Chris Hardwick's bad statement got people talking about toxic nerd culture
/https%3A%2F%2Fblueprint-api-production.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fuploads%2Fcard%2Fimage%2F793926%2F1e0a023a-c3aa-41f1-ac12-b161b87bc006.jpeg)
"As a husband, a son, and future father, I do not condone any kind of mistreatment of women."
On Friday night, entertainer and geek "hero" Chris Hardwick responded to Chloe Dykstra's allegations that he sexually assaulted her and engaged in other toxic behavior while the two were dating. His carefully worded statement refuted Dykstra's account, and ended with that oh-so-familiar defense you see above.
Let's be clear: "Guilty until proven innocent" is for a court of law to decide, if that's where this story eventually goes. The court of public opinion operates under no such constraints, and in the post-Harvey Weinstein days of 2018 we believe the accuser.
Hardwick's response, then, reads as textbook gaslighting.
His alleged actions and subsequent statement drew quick condemnation on social media, and in those responses a common theme began to emerge: Nerd culture itself is toxic.
It’s like a new strain of misogyny — they never stopped fully hating or resenting or being scared of women and now that they can GET women, they see them as their personal playthings
— Dana Schwartz (@DanaSchwartzzz) June 15, 2018
And here’s the kicker: these men will always think that they’re the victim
— Dana Schwartz (@DanaSchwartzzz) June 15, 2018
Some of the worst misogynists, abusers, and narcissists I know are self-proclaimed nerds. Nerd culture is extremely corporate, not very radical, and not all that progressive. So, basically, mainstream nerd culture can die right now and I’d be happy.
— Alison Stevenson (@JustAboutGlad) June 15, 2018
I’ve met a lot of kind and wonderful nerds but I agree, once the nerds inherited the earth a lot of them turned into the jocks of every 80s movie. To turn that around, it would be wise for the nerd community to start treating female nerds/nerds-of-color like the rockstars they R
— Lexi Alexander (@Lexialex) June 16, 2018
The most pernicious, outdated pop culture trope that needs to die is that male nerds are cultural underdogs who are entitled to their demands. Even the 1980s movie Revenge of the Nerds has a literal rape scene played for laughs. The nerds won a long time ago & they fucking suck.
— Aaron Stewart-Ahn (@somebadideas) June 16, 2018
This isn’t unique to nerd culture but the mix of identity-as-consumption and fanatical devotion to consumption (which is what nerd culture really is) creates a toxic mix where consumption is the only way people see themselves as having a place in the world
— toynbee tyler (@tylersnotes) June 16, 2018
In short, if you really liked a podcast and the person responsible for it is an abuser, you can still have liked the podcast without needing the abuser to be good actually.
— toynbee tyler (@tylersnotes) June 16, 2018
Just a handful of examples. There are plenty more.
Nerd culture is what's given way to movements (read: hate groups) like GamerGate and Sad Puppies. It's why Leslie Jones took a social media hiatus and probably why Kelly Marie Tran deleted her Instagram.
It's why, if you look far enough back, you can still find headlines like this on the internet.
Image:
(Protip: Nothing ever "ruined" San Diego Comic Con's Hall H. Twilight was huge and drew big crowds, just like Marvel, Star Wars, The Walking Dead, and more. If you think big crowds like the one Twilight drew ruined Hall H... well... Chris Hardwick and the commodification of geek culture plays a big role there. But that's a conversation for another day.)
For a long, long time in pop culture, geeks have been the "good guys" to the jocks' "bad guys." That's been reinforced ad nauseum by everything from Spider-Man alter-ego Peter Parker's existence to the conceit of an entire fictional universe in Ernest Cline's book, Ready Player One.
But over the course of the past decade, as geeky interests have moved in to dominate the mainstream, that facade has crumbled. A male geek's pursuit of an "out of his league" love interest used to be the basis for a fictional story's emotional beats; as we all look back now and re-examine how we got here, we pick up on the deeply unsettling aspects of those plotlines.
This isn't to suggest that loving a thing adored by the geeky set is inherently bad. But, as some suggested in the social media musings above, tethering your identity to the products you consume can have toxic results. If you are what you like, any criticism of the thing you like can come off as a personal attack.
No one's suggesting that all geek properties should be put to death. But this conversation that's sprung up in the wake of the Hardwick revelations is yet another product of our culture's ongoing process of self-reflection as would-be "heroes" and "industry giants" are revealed as the villains they actually are.
It wasn't so long ago that we cheered at the idea of geeks inheriting the Earth. Now, we know better.