Arsenal
Bournemouth
Brighton & Hove Albion
Burnley
Chelsea
Crystal Palace
Everton
Huddersfield Town
Leicester City
Liverpool
Manchester City
Manchester United
Newcastle United
Southampton
Stoke City
Swansea City
Tottenham Hotspur
Watford
West Bromwich Albion
West Ham
Aston Villa
Barnsley
Birmingham City
Bolton Wanderers
Brentford
Bristol City
Burton Albion
Cardiff City
Derby County
Fulham
Hull City
Ipswich Town
Leeds United
Middlesbrough
Millwall
Norwich City
Nottingham Forest
Preston North End
Queens Park Rangers
Reading
Sheffield United
Sheffield Wednesday
Sunderland
Wolverhampton
Aberdeen
Celtic
Dundee
Hamilton Academical
Hearts
Hibernian
Kilmarnock
Motherwell
Partick Thistle
Rangers
Ross County
St Johnstone
A.C. Milan
A.S. Roma
AS Monaco FC
Atletico Madrid
Barcelona
Bayern Munich
Borussia Dortmund
Inter Milan
Juventus FC
Napoli
PSG
RB Leipzig
Real Madrid
Sevilla
Valencia CF

VAR crisis: Chelsea boss Antonio Conte action confirms curse on English football

ANTONIO CONTE leapt around the touchline in his usual manic fashion as the referee waved away a penalty appeal for his Chelsea team, and then he made use of the new weapon in an angry football manager’s armoury of discontent.

Antonio ConteGETTY

Antonio Conte made a 'square in the air' motion

He confronted the ever hapless fourth official and drew an imaginary ‘square in the air’ to plead for the referee to assess the incident against with a video replay.

And so the curse of technology was launched into English football.

The game will only suffer.

In this instance, Martin Atkinson, the on-field ref in last week’s League Cup semi-final between Chelsea and Arsenal, had already decided to use the new VAR system.

Replays confirmed his initial decision was correct, and Mr Atkinson was a happy boy with his new toy. But this was an easy call for the ref, one that really didn’t need a second look from the video ref in his bunker somewhere near Heathrow Airport.

It was another glimpse, like Conte’s hand signal, of where football is heading --- to a future of matches full of delays and phoney controversies as so many incidents get the VAR treatment.

We have already seen from evidence this season in Germany and Italy, where VAR is being used in League matches, that some difficult decisions, the ones that always split opinion, can stop play for three, four and five  minutes at a time. 

It was inevitable --- and most people hate it. Yet it will only get worse.

Look at what happened in rugby and cricket. Video replays were introduced with the intention, like football now, of being used sparingly, and only on major moments.

Once the genie was out of the bottle, though, technology took over; it trampled all over their sports.

In rugby they call it TMO. Many matches are now so stop-start they last more than two hours, despite being the game being 40 minutes per half.

In cricket they call it DRS. The use has mushroomed from the line decisions of run-out calls to lbws, dubious catches, no-balls, snicko for edges, and boundary fielding issues. 

If you believe in football’s current insistence that VAR will be a rare event in a match, well, you are living in a fool’s paradise.

Ah, but it will deliver sporting justice say noisy supporters.

That’s another myth.

Yes, of course, there will be occasions when the use of VAR does correct a bad and crucial mistake by the officials. That will be welcome when it happens, and it would be stupid to deny that.

But will these moments be worth all the negative consequences? I’m certain they won’t.

Call it TMO, DRS or VAR, the truth is that they will not and cannot provide perfect sporting justice. Rugby and cricket still abound with arguments about decisions --- think of the furore around a dodgy stumping verdict on Moeen Ali in the recent Ashes campaign.

That series ended with England star Jonny Bairstow moaning that DRS was messing with players’ careers.

In German football this season there has already been a manager sent off for coming onto the pitch to protest about VAR decision he did not agree with.

The systems cause much more trouble than they solve.

This is not a plea for VAR to disappear. That battle is lost. It is a lament for the future, one that will see football fans, players, managers and TV pundits scream for more and more use.

Jonny BairstowGETTY

Jonny Bairstow has had his problems with DRS

Conte’s ‘square in the air’ is a prelude to demands for managers to be allowed reviews of incidents in the way that happens in cricket and tennis. It will be granted --- and you can surely imagine the aggravation that will ensue.

The unintended consequence of all this will be diminished respect for referees, and diminished authority.

Players will query decisions because they know technology may prove their point. Referees will become less certain of themselves, and they will ask for replays rather than be made to look like chumps.

This is clear enough from the pattern or rugby and cricket. Refs and umpires increasingly decline to trust the certainty of their own judgement as they always used to, and just defer to technology.

How many ridiculously obvious run-out decisions are now referred by umpires who have become fearful that technology may show an error?

What has happened in cricket will happen in football soon enough.

The ability to challenge an umpire’s decision has changed the dynamic of relationship between players and officials --- and not just at elite level.

Watch the game at grass roots on a village green and you routinely witness players drawing the TV ‘square in the air’ at umpires to show displeasure at a decision.

When sport actively encourages competitors to distrust the decisions of the neutral arbiter, the outcome can only be a matter of deep regret.

Arsenal
Bournemouth
Brighton & Hove Albion
Burnley
Chelsea
Crystal Palace
Everton
Huddersfield Town
Leicester City
Liverpool
Manchester City
Manchester United
Newcastle United
Southampton
Stoke City
Swansea City
Tottenham Hotspur
Watford
West Bromwich Albion
West Ham
Aston Villa
Barnsley
Birmingham City
Bolton Wanderers
Brentford
Bristol City
Burton Albion
Cardiff City
Derby County
Fulham
Hull City
Ipswich Town
Leeds United
Middlesbrough
Millwall
Norwich City
Nottingham Forest
Preston North End
Queens Park Rangers
Reading
Sheffield United
Sheffield Wednesday
Sunderland
Wolverhampton
Aberdeen
Celtic
Dundee
Hamilton Academical
Hearts
Hibernian
Kilmarnock
Motherwell
Partick Thistle
Rangers
Ross County
St Johnstone
A.C. Milan
A.S. Roma
AS Monaco FC
Atletico Madrid
Barcelona
Bayern Munich
Borussia Dortmund
Inter Milan
Juventus FC
Napoli
PSG
RB Leipzig
Real Madrid
Sevilla
Valencia CF

VAR crisis: Chelsea boss Antonio Conte action confirms curse on English football

ANTONIO CONTE leapt around the touchline in his usual manic fashion as the referee waved away a penalty appeal for his Chelsea team, and then he made use of the new weapon in an angry football manager’s armoury of discontent.

Antonio ConteGETTY

Antonio Conte made a 'square in the air' motion

He confronted the ever hapless fourth official and drew an imaginary ‘square in the air’ to plead for the referee to assess the incident against with a video replay.

And so the curse of technology was launched into English football.

The game will only suffer.

In this instance, Martin Atkinson, the on-field ref in last week’s League Cup semi-final between Chelsea and Arsenal, had already decided to use the new VAR system.

Replays confirmed his initial decision was correct, and Mr Atkinson was a happy boy with his new toy. But this was an easy call for the ref, one that really didn’t need a second look from the video ref in his bunker somewhere near Heathrow Airport.

It was another glimpse, like Conte’s hand signal, of where football is heading --- to a future of matches full of delays and phoney controversies as so many incidents get the VAR treatment.

We have already seen from evidence this season in Germany and Italy, where VAR is being used in League matches, that some difficult decisions, the ones that always split opinion, can stop play for three, four and five  minutes at a time. 

It was inevitable --- and most people hate it. Yet it will only get worse.

Look at what happened in rugby and cricket. Video replays were introduced with the intention, like football now, of being used sparingly, and only on major moments.

Once the genie was out of the bottle, though, technology took over; it trampled all over their sports.

In rugby they call it TMO. Many matches are now so stop-start they last more than two hours, despite being the game being 40 minutes per half.

In cricket they call it DRS. The use has mushroomed from the line decisions of run-out calls to lbws, dubious catches, no-balls, snicko for edges, and boundary fielding issues. 

If you believe in football’s current insistence that VAR will be a rare event in a match, well, you are living in a fool’s paradise.

Ah, but it will deliver sporting justice say noisy supporters.

That’s another myth.

Yes, of course, there will be occasions when the use of VAR does correct a bad and crucial mistake by the officials. That will be welcome when it happens, and it would be stupid to deny that.

But will these moments be worth all the negative consequences? I’m certain they won’t.

Call it TMO, DRS or VAR, the truth is that they will not and cannot provide perfect sporting justice. Rugby and cricket still abound with arguments about decisions --- think of the furore around a dodgy stumping verdict on Moeen Ali in the recent Ashes campaign.

That series ended with England star Jonny Bairstow moaning that DRS was messing with players’ careers.

In German football this season there has already been a manager sent off for coming onto the pitch to protest about VAR decision he did not agree with.

The systems cause much more trouble than they solve.

This is not a plea for VAR to disappear. That battle is lost. It is a lament for the future, one that will see football fans, players, managers and TV pundits scream for more and more use.

Jonny BairstowGETTY

Jonny Bairstow has had his problems with DRS

Conte’s ‘square in the air’ is a prelude to demands for managers to be allowed reviews of incidents in the way that happens in cricket and tennis. It will be granted --- and you can surely imagine the aggravation that will ensue.

The unintended consequence of all this will be diminished respect for referees, and diminished authority.

Players will query decisions because they know technology may prove their point. Referees will become less certain of themselves, and they will ask for replays rather than be made to look like chumps.

This is clear enough from the pattern or rugby and cricket. Refs and umpires increasingly decline to trust the certainty of their own judgement as they always used to, and just defer to technology.

How many ridiculously obvious run-out decisions are now referred by umpires who have become fearful that technology may show an error?

What has happened in cricket will happen in football soon enough.

The ability to challenge an umpire’s decision has changed the dynamic of relationship between players and officials --- and not just at elite level.

Watch the game at grass roots on a village green and you routinely witness players drawing the TV ‘square in the air’ at umpires to show displeasure at a decision.

When sport actively encourages competitors to distrust the decisions of the neutral arbiter, the outcome can only be a matter of deep regret.

VAR crisis: Chelsea boss Antonio Conte action confirms curse on English football

ANTONIO CONTE leapt around the touchline in his usual manic fashion as the referee waved away a penalty appeal for his Chelsea team, and then he made use of the new weapon in an angry football manager’s armoury of discontent.

Antonio ConteGETTY

Antonio Conte made a 'square in the air' motion

He confronted the ever hapless fourth official and drew an imaginary ‘square in the air’ to plead for the referee to assess the incident against with a video replay.

And so the curse of technology was launched into English football.

The game will only suffer.

In this instance, Martin Atkinson, the on-field ref in last week’s League Cup semi-final between Chelsea and Arsenal, had already decided to use the new VAR system.

Replays confirmed his initial decision was correct, and Mr Atkinson was a happy boy with his new toy. But this was an easy call for the ref, one that really didn’t need a second look from the video ref in his bunker somewhere near Heathrow Airport.

It was another glimpse, like Conte’s hand signal, of where football is heading --- to a future of matches full of delays and phoney controversies as so many incidents get the VAR treatment.

We have already seen from evidence this season in Germany and Italy, where VAR is being used in League matches, that some difficult decisions, the ones that always split opinion, can stop play for three, four and five  minutes at a time. 

It was inevitable --- and most people hate it. Yet it will only get worse.

Look at what happened in rugby and cricket. Video replays were introduced with the intention, like football now, of being used sparingly, and only on major moments.

Once the genie was out of the bottle, though, technology took over; it trampled all over their sports.

In rugby they call it TMO. Many matches are now so stop-start they last more than two hours, despite being the game being 40 minutes per half.

In cricket they call it DRS. The use has mushroomed from the line decisions of run-out calls to lbws, dubious catches, no-balls, snicko for edges, and boundary fielding issues. 

If you believe in football’s current insistence that VAR will be a rare event in a match, well, you are living in a fool’s paradise.

Ah, but it will deliver sporting justice say noisy supporters.

That’s another myth.

Yes, of course, there will be occasions when the use of VAR does correct a bad and crucial mistake by the officials. That will be welcome when it happens, and it would be stupid to deny that.

But will these moments be worth all the negative consequences? I’m certain they won’t.

Call it TMO, DRS or VAR, the truth is that they will not and cannot provide perfect sporting justice. Rugby and cricket still abound with arguments about decisions --- think of the furore around a dodgy stumping verdict on Moeen Ali in the recent Ashes campaign.

That series ended with England star Jonny Bairstow moaning that DRS was messing with players’ careers.

In German football this season there has already been a manager sent off for coming onto the pitch to protest about VAR decision he did not agree with.

The systems cause much more trouble than they solve.

This is not a plea for VAR to disappear. That battle is lost. It is a lament for the future, one that will see football fans, players, managers and TV pundits scream for more and more use.

Jonny BairstowGETTY

Jonny Bairstow has had his problems with DRS

Conte’s ‘square in the air’ is a prelude to demands for managers to be allowed reviews of incidents in the way that happens in cricket and tennis. It will be granted --- and you can surely imagine the aggravation that will ensue.

The unintended consequence of all this will be diminished respect for referees, and diminished authority.

Players will query decisions because they know technology may prove their point. Referees will become less certain of themselves, and they will ask for replays rather than be made to look like chumps.

This is clear enough from the pattern or rugby and cricket. Refs and umpires increasingly decline to trust the certainty of their own judgement as they always used to, and just defer to technology.

How many ridiculously obvious run-out decisions are now referred by umpires who have become fearful that technology may show an error?

What has happened in cricket will happen in football soon enough.

The ability to challenge an umpire’s decision has changed the dynamic of relationship between players and officials --- and not just at elite level.

Watch the game at grass roots on a village green and you routinely witness players drawing the TV ‘square in the air’ at umpires to show displeasure at a decision.

When sport actively encourages competitors to distrust the decisions of the neutral arbiter, the outcome can only be a matter of deep regret.

Man City Pep Guardiola Premier League Etihad

Man City could throw away Premier League title despite lead - Pep Guardiola

Real Madrid Marcelo La Liga Villarreal defeat

Real Madrid news: Marcelo blasts Los Blancos after shock defeat… I feel like we’re sinking

Liverpool news Mohamed Salah Cristiano Ronaldo Lionel Messi Premier League Ian Rush

Liverpool news: Mohamed Salah is better than Cristiano Ronaldo and Lionel Messi - Rush

Naby Keita RB Leipzig Ralf Rangnick transfer update

Naby Keita: RB Leipzig boss Ralf Rangnick issues fresh transfer update after ‘final match’

Chelsea Leicester Antonio Conte Premier League Stamford Bridge result

Chelsea 0 - Leicester 0: Fans turn on Blues after another lacklustre performance

Hawaii ballistic missile threat warning video watch Donald Trump false alarm drill launch

WATCH: ‘I don’t want to' Terrified Hawaiian girl placed in DRAIN during missile alert

Hawaii ballistic missile threat warning false alarm drill launch attack USA reaction

Hawaii False MISSILE Alert: ‘It was my fault' Employee owns up & reveals how CHAOS started

john worboys rapist release parole prison news latest taxi driver

John Worboys ’too dangerous for an open prison' - so why is set to walk 12 months later?

brexit news eu uk no deal free trade agreement economists for free trade

Brexit shock: No deal will cost EU £500billion

EastEnders Spoilers Phil Mitchell Mel Owen Steve McFadden Tamzin Outhwaite £30K Bail BBC 1

EastEnders spoilers: Phil Mitchell wants £30k back from Mel Owen in historic soap twist

Naby Keita leaving gift RB Leipzig Liverpool

Naby Keita 'delivers leaving gift' for RB Leipzig ahead of Liverpool move

Man Utd transfer news Henrikh Mkhitaryan Jose Mourinho update Old Trafford

Man Utd boss Jose Mourinho gives transfer update on Henrikh Mkhitaryan

Tottenham Everton LIVE updated Premier League

Tottenham 4 - Everton 0: Harry Kane breaks record as Spurs smash Toffees

Newcastle Swansea Joselu Premier League Rafa Benitez

Newcastle 1 - Swansea 1: Joselu ends barren run but Toon still winless in seven

Watford Southampton Abdoulaye Doucoure Premier League

Watford 2 - Southampton 2: Abdoulaye Doucoure late handball denies Saints long-awaited win

Crystal Palace Burnley Roy Hodgson Premier League

Crystal Palace 1 - Burnley 0: Roy Hodgson continues fine form with Eagles

West Brom Brighton Premier League Alan Pardew Chris Hughton Jonny Evans Baggies

West Brom 2 - Brighton 0: Jonny Evans scores on what could be his last game for Baggies

Alexis Sanchez Arsenal Man Utd Man City transfer gossip rumours

Alexis Sanchez: Is this the clue transfer decision is close as Man Utd and Man City wait?

  • Find us on Facebook
  • Follow us on Twitter
  • Check us on Google+
  • Subscribe to our rss feed