CLOSE

President Trump is drawing an angry response, after using an expletive to describe the countries that many immigrants in the U.S. came from. One critic is Republican congresswoman Ileana Ros-Lehtinen of Florida, who says Trump has a long history of making racist statements. (Jan. 12) AP

EJ Montini: Without them there would be no United States of America.

LINKEDIN 23 COMMENTMORE

At one time or another, just about any place from which anyone has emigrated to America has been referred to as what Donald Trump – the sitting president of the United States – referred to as “s--hole countries.”

Reports say that during a meeting with members of Congress concerning immigration the president got upset when there was talk of immigrants from Haiti and African countries, saying, “Why are we having all these people from shithole countries come here?"

Trump grew up in New York, but I guess he never got around to reading the inscription on the State of Liberty.

His own ancestors trace their roots to places like Germany and Scotland.

At different times in our past, there were Americans who would have referred to those places using Trump’s crude adjective.

Greatness comes from 's--hole countries'

Contemporary Americans with Haitian family roots include the musician and humanitarian Usher and the basketball star Blake Griffin.

As for Africa, there are too many Americans of importance of African ancestry to name them all.

DIAZ: Hey, Donald Trump, I'm not Norwegian

Just a few might include Muhammad Ali, Clarence Thomas, Martin Luther King Jr., Willie Mays, Maya Angelou, Jackie Robinson, Booker T. Washington, George Washington Carver and a man you may not have heard of named William H. Carney. He was the first African American awarded the Medal of Honor in the Civil War.

Pick any nation from which America has drawn immigrants and you will find offspring who go on to do great things.

All of those countries, at one time or another, would been called you-know-what countries.

Although, perhaps, not by the president of the United States.

Without them, there would be no us

Early Americans looked down at the Irish.

But among the Americans with lineage to Ireland are Walt Disney, Christa McAuliffe (the teacher-astronaut killed in 1986 Challenger disaster), Audie Murphy (the most decorated soldier of World War II) and more than 20 presidents, ranging from Andrew Jackson to Ulysses S. Grant to John F. Kennedy.

My family came from Italy, among a wave of immigrants from a country perhaps referred to in scatological terms at one time. But without those immigrants there would have been no Americans like Enrico Fermi (the physicist and Nobel Prize recipient), and no Frank Sinatra, Robert De Niro, the businessman Lee Iacocca or the Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia.

MORE: Trump (sort of) denies comment on Twitter

And no me.

And – pick a country – no you.

(Unless you are Native American.)

Someone should remind the president – not that it would do any good – that without the world’s “shithole countries” there would be no America.

MORE FROM MONTINI:

Laid-off Carrier workers brought Trump's 's--'

Drunk who slapped Harvey Weinstein is no hero

Doug Ducey’s new albatross – Joe Arpaio

  • Montini: We failed a big test on charter schools
    Montini: We failed a big test on charter schools
  • Montini: This is even better than the Pence Rule
    Montini: This is even better than the Pence Rule
  • Montini: Senate passed tax bill before reading it
    Montini: Senate passed tax bill before reading it
  • Montini: Ask your boss about Trump's tax plan
    Montini: Ask your boss about Trump's tax plan
  • Montini: Why I'm thankful to live in Arizona
    Montini: Why I'm thankful to live in Arizona
  • Montini: Trump's border wall has already been breached
    Montini: Trump's border wall has already been breached
  • Montini: Let's treat guns like trucks
    Montini: Let's treat guns like trucks
  • Montini: Fontes has a potty mouth, you know who else does?
    Montini: Fontes has a potty mouth, you know who else does?
  • Montini: Donald Trump is like a State Fair corndog
    Montini: Donald Trump is like a State Fair corndog
  • Montini: Donald Trump can't keep the media in the dark
    Montini: Donald Trump can't keep the media in the dark
  • Montini: Why shouldn't sports and politics mix?
    Montini: Why shouldn't sports and politics mix?
  • Montini: Stop following the template on mass shootings
    Montini: Stop following the template on mass shootings
  • Trump's NFL comments stir up racists: Montini
    Trump's NFL comments stir up racists: Montini
  • Montini: We'll need immigrants to rebuild
    Montini: We'll need immigrants to rebuild
  • Montini: Will Congress kick the can on dreamers?
    Montini: Will Congress kick the can on dreamers?
  • Montini: Remember this hero on Sept. 4
    Montini: Remember this hero on Sept. 4
  • Montini: Are dreamers bargaining chips or hostages?
    Montini: Are dreamers bargaining chips or hostages?
  • Montini: Arpaio wins the lottery, begs for change
    Montini: Arpaio wins the lottery, begs for change
  • Montini: This is the real America
    Montini: This is the real America
  • Montini: What you'll need for Trump's Phoenix visit
    Montini: What you'll need for Trump's Phoenix visit
  • Montini: Mr. Governor, tear down this memorial
    Montini: Mr. Governor, tear down this memorial
  • Montini: Will Doug Ducey whiff on Obamacare?
    Montini: Will Doug Ducey whiff on Obamacare?
  • Montini: The kind of Trumpcare we really need
    Montini: The kind of Trumpcare we really need
  • EJ Montini: Health care isn't like grocery shopping
    EJ Montini: Health care isn't like grocery shopping
  • Montini: Hobby Lobby's unholy ISIS link
    Montini: Hobby Lobby's unholy ISIS link
  • Montini: Robert Mueller has way more political capital than Andy Biggs
    Montini: Robert Mueller has way more political capital than Andy Biggs
  • Montini: How can you possibly live in that heat?
    Montini: How can you possibly live in that heat?
  • Montini: Schweikert begs for cash to protect him from cookies
    Montini: Schweikert begs for cash to protect him from cookies
  • Montini: What about homegrown terrorists?
    Montini: What about homegrown terrorists?
  • Montini: That colander guy is onto something
    Montini: That colander guy is onto something
  • Montini: Arizona is like the worst gym on Earth
    Montini: Arizona is like the worst gym on Earth
  • Montini: Did Trump bow to the Saudi King?
    Montini: Did Trump bow to the Saudi King?
  • Montini volunteers free tickets - with Bickley's help
    Montini volunteers free tickets - with Bickley's help
  • Montini: How you can honor Tucson shooting victims
    Montini: How you can honor Tucson shooting victims
  • Montini: Trump's voter fraud commission is a fraud
    Montini: Trump's voter fraud commission is a fraud
  • Montini: Congress can opt themselves out of Trumpcare
    Montini: Congress can opt themselves out of Trumpcare
  • Montini: 'I think you're the communist'
    Montini: 'I think you're the communist'
  • Montini: This bill lets anyone privately buy a gun
    Montini: This bill lets anyone privately buy a gun
  • Montini: You really are as stupid as you look
    Montini: You really are as stupid as you look
  • Montini: Drop the criminal case against Joe Arpaio
    Montini: Drop the criminal case against Joe Arpaio
  • Montini: Want to be a brick in the border wall?
    Montini: Want to be a brick in the border wall?
  • Montini: Vouchers are like a game of three-card monte
    Montini: Vouchers are like a game of three-card monte
  • Montini: Congress should treat the Supreme Court like a pepperoni pizza
    Montini: Congress should treat the Supreme Court like a pepperoni pizza
  • Montini: Shame on these abortion foes
    Montini: Shame on these abortion foes
  • Montini: Trump spends first 10 weeks on the golf course
    Montini: Trump spends first 10 weeks on the golf course
  • Montini: What drawing a swastika really says about you
    Montini: What drawing a swastika really says about you
  • Montini: Wool pulled over Republican politician's eyes on replacement for Obamacare
    Montini: Wool pulled over Republican politician's eyes on replacement for Obamacare
  • Montini: So, Trump apologizes to Obama ... nah ...
    Montini: So, Trump apologizes to Obama ... nah ...
  • Montini: Work or spring training baseball? You decide
    Montini: Work or spring training baseball? You decide
  • Montini: How do we really fix Obamacare?
    Montini: How do we really fix Obamacare?
  • Montini: Supreme Court should order respect with their fries
    Montini: Supreme Court should order respect with their fries
  • Montini: Would you call Lori Piestewa a squaw?
    Montini: Would you call Lori Piestewa a squaw?
  • Montini: Trump's actions take us back to 1988 Arizona
    Montini: Trump's actions take us back to 1988 Arizona
  • Montini: Arizona's Republican congressional delegation are lap dogs
    Montini: Arizona's Republican congressional delegation are lap dogs

 

LINKEDIN 23 COMMENTMORE
Read or Share this story: http://azc.cc/2D7eLws