Mould, leaking wastewater disgusts Dunedin student flat tenants

Mould was present throughout the year, prompting students to seek legal advice.
SUPPLIED

Mould was present throughout the year, prompting students to seek legal advice.

Tenants of a "horrible" Dunedin student flat have won a confidential payout after an inspection report found toxic black mould posed a serious risk to their health.

The nine female tenants inspected the flat in the middle of 2016, and were told by those tenants it was a typical student flat.

The group signed a year-long lease for 2017, each paying $140 a week.

A spoon is used as a lock for a door in a Dunedin student flat. The nine female tenants have since received a payout for ...
SUPPLIED

A spoon is used as a lock for a door in a Dunedin student flat. The nine female tenants have since received a payout for the state of the property.

But the students, who are studying medicine, dentistry, law and sciences, quickly realised they were living in a house of horrors.

READ MORE:
Inside a chilly six-bedroom Dunedin flat 
The student flat where shabby meets luxe 
Hundreds cheer on initiation 
Mock ad for burnt-out Dunedin flat designed to scare
Stuff Nation: Top 5 student accommodation comments

"I was the sickest I have ever been in that flat," said one of the flatmates, speaking on the condition of anonymity.

A Dunedin house rented by nine students found to be leaky and mouldy.
HAMISH MCNEILLY/STUFF

A Dunedin house rented by nine students found to be leaky and mouldy.

One of the tenants became so sick she developed asthma and a doctor – her flatmate's father – believed mould was the problem.

It was there when some of the women moved into the flat in the new year. It was outside the house. It was on the walls. It was in the fridge.

The property manager later sent a cleaner around, but the tenants remained concerned about the state of the three-level home.

Mould contaminated clothing, which had to be thrown out.
SUPPLIED

Mould contaminated clothing, which had to be thrown out.

As the seasons changed, the problems worsened.

Ad Feedback

One of the tenants told Stuff that mould began to spread through her room, with the dampness compounded by a shower leaking into a lounge below.

"It is a lot of money for a disgusting flat," one of the flatmate's said.

Photos of a Dunedin student flat at the beginning of a 2017 tenancy.
SUPPLIED

Photos of a Dunedin student flat at the beginning of a 2017 tenancy.

The property manager got a builder to look at the problems "but nothing actually got fixed", so the tenants decided to enlist their own building inspector.

His report filed in November concluded the leak affecting the bedrooms could have been present for up to two years, and the home was not water tight. The inspector noted there was a "significant/serious risk" toxic black mould stachybotrys could be present in the wall.

A flatmate said the inaction from the property manager and owner, coupled with their concerns that the issues may never be addressed, prompted them to go to the Tenancy Tribunal.

Both parties went through mediation, with the flatmates' lawyer filing a submission seeking more than $100,000 against Paul Reuben, of Student Accommodation Ltd, and Blackdog Properties.

"They have endured a poorly maintained and managed residence that has adversely impacted upon their health, safety, and quiet enjoyment of that property," the submission said.

The Christchurch owner of Blackdog Properties, Tim Coslett, declined to comment. Reuben said in an emailed statement "any dealings with our clients is confidential".

The report concerning mould, completed in March, showed the tenants "suffered from prolonged exposure to high concentrations of toxic mould".

"The mould is sufficiently toxic to require those entering the property to wear personal protective equipment, such as specialist gloves, footwear, eye protection, full body skin protective suits, and respirators, and for any soft furnishings and other contaminated items to be disposed of as contaminated waste to prevent others from being exposed to the toxins," the tenants' lawyer noted.

Despite the limited number of tests, there were "alarmingly high spore counts".

Both parties agreed to settle for an undisclosed sum.

A flatmate said they wanted their experience to serve as a reminder for students they should not accept poor housing.

 - Stuff

Comments

Auckland

Dancers' Fresh routine video

Manurewa High School principal Pete Jones says he's "really proud" of the school's dancers.

Now this a story all about how Auckland dancers went viral in Fresh Prince tribute.

Meet Auckland's Black Fern firefighter video

Rochelle Martin has been working for Fire and Emergency New Zealand for 17 years.

"This was such an honour as I am the first female career firefighter to be in this position."

Cutest-ever protest over plastic

In a handwritten letter to Stuff, young Maddie Barr asks "other people in the world" to use paper straws in place of ...

An Auckland child has written a letter pleading for "other pepile in the wirld" to stop using plastic straws.

School to face a concrete wall

Hobsonville School found out last week a 12-metre high factory will be built along approximately half of the school's ...

An Auckland school says it has been 'disregarded' after a 12m-high factory on its boundary is granted consent.

Wellington

Crash victim 'vivacious, kind'

Megan Nation was 43.

Megan Nation, 43, died when her car plunged into a ditch off Tauroa Rd in Hawke's Bay.

Fire checks needed

Alumnium cladding with a combustible core was blamed for the Grenfell Tower disaster. (File photo)

18 Wellington buildings with cladding like that seen in Grenfell Tower tragedy told to get fire safety checks.

Bullying allegations at SPCA

20052015. Supplied photo. SPCA Canterbury generic dog photo.

After bullying claims at Wellington SPCA surfaced, its boss called all staff into a meeting.

Another capital PostShop closing

05072016News. John Hawkins/Fairfax NZ 
NZ Post logo Invercargill

Kilbirnie residents saddened to hear their PostShop will be closing its doors on Thursday.

Canterbury

Redevelopment likely to be staged

01052018 News Photo: Iain McGregor/Stuff
Still no plan for Cathedral Square.

Plans for the redevelopment of Cathedral Square will be released on Wednesday, six years after the project was announced.

Payout for 'toxic' flat

A Dunedin house rented by nine students found to be leaky and mouldy.

Their mouldy flat was endangering their health, so nine students hired a lawyer seeking a six-figure payout.

Canterbury horse breeder in court

MPI has asked Holly Farm owner David Marshall to reduce horse numbers on his farm to a more manageable level.

Man taken to court after years of complaints about dead, hurt and emaciated animals on his farm.

Post shops closing down

The Kiwibank and Post Shop branch in Moray Place, Dunedin, is one of four in the city to be closing soon.

Kiwibank and New Zealand Post will close four joint branches around Dunedin.

Waikato

Sinking feeling at city rowing club

The Hamilton Rowing Club has operated out of the same riverside spot since 1903.

A 115-year-old club could be asked to pack up and leave its riverside facility.

Unhealthy scout fetish

Paul Nimmo, pictured in 2013 wearing some of his scouting regalia.

Paul Nimmo was an ingratiating "alpha male" who had an "unhealthy association" with scouting nostalgia.

Man robbed on street

Two people were robbed of $200 on Ulster St in Hamilton.

Two people armed with bats robbed a man of $200 on Ulster St, Hamilton.

Sale set to rope in investors

The Adventure Waikato outdoor pursuits centre in the Waikato is for sale.

Jurassic Journey, caving, and zip line adventures all part of the package.

Bay Of Plenty

Murder accused dad smoked meth 'daily'

Donovan Michael Duff is on trial at the High Court in Rotorua accused of the murder of his nine-month-old daughter (FILE).

Baby, allegedly murdered by her own father, found to have traces of methamphetamine in her system.

Bottling giant investment granted

Nongfu Spring Ltd, through the company Creswell NZ, is seeking resource consent to draw more than one billion litres of ...

Chinese-owned bottling giant gets government approval for investment in Bay of Plenty spring.

Have you seen Harata Kiwi?

Police are looking to locate 30-year-old Harata Kiwi.

Police are appealing for any information on the whereabouts of Harata Kiwi - actively avoiding Tauranga police.

More downpours, severe gales

The low was expected to move onto the Bay of Plenty during Tuesday morning.

Just a week after torrential rain brought flooding, more is on the way.

Taranaki

Fire treated as arson video

The fire was started in the office and didn't damage the restaurant or kitchen.

The chef and manager were alerted to the fire and tracked the alleged offender who was later arrested.

Man chainsaws his neighbour's fence

A long-running dispute with his neighbours resulted in court charges for a South Taranaki man.

This court summary reads like an episode of Neighbours at War

Wind cuts power video

Power is cut to homes in the Tasman district.

More than 1000 properties in New Plymouth lost their power.

Counting down to supermarket

An artist's impression of the new Countdown which is to be built in Hawera.

Work's about to start on Hāwera's big new supermarket.

Manawatu

Rivers under watch as water rises video

Water laps over the top of the Pohangina River bridge near Totara Reserve.

Rivers are being monitored as Manawatū, Rangitīkei, Pohangina and Ōroua all rise.

Contraband history

A Manawatū Prison visitor is accused of trying to smuggle methamphetamine to an inmate (file photo).

Man had reputation of smuggling items into jail. His partner is accused of supplying him.

Pat Kelly remembered at council 

Pat Kelly served Palmerston North ratepayers for more than two decades, first on the Palmerston North City Council and ...

Horizons councillors pay respects to long-serving public servant Pat Kelly.

Marist open gap

Jordan Joblin-Hall in action for Marist against Hokowhitu.

FOOTBALL: Federation League leaders five points ahead of nearest rival.

Nelson

Spreading warmth and understanding video

Former refugee Johnsy Johnsy's  has come a long way in six years in New Zealand.

"Hi, I'm Johnsy Johnsy. I'm from Absolute Energy and I've come to install your insulation."

No grandstand finish video

Protesters line the windows outside the packed Golden Bay Community Board meeting with placards in support of the ...

Protesters fighting to stop the demolition of an historic Golden Bay grandstand remain hopeful they can save it.

Chickens and dirty, rotten eggs

Unwanted chickens and roosters are being dumped all over the country and left to fend for themselves.

Cowardly poultry owners are dumping birds because they are too gutless to kill them once they've stopped laying.

Driver in near head-on

A disqualified driver has admitted losing control of his car on a wet road and driving off after swiping the side of an ...

A disqualified driver who lost control on a wet road, nearly causing a head-on crash, has some explaining to do.

Marlborough

Former TV star's life 'disintegrated'

A former television star drove along a pedestrian track beside the Taylor River, in Blenheim, close to Stuart St.

Drink-driving star could have killed, but needs support at "precarious point" in his bid to stay sober.

Slip closes SH1 lane

Properties in Koromiko have been flooded following heavy rain.

Highway partially closed by slip and flooding as heavy rain continues.

Rates row continues

Graeme Parker on the deck of his family cottage in Whenuanui Bay, in 'Picton vicinity', in the Queen Charlotte Sound.

Their century-old cottage hasn't changed, neither have the services it receives. So why the change?

What's another year?

Seddon's new water treatment plant should be up and running by October.

A boil water notice has hovered over the region for decades, but it might not be going anywhere anytime soon.

South Canterbury

Wheelhouse gets a lift gallery video

Paul Comer, left, and Craig Hopper give the thumbs off after the Rangatira's wheelhouse was lifted off on Tuesday.

The Rangatira's wheelhouse is on its way to a new home after a big job lifting it from the ship.

Notice to complier 

Environment Canterbury air quality implementation officer Mark Bourassa checks for smoking chimneys in Timaru on ...

Timaru man receives notice to upgrade despite already having compliant burner.

Boys' High players plan big futures

Jonetani 'John' Vasurakuta, 18, of Fiji, left, and Patelesio 'Sio' Latu, 15, of Tonga have come to New Zealand to play ...

Jonetani 'John' Vasurakuta and Patelesio 'Sio' Latu have come to New Zealand to further their rugby dreams.

Doll case adjourned

A Timaru child sex doll imporation case has been adjourned to August.

The case of an alleged Timaru child sex doll importer has been adjourned to August.

Otago

Post shops closing down

The Kiwibank and Post Shop branch in Moray Place, Dunedin, is one of four in the city to be closing soon.

Kiwibank and New Zealand Post will close four joint branches around Dunedin.

Payout for 'toxic' student flat

A Dunedin house rented by nine students found to be leaky and mouldy.

Their mouldy flat was endangering their health, so nine Dunedin students hired a lawyer seeking a six-figure payout.

Dunback crash victim named

Police have named Craig Porter, a 50-year-old from Palmerston, as the man who died in a single-vehicle crash at a ...

Police have named Craig Porter, of Palmerston, as the man killed after a ute rolled on a North Otago farm on Sunday.

Driver climbs up bank after crash

The driver was lucky to escape injury when her car rolled down a bank.

Police believe loose gravel on rural roads may have caused two car crashes near Queenstown.

Southland

Wanted man arrested

Armed police at the north end of Philip St in Gladstone, Invercargill, search for a wanted man who was on the run.

Armed police have arrested a wanted man, who led them on a short pursuit and forced them to organise a large search.

Week-long famine

Menzies College teacher aid Phillip Snedden, 29, has chosen to participate in the 40-hour famine with a twist, ...

When Philip Snedden's 168-hour famine ends he wants to eat a pizza and have a beer.

Bedroom fire in Waikiwi

Firefighters attended a fire in Waikiwi.

Firefighters have been called out to a fire at a Waikiwi property.

Trail decision set for final approval

The first stage of the Around the Mountains Cycle Trail was opened to the public at the end of 2014.

The Southland District Council has recommended a cost-effective option for completing the Around the Mountains Cycle Trail.