McMillan Shakespeare shares reached as low as $11.95 today but are now at $12.33, down 8 per cent, after analysts at Macquarie and Evans & Partners cut their ratings following yesterday's market update and earnings downgrade.
Meanwhile Citi Research analysts have maintained their 'buy' rating but lower their estimates for earnings before interest, tax, depreciation, and amortisation down by 8.3 per cent to $121.4 million. They expect post-tax profit to be at the higher end of the revised guidance at $89 million. Citi's buy rating remains because the analysts were pessimistic about McMillan's bid for Eclipx, which lapsed several weeks ago.
"McMillan Shakespeare's announcement is evidence of the cyclical headwinds noted in the new car market (14 months of consecutive declines). Novated leasing businesses, while still cyclical, have historically out-performed corporate fleet businesses and remain our preferred exposures into the auto leasing category," the team led by Ross Barrows writes.
"We are hopeful of improved conditions in the first half of 2019-20 from a cyclical improvement and increased consumer sentiment and visibility post the federal election."