State continues to build \'jigsaw of evidence\'

Advertisement

State continues to build 'jigsaw of evidence'

Day 2 of 3: The state is arguing the admissibility of proposed evidence it says will prove Mr Edwards had a tendency to attack vulnerable women.

Link between marriage breakdown and murders 'utterly irrelevant': Defence

Defence lawyer, Paul Yovich, has argued the personal circumstances occurring in Mr Edwards’ life around the time of the alleged offences is “utterly irrelevant”.

He argues there is no evidence his client was emotionally upset or unhappy following the break-down of his marriage between 1994 and 1996.

“There is no evidence whatsoever about the accused's acute or ongoing mental state or emotional state,” he said.

“It cannot be assumed your happier in a relationship than when you’re out of one.

“It cannot be assumed when you’re in a relationship, unhappiness is necessarily rare.”

Offending occurred during 'tumultuous times' in accused's relationships

Ms Barbagallo is arguing Mr Edwards' offending occurred when he was going through "tumultuous times" in his relationships. 

She says for that reason, the Hollywood Hospital assault should be considered as propensity evidence for all the charges against him, as it occurred after he discovered his girlfriend had cheated on him.

"We say there is an escalation of violence," she said.

"He goes from attacking a woman at a hospital...and then going on, we say, abducting, with a sexual motive, and murdering three girls."

The state alleges that shortly before the Karrakatta rape in 1995, Mr Edwards' wife's lover moved in with them. 

In January 1996, the same month Sarah Spiers disappeared, his wife left the marital home with the man she was having an affair with.

In May, Mr Edwards learned his wife was pregnant by the other man.

The following month, Ms Rimmer was murdered. 

In April 1997, Mr Edwards met his second wife and his alleged offending stopped. 

Advertisement

Mr Edwards' 'has tendency to attack vulnerable women from behind': State claims

State lead prosecutor, Carmel Barbagallo is arguing why the state wants to submit propensity evidence in Mr Edwards' trial. 

She said the state's proposal is Mr Edwards' tendency to attack women "in a particular way" should be considered when determining his innocence or guilt for each of the charges.

She made a metaphor of Mr Edwards' alleged offending tendencies as being part of a "small pond" of potential offenders. 

"There are many men that attack women they know as opposed to those they don't. So the pond is significantly decreased," she said. 

"A much smaller pond [attack vulnerable strangers].

"Attacking them from behind, a smaller pond again.

"The use of some fabric cloth to put over their mouth, the pond this offender can come from is reduced again.

"Saying very little or nothing to women in the attack, again the pond decreases."

Justice Stephen Hall asked, "how big is that pond?".

Ms Barbagallo alleged regardless of the locations or timing of the alleged offences, the manner in which Mr Edwards' allegedly offends, she says, has a tendency. 

"It's the manner by which he undertakes that attack...regardless of the geography, regardless of the time-frame," she said. 

"It's the behaviour he engages in on each occasion."

Day 2 of Mr Edwards' pre-trial hearing gets under way

Good morning readers, 

Loading

Heather McNeill and Phil Hickey here, reporting from the Supreme Court of Western Australia for day two of Bradley Robert Edwards' pre-trial directions hearing. 

The hearing is arguing the admissibility of some of the state's proposed evidence against the accused Claremont serial killer. 

Much of the proposed evidence is propensity evidence the state says goes towards Mr Edwards' tendency to attack vulnerable women in a particular way. 

The related article in this post is a blog from day one of the hearing, which includes the state's alleged case against Mr Edwards. 

It's important to note the details set out by state prosecutor Carmel Barbagallo during the hearing are allegations and that no evidence had been put before the court yet.

Bradley Robert Edwards has pleaded not guilty to the murders of Sarah Spiers, 18, Jane Rimmer, 23, and Ciara Glennon, 27, in 1996 and 1997.

The 50-year-old has also denied raping a 17-year-old girl in Karrakatta Cemetery in 1995 and attacking an 18-year-old woman in her Huntingdale home in 1988.

Most Viewed in National

Loading