President Trump called New York Times report that he ordered special counsel Robert Mueller fired 'fake news.' The Times reports Trump ordered the firing last June but backed off when White House lawyer Don McGahn threatened to quit. (Jan. 26) AP
WASHINGTON — If Russia special counsel Robert Mueller is building a case of obstruction against President Trump, the president’s thwarted attempt to fire the special counsel last year may have made Mueller’s job that much easier.
Even though White House Counsel Donald McGahn successfully headed off Trump’s reported effort Mueller could use the episode as evidence of Trump’s intent to shield himself from possible legal jeopardy, analysts said.
The New York Times and The Washington Post reported late Thursday that Trump ordered McGahn to fire Mueller in June, but McGahn refused and threatened to quit if the president insisted. The reports said Trump abandoned the idea after that. Trump on Friday dismissed the report as "fake news."
'EXPLICIT EVIDENCE' OF INTENT
“The hardest thing to prove in most obstruction cases is intent to obstruct,” former federal prosecutor Patrick Cotter said. “Explicit evidence of such an intent, like actually ordering Mueller’s firing, is extremely valuable to the investigators.
“This evidence,” Cotter said, “will make it even harder for Trump to argue that whatever he did —was not because he was trying to obstruct.”
Ron Hosko, former chief of the FBI’s criminal division, said the president has placed himself in a potentially “precarious” legal position that also will make a looming interview with Mueller’s investigators even more complicated.
“If Mueller also has evidence that the Trump campaign coordinated with the Russians, the president’s attempt to fire Mueller only invites an obstruction charge,” Hosko said. “And if there is evidence of an underlying crime of collusion, I think you could see Mueller move very quickly.”
An obstruction case would be harder to prosecute without evidence of an underlying crime, such as colluding with a foreign government to tip an election.
BUILDING THE CASE
While Trump’s push against Mueller was first disclosed by the New York Times late Thursday, it is likely that the special counsel—who already has interviewed McGahn, then-chief of staff Reince Preibus and former press secretary Sean Spicer—has been aware of the failed effort for some time.
“In addition to the interviews, Mueller likely has the text messages, emails and other communications that will provide a fuller context to what led to this (attempt to fire Mueller) and the decision to dismiss former FBI Director James Comey,” Hosko said.
Comey’s dismissal, which came just a month prior to move against Mueller, has been a central focus of the obstruction examination.
In the days after the firing of Comey, who was managing the Russia investigation, Trump told NBC News that the director’s dismissal was linked to his handling of the Russia inquiry.
“You know, this Russia thing with Trump and Russia is a made-up story,” the president said then. “It’s an excuse by the Democrats for having lost an election that they should’ve won.”
Since his firing, Comey has become a an important witness for Mueller related to the president’s possible attempts at obstruction, disclosing last year that he kept detailed memos of every encounter with Trump.
Among those contacts: the president allegedly asked Comey to pledge his loyalty to him. He also urged Comey to drop the FBI’s investigation into former national security adviser Michael Flynn for lying about his contacts with Russian Ambassador Sergey Kislyak just prior to the inauguration in which the two discussed the lifting of Obama administration sanctions against Russia.
Flynn pleaded guilty last month to lying to the FBI and is cooperating with the continuing special counsel’s investigation.
SESSIONS' ROLE
Mueller’s focus on possible obstruction emerged in fuller view earlier this week, when the Justice Department acknowledged that Attorney General Jeff Sessions had been interviewed for several hours by Mueller’s team.
Sessions, who participated in Comey’s firing, also is a key witness to the events that prompted the abrupt dismissal.
The attorney general, who recused himself last year from the Russia inquiry because of his own campaign-related contacts with Kislyak, has said that Comey was fired last May because of his controversial handling of the investigation into Hillary Clinton’s use of private email server while she was secretary of State.
Yet only a month after dismissing Comey, an angry president apparently sought to take out Mueller, too, said officials familiar with the incident.
OVAL OFFICE IRE
Trump was upset about what he believed was Mueller's alleged conflicts—his interest in replacing Comey as FBI director, Mueller’s resignation from a Trump-owned golf club and political affiliations at Mueller’s law firm —and talked to his lawyers about them, they said.
His lawyers convinced him it was a bad idea and eventually Trump pledged to work with Mueller's office, which they said he has done.
At the same time, the officials said that Trump discussed possibly firing Mueller with his friends.
Christopher Ruddy, CEO of Newsmax Media and a friend of Trump, told the PBS NewsHour in June:
“I think he’s considering perhaps terminating the special counsel. I think he’s weighing that option ... I personally think it would be a very significant mistake.”
Yet legal analysts said the collective weight of Trump's actions is pushing him closer to an ugly confrontation with the special counsel.
"The evidence is compelling of President Trump's corrupt intent to thwart the Russia investigation and obstruct justice," said University of Notre Dame law professor Jimmy Gurule, .
"Trump, by his own admission, fired former FBI director James Comey because of the 'Russia thing.' One month later, the president attempted to fire Mueller, who was conducting the Russia investigation, said Gurule, a former federal prosecutor who worked in the administration of President George H.W. Bush. "The only reasonable inference to draw is that Trump, with corrupt intent, attempted to obstruct and impede the due administration of justice, which is a federal crime."
- Audio: Trump 'looking forward' to Mueller interview
- Sessions Questioned in Mueller's Russia Probe
- Top Democrat accuses White House of 'gag order' on Bannon
- AP Sources: WH Directs Bannon At House Interview
- Report: Steven Bannon subpoenaed in Mueller's Russia investigation
- Poll: Majority of voters think Mueller investigation is 'fair'
- Trump: Interview Unlikely in Mueller Probe
- House Democrats want to subpoena the Trump organization
- Trump refuses to commit to Mueller interview for Russia probe
- Report warns of Russian meddling
- Trump's lawyer sues BuzzFeed for defamation over Russia dossier
- U.S. must act now to ward off Russian election meddling in 2018
- Pelosi, Dems blast House GOP over Russia probe
- Author of Trump Dossier was told FBI had a 'source' inside campaign
- Russian lawyer believes she met Ivanka after 2016 Trump Tower meeting
- Attorneys discuss options for Trump interview in Mueller Russia probe
- Robert Mueller may have a 'deep throat' witness
- Bannon calls Trump Jr.'s meeting with Russian lawyer 'treasonous'
- Trump: 'No collusion,' but Russia probe makes U.S. look 'very bad'
- Russian hackers targeted over 200 journalists globally during election
- Bannon and Lewandowski asked to testify in House Russia probe
- CNN: Trump reportedly says Mueller will exonerate him soon
- Poll: Majority disapprove of Trump's handling of Russia probe
- Sen. Warner cautions Trump: Don't remove Mueller
- Report: FBI warned Trump that Russia might try to infiltrate campaign
- President Trump won't rule out pardoning Michael Flynn
- Trump still hasn't had a cabinet meeting on Russian interference
- James Comey sends cryptic tweet over 'character' of leaders
- Rosenstein grilled on Mueller probe and FBI bias
- What does Flynn’s guilty plea mean for Pence?
- Dem: Evidence of Trump-Russia coordination 'damning'
- Trump & Russia: Lawyer denies Deutsche subpoena
- More charges may be coming for ex-Trump campaign aide
- Report: Robert Mueller subpoenas Deutsche Bank on Trump's finances
- Trump: 'I feel badly for General Flynn'
- Lawyer says he wrote Trump's tweet about Michael Flynn
- Trump targets FBI in early morning tweets
- Russian lawmakers dismiss Michael Flynn plea
- Trump on Flynn Guilty Plea: 'No Collusion'
- Here's how The White House responded to Mike Flynn's plea deal
- AP explains Michael Flynn's court appearance
- AP: Kushner directed Flynn to contact Russia
- Michael Flynn pleads guilty to lying to FBI
- Senators say Kushner isn't being forthcoming in their Russia probe
- Reports: Anti-Trump texts got an FBI agent pulled from Russia probe
- Shaub: Trump's tweet on Michael Flynn could be the end
- Wall Street falls on Russia probe
- Flynn says Trump transition team directed him
- The fall of Michael Flynn: A timeline
- Poll: Majority of voters say Mueller is running fair Russia probe
- FBI probing Russian payments ‘to finance election campaign of 2016’
- Jeff Sessions calls out lies in House hearing
- Trump: Putin believes Russia didn't hack election
- Report: Mueller Investigating Flynn over in alleged extradition plot
- Russia Twitter trolls deflected Trump bad news
- Schiff: U.S. democracy under threat
- Ross says he didn't conceal his ties to a Russian energy company
- Carter Page downplayed his Russia trip during his House testimony
- Nearly half of Americans think Trump committed Russia-related crime
- Russian hackers tried to gain access to emails from top U.S. generals
- Gov. Chris Christie: Mueller's targets ‘should be concerned’
- Trump tweets about 'witch hunt' as Mueller charges loom
- Here are lawmakers' early reactions to the Manafort, Gates indictments
- When asked about collusion, Sanders points to Clinton
- Ryan: Manafort, Gates indictments 'big news'
- Manafort indicted; Ex-Trump aide pleads guilty
- First charges in Mueller's Russia probe filed
- Report: Trump pledges $430K to pay staffers' Russia probe legal fees
- Report: Russia is behind fake GOP Twitter account
- Leaked memo: Russian Lawyer in Trump, Jr meeting may be Kremlin agent
- Were Russian trolls trained by watching 'House of Cards'?
- The Trump reelection campaign has spent $1 million on lawyers
- Reince Priebus grilled in Mueller investigation
- Google reportedly finds political ads in its network linked to Russia
- Emails reportedly show Trump Jr.'s Russia meeting was about sanctions
- Report: Russia-backed Facebook page sold merchandise to spark tension
- Robert Mueller's team met with spy who provided Trump-Russia dossier
- Investigators Say Russia Is Still Trying to Interfere in U.S. Politics
- Senate Intel Head: Issue of collusion still open
- Facebook will hire 1,000 people to review ads
- Another social media giant met with lawmakers to discuss Russia
- Report: Sean Spicer hires criminal defense attorney in Russia probe
- Roger Stone asserts that Trump campaign did not collude with Russia
- Homeland security confirms 21 States targeted in 2016 Russia hacks
- Trump loops Facebook into the 'Russia hoax'
- Liam Neeson sees 'similarities' between Watergate and Russia scandal
- Facebook to release Russia ads to Congress
- Rep. Waters: I 'guarantee' the president colluded with the Russians
- Senate opens previously closed Russia hearing with Trump's lawyer
- Special counsel Mueller is investigating Facebook ads linked to Russia
- Michael Flynn Jr. is being investigated in the Federal Russia probe
- Report: Trump ranting about Comey and Mueller behind closed doors
- Trump campaign reportedly hands over documents to Robert Mueller
- Top Democrat says Russian Facebook ads are the 'tip of the iceberg'
- Trump Administration closes three Russian diplomatic locations
- Dan Rather says Trump is ‘seized with fear’ over Mueller investigation
- Robert Mueller subpoenas Paul Manafort's spokesman and former attorney
- Pro-Russian bots are helping the white nationalist cause
- Putin's spokesman confirms he received email from Trump's lawyer
- Kremlin: Trump Moscow real estate inquiry was ignored
- Report: Trump campaign aide repeatedly tried to set up Russia meetings
- Investigators want to question Trump's secretary over Russia probe
- FBI raids home of Trump's ex-campaign chairman amid Russia probe
- Mueller grand jury could mean criminal evidence has been found
- Kislyak: Talks With Flynn Revealed 'No Secrets'
- Trump to West Virginians: 'Are there any Russians here tonight?'
- Trump: 'The Russia story is a total fabrication'
- President Trump dismisses Russia questions as grand jury impaneled
- Special counsel Robert Mueller convenes grand jury in Russia probe
- Senators band together to protect Robert Mueller's job
- Report: President Trump dictated son's Russia statement
- Foreign agents in the spotlight in Trump-Russia investigation
- Republicans block an attempt to investigate president Trump's finances
- Trump on Russia investigation: 'Next up, 11-year-old Barron Trump!'
- Lawmakers say Facebook holds the answers to the Trump's ties to Russia
- Trump sends warning to Mueller
- Sessions steadfast amid Trump dissatisfaction
- The Russia probe is now focusing on Trump's digital campaign
- 8th person at Donald Trump Jr's meeting with a Russian lawyer revealed
- Trump questions Putin. Trevor Noah has questions about Trump.
- Secret Service dumps cold water on vetting Donald Trump Jr.'s meeting
- New figure emerges in Trump, Jr. meeting
- Trump: Most 'would have taken that meeting'
- Vice President Pence's spokesman not saying he met Russian Operatives
- Sen. Graham seems really ticked about Trump Jr.'s Russia meeting
- Corey Lewandowski predicts White House leakers will be fired
- Colbert finds Don Jr.'s smoking gun
- Watergate special prosecutor to Congress, keep up the Russian probes
- Trump Jr's Russia meeting has White House on hunt for the mole
- D.C. reacts to Donald Trump Jr.'s Russia emails
- The Russian sanctions that led to Trump Jr.'s Kremlin-tied meeting
- Senator Ted Cruz dodged questions on Trump's ties with Russian
- Trump statement: Son is 'high-quality person'
- Publicist set up Trump Jr. and lawyer meeting
- Donald Trump Jr. tweets email chain on Russia meeting
- Donald Trump Jr. releases email thread about Russian lawyer meeting
- Russian lawyer who met with Trump, Jr. says no damaging Clinton info
- The man behind the Trump Jr. meeting checked in on Facebook
- Conflicting stories on if Kremlin was involved in Trump Jr.'s meeting
- Report: Trump Jr. met with Russian lawyer during campaign
- Putin: No grounds for U.S. election allegations
- Paul Manafort registered as a foreign agent ... 5 years late
- See who's got Trump's back in the Russia investigation
- Trump suggests his 'tapes' tweet was to keep Comey honest
- Obama planned to leave 'digital bombs' for Russia after hacking
- Intel officials: Trump suggested refuting Russia collusion
- Legal answers to questions about Donald Trump and Robert Mueller
- Obama officials worried alarm over Russian interference would backfire
- Johnson defends Comey judgment on Russia probe
- Russia tried to hack election systems in 21 states
- Sean Hannity compares Russia investigation to the 'birther' conspiracy
- White House reportedly hoping to block tougher sanctions on Russia
- Trump's personal lawyer hires his own lawyer in wake of Russia probe
- Trump's Deputy AG may also have to recuse himself from Russia probe
- Vice President Pence lawyers up for Russia investigation
- Putin says Russia is open to James Comey if he faces 'persecution'
- Special counsel Robert Mueller will investigate President Trump
- Jeff Sessions wants to clear the air on his conversations with Comey
- Some of Trump's supporters think Robert Mueller should be fired
- AG Sessions to testify before Senate Intelligence Committee
- Republican U.S. Rep. defends both Trump and Comey
- Trump: 'WOW, Comey is a leaker'
- Comey: Lordy I hope there are tapes
- Analysis: Comey Opens Up About Trump Meetings
- Trump's pick for the next FBI director has Russian ties of his own
- Trump allies take aim at Comey's credibility
- Most people don't trust Trump in the Russia investigation
- Top Law Firms Reportedly Declined to Represent Trump in Russia Investigation
- Report: Trump team sought to lift Russian sanctions
- The FBI's Russia probe is reaching across the pond
- It's official, James Comey will testify about Trump and Russia
- The White House says it won't answer questions about Russia anymore
- There's a new name in the FBI's Trump-Russia collusion probe
- Michael Flynn pleads The Fifth over Russia investigation
- Trump reportedly asked intel chiefs to deny evidence in Russia probe
- Trump to Russians: Firing 'nut job' James Comey relieved pressure
- Trump says special counsel appointment is a 'witch hunt'
- TIME's new cover gives the White House a renovation
- Russia tried to take over 10,000 Pentagon workers Twitter accounts
- Trump team had a lot more contact with Russia than thought
- Former FBI Director Mueller to lead Russia probe
- Russia investigation special counsel: Who is Robert Mueller?
- Ryan: 'We need the facts' on Trump Russia links
- Trump: Russian FM meeting 'very successful'
- White House: No need for special prosecutor
- Trump's lawyers say he has no income from Russians
- Sean Hannity claims Trump-Russia link is a ‘bizarre conspiracy theory’
- Michael Flynn associates issued subpoenas in Russia investigation
- Republican Senator wants to investigate Trump for Russian ties
- Sally Yates to testify on Russia election probe
- Trump properties tied to alleged Russian mobsters
- Trump's former manager Paul Manafort reportedly pitched plan to benefit Vladimir Putin
- John McCain on President Trump's Russian Connections: 'Lot of Shoes to Drop'
- Report: Trump campaign approved adviser's trip to Russia
- Dems: Trump, Russia relationship 'disconcerting'