#VanBreda didn't wear a balaclava and gloves, Adv Botha says. Why was not a single bit of DNA found on any of his family members?
Postmortem findings - Dr Anthony agreed with Dr Perumal's report that it
was likely Rudi could still move after assault, even if not purposeful.
He may have pulled duvet, Adv Botha says. #VanBreda
15:24
ShareIcon
Judge Desai questions why someone would carry an axe to a home invasion. Adv Botha says gratuitous violence is rife in SA. #VanBreda
No DNA of Marli on axe, despite being hit 8 times with it, nor on #VanBreda.
Reade-Jahn in court said the axe was not the one he had seen at the
family home.
Judge Desai asks if you go to a braai, do you study the axe
of your host?
15:14
ShareIcon
Judge Desai asks what is likelihood of an attacker entering the property with an axe?
15:13
ShareIcon
Indicates Marli #VanBreda was attacked with another weapon, Adv Botha says, and Henri had said there was a possibility of a second attacker.
Is there another reasonable possibility she was not attacked with the axe, Adv Botha asks. It's the only reasonable possibility or explanation, Adv Botha says. #VanBreda
Judge Desai asks why there would be no trace of an intruder. Adv Botha says Lt Col Otto testified perpetrator would leave a trace, but not if he wore a balaclava or gloves.
Desai says there is no objective verification of an intruder.
15:07
ShareIcon
State says Marli's injuries caused by axe. It was swabbed by two police officers. Not a single trace of Marli's DNA was found on the weapon, Adv Botha says. #VanBreda
Judge Desai asks Botha to explain why no blood stains on upper part of #VanBreda's body. Henri asks to speak to Botha. He says it could have flaked off. If he was attacker, 1 would expect he would be drenched in blood. Does that not place him further away from attack, Botha asks.
Debate on the location of blood splatter between Botha and
Judge Desai
14:57
ShareIcon
Desai asks Botha to explain the lack of blood stains in the
upper part of Henri's body
14:53
ShareIcon
If Dr Olckers wasn't brought in, the court would have been under impression that #VanBreda's mother and brother's DNA had been under his nails, on his shorts and in the shower, Adv Botha says.
Botha arguing that the State's DNA results were biased
14:42
ShareIcon
His client handled the axe after being stabbed and shortly after Rudi was attacked. When #VanBreda threw axe and it hit the wall, blood was liquid enough to cause a flow pattern, Adv Botha says.
Question on a matter of record momentarily throws Botha from
course, but he is soon back to full voice
14:37
ShareIcon
Evidence corroborates Henri's version of events, says Botha
14:36
ShareIcon
Henri admitted that he handled the axe after the crime, says
Botha
14:35
ShareIcon
Blood stain in bathroom- a suspected print or a stain- in the bathroom could not have been #VanBreda, Botha says, because there was no blood under Henri's sock. No evidence proving Henri made this stain.
Botha has tackled security, DNA evidence and blood splatter –
key evidence in the State's case against Henri van Breda
14:30
ShareIcon
Blood stains on #VanBreda does not mean he was the attacker, only places him in the immediate vicinity, Adv Botha says. Impact spatter on socks excludes possibility his client was wearing shoes and took it off. Blood on heel excludes him as attacker, faces away from event.
Blood from the axe dripped on Henri van Breda's heel, says
Botha
14:28
ShareIcon
Botha argues that impact splatter evidence helps his case
14:26
ShareIcon
We're back live
13:08
ShareIcon
Adv Botha says SOPs not followed, lab not accredited, analyst didn't pass proficiency test. Dr Olckers found findings not scientifically reliable. To retest 155 samples would've meant #VanBreda would have been out fo funds a long time ago. Botha made decision not to test.
Why has SAPS lab not been able to get accreditation within last 16 years? They have been incapable of qualifying for accreditation, Adv Botha says. #VanBreda
According to case law, you can't have regard to samples that
have not been tested according to Standard Operating Procedures, Botha argues
12:46
ShareIcon
Adv Botha says Dr Olckers was right when said SAPS lab hadn't complied with SOPs in terms of same case being separated on worksheets to prevent cross-contamination. Findings not scientifically sound it procedure not followed. #VanBreda
Botha says the DNA result was not scientifically sound
12:40
ShareIcon
Adv Botha now moving onto the DNA evidence. Judge Desai asks why Dr Olckers didn't test samples? Adv Botha says without Dr Olckers, we would still believe DNA of Henri, mother and Rudi was in shower, as well as other clarity surrounding mix samples. #VanBreda
The only thing that bothers me is that she could have simply
rebutted the State's case, says Desai of Dr Antonel Olckers
12:36
ShareIcon
Why did your expert witness not test the samples herself and
say that they are wrong?
Desai tackles Dr Antonel Olckers
Botha says her evidence was valuable
12:32
ShareIcon
Adv Botha says her bias was displayed when she said she didn't know at time that #VanBreda was busy attacking his family. When she testified she made a connection. Judge Desai says no, she slept through attack, she heard what happened prior. Asks why she would be biased.
Desai argues: Why would a neighbour who doesn't even know
you, come to testify against you?
Botha says he doesn't know why, except to say that it is
there
12:30
ShareIcon
Adv Botha maintains his client was a good witness. According to WO Hitchcock's recording of the scene, a DVD was next to TV, couch and pillows indicate that people had been watching tv. Adv Botha says she should have called security if she was concerned. #VanBreda
Desai says the neighbours may not have wanted to interfere
in the Van Breda household "fight".
"Where I grew up, everybody would rush out and join the
fight"
12:22
ShareIcon
Opt' Hof couldn't determine language, how many people involved, what was being said, Adv Botha says. Can we exclude it was coming from another house? Judge Desai says she was an objective witness. You suggesting she is dishonest? No, Botha says. Believes she was biased. #VanBreda
Judge Desai and Botha have mini debate on the neighbour's child
who woke up at 04:00
12:19
ShareIcon
Adv Botha says security guard Wyngaard was 40m from #VanBreda house and was tasked with looking out for disturbances. He didn't hear anything. Annelize Taljaard, another neighbour, said she didn't hear anything.
Improbable that neither Henri nor Marli didn't tell their girlfriend/boyfriend that there was an argument in the #VanBreda house if there had been one, Adv Botha says.
News24 allows you to edit the display of certain components based on a location.
If you wish to personalise the page based on your preferences, please select a
location for each component and click "Submit" in order for the changes to
take affect.
*
*
Saving your settings
Facebook Sign-In
Hi News addict,
Join the News24 Community to be involved in breaking the news.
Log in with Facebook to comment and personalise news, weather and listings.
