However, he turned down Liverpool in 2007 to join West Ham for a reported $150,000 a week. After three good seasons he left to join Everton only to depart after six months. After spells in Turkey and the A-League he joined Watford then Doncaster in 2014 before retiring after missing out on the World Cup.
Craig Moore
Glasgow Rangers 1993-98, '99-05, Crystal Palace 1998-'99, Newcastle 2005-07.
Appearances: 306
Goals: 20
A classy centre-back with a touch of steel, Moore enjoyed a trophy-laden 12-year stint with Rangers where he cemented his place in an outstanding side that featured regularly in the Champions League and won the Scottish treble in 2003. Newcastle gave Moore the chance to play in the Premier League in 2005 and he impressed the St James' Park crowd. However, injuries limited him to just 30 games in two years.
Former soccer player Joe Marston, the first australian to play professionally in the UK, being presented to the Queen Mother in 1954 at Wembley. Photo Bruce MillerCredit:Bruce Miller
Joe Marston
Club: Preston North End 1950-55
Appearances: 185
The pioneering Sydneysider was the defensive linchpin in a fine Preston team. Signed in 1950, Marston was not only the first Australian to play in England but also the FA Cup final. He was a key man in the team that were denied the 1953 First Division title on goal average. Finished his career at Deepdale by being serenaded from the field to the tune of Waltzing Matilda. Named one of the club's six greatest-ever players last year.
MIDFIELDERS:
Craig Johnston
Clubs: Middlesbrough 1977-81, Liverpool 1981-1988
Number of all competition appearances: 335
Goals: 56
An outstanding attacking midfielder and a regular member of a magnificent Liverpool side in the early 1980s. What he lacked in technical ability, he made up for with an eye for goal, pace and power. Despite an outgoing personality, Johnston was constantly wracked with self-doubt and even went as far to claim he was the worst player in a fantastic team. He wasn't.
Mile Jedinak
Crystal Palace 2011-16, Aston Villa 2016-19
Appearances: 257
Goals: 12
Robbie Slater became the first Australian to win a Premier League title in 1995 at Blackburn and enjoyed spells at West Ham and Southampton. However, he's edged out by former Socceroos skipper Jedinak. The defensive midfielder was an inspirational captain at Palace and played a significant role in their promotion to the EPL in 2014. After helping them stay there, he led the Eagles out for the 2016 FA Cup final. Joined Villa later that year and won promotion again in 2019.
Tim Cahill
Millwall 1998-2004, 2019; Everton 2004-2012
Appearances: 453
Goals: 108
Tim Cahill celebrates Louis Saha's goal during their 2009 FA Cup quarter-final.Credit:Reuters
In addition to being a Socceroos great, Cahill is held in similarly-high esteem at Millwall and Everton. Signed for just $A3.8 million by the Toffees, in an eight-year stint he regularly topped their scoring charts. Scored in three successive World Cups for Australia and joined some exalted company by appearing in his fourth in 2018.
Stan Lazaridis
West Ham 1995-99, Birmingham City 1999-2006
Appearances: 260
Goals: 11
The flying left-winger endured a mixed time during his spell with West Ham, but found his feet at Birmingham where he became a huge crowd favourite. Scored a penalty in a shoot-out win that earned EPL promotion in 2002, ending a 17-year top-flight absence.
STRIKERS:
Harry Kewell
Leeds United 1996-2003; Liverpool 2003-2008
Appearances: 274
Goals: 56
The most naturally-talented player produced by Australia. Injuries blighted the attacker's Liverpool career, forcing him off during the 2005 Champions League and 2006 FA Cup finals. It was at Leeds where his star shone brightest in a brilliant side that reached the 2001 Champions League semi-final. However, some disparaging comments when he left for Anfield and a later move to Galatasaray tarnished his reputation with Leeds fans.
Harry Kewell sores his first goal for Leeds against Derby County in 2001.Credit:PA
Mark Viduka
Leeds United 2000-2004 Middlesbrough 2004-07, Newcastle 2007-09
Appearances: 240
Goals: 62
Scored 30 goals in 37 games for Celtic before joining Leeds where he etched his named in club folklore by smashing four goals past Liverpool. Unlike Kewell, he is still revered at Elland Road. Viduka was a top-class striker blessed with an immaculate first touch, aerial ability and was a great finisher. Also enjoyed good success at Middlesbrough where he spearheaded their run to the Europa League final. Joined Newcastle in 2007 but injuries blighted his two years at the club.
AAP