NJ.com
  • Home
  • News
  • Politics
  • Sports
  • High School Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Legal Notices
  • Videos
  • Obituaries
  • Autos
  • Jobs
  • Real Estate
  • Rentals
  • Health
  • Classifieds
  • Local Businesses
  • Place An Ad
  • Opinion
  • Follow Us
  • Subscribe
  • News
  • News by County
  • All Newspapers
  • Business
  • Crime
  • Data
  • Education
  • Health
  • Lottery
  • Obituaries
  • Politics
  • Atlantic
  • Bergen
  • Burlington
  • Camden
  • Cape May
  • Cumberland
  • Essex
  • Gloucester
  • Hudson
  • Hunterdon
  • Mercer
  • Middlesex
  • Monmouth
  • Morris
  • Ocean
  • Passaic
  • Salem
  • Somerset
  • Sussex
  • Union
  • Warren
  • The Star-Ledger
  • The Times of Trenton
  • The Jersey Journal
  • South Jersey Times
  • Hunterdon County Democrat
  • Independent Press
  • Horse News
  • Politics Home
  • Chris Christie
  • Opinion
  • The Auditor
  • Sports Home
  • Devils
  • Eagles
  • Flyers
  • Giants
  • Jets
  • Knicks
  • Mets
  • Nets
  • Phillies
  • Rangers
  • Red Bulls
  • Rutgers Basketball
  • Rutgers Football
  • Rutgers Sports
  • Seton Hall
  • Sixers
  • Yankees
  • Football
  • Wrestling
  • Boys Basketball
  • Girls Basketball
  • Boys Bowling
  • Girls Bowling
  • Boys Fencing
  • Girls Fencing
  • Boys Ice Hockey
  • Girls Ice Hockey
  • Boys Skiing
  • Girls Skiing
  • Boys Swimming
  • Girls Swimming
  • Boys Winter Track
  • Girls Winter Track
  • Off Season Sports
  • Bergen County
  • Baseball
  • Boys Cross Country
  • Girls Cross Country
  • Field Hockey
  • Football
  • Boys Golf
  • Girls Golf
  • Gymnastics
  • Boys Lacrosse
  • Girls Lacrosse
  • Boys Soccer
  • Girls Soccer
  • Softball
  • Boys Tennis
  • Girls Tennis
  • Boys Track and Field
  • Girls Track and Field
  • Boys Volleyball
  • Girls Volleyball
  • Wrestling
  • Entertainment Home
  • Atlantic City Entertainment
  • Celebrities
  • Comics
  • Events
  • Food & Dining
  • Arts
  • Indulge
  • Inside Jersey
  • Movies
  • Music
  • Puzzles
  • Shore
  • TV
  • Homes for Sale
  • New Homes
  • For Rent
  • Foreclosures
  • Commercial
  • Real Estate News
  • Resources
  • Place An Ad
  • Home Buying
  • Sell My Home
  • Rental Living
  • Home Ideas
  • Mortgages and Loans
  • I'm Moving
  • Obituaries
  • Rentals
  • Pets
  • For Sale
  • Garage Sales
  • Find n Save
  • Fraud Prevention
  • Manage Your Ad
  • Place An Ad
  • Find A Business
  • Food & Dining
  • Retail Shopping
  • Health & Medicine
  • Personal Care
  • Entertainment
  • Real Estate
  • Automotive
  • Claim Your Business
  • Visit our Facebook Page
  • Follow us on Twitter
  • View our Instagram photos
  • See our Tumblr feed
  • See our Pinterest page
  • Visit us on Google Plus
  • Back to Main Menu
  • Email newsletters
  • The Star-Ledger
  • The Times of Trenton
  • The Jersey Journal
  • South Jersey Times
  • Hunterdon County Democrat
Back to Main Menu

Customize Your Weather

Enter City and State or Zip Code

Congratulations!

Your weather is set to . You can change the location at any time.
AccuWeather.com Quick Look

View Full Weather Report
Close

Sign in to
NJ.com

User Profile
You are signed in as

Edit Public Profile Sign Out
  • Email newsletters
  • The Star-Ledger
  • The Times of Trenton
  • The Jersey Journal
  • South Jersey Times
  • Hunterdon County Democrat

New York Giants

What is 'Plan D' (as in doomsday) for Giants coach? If no Patricia, McDaniels, Shurmur, then what?

Posted January 13, 2018 at 06:15 AM | Updated January 13, 2018 at 06:15 AM
Comment

By Ryan Dunleavy | NJ Advance Media for NJ.com

A 3-in-4 chance is an opportunity you jump at if you are hitting a baseball or playing the lottery.

But it has to scare the Giants' brass.

There are four head coach vacancies and the Giants reportedly narrowed their list to three candidates: Vikings offensive coordinator Pat Shurmur, Patriots offensive coordinator Josh McDaniels and Patriots defensive coordinator Matt Patricia.

Then came a report Friday from Newsday that there is an unknown "sleeper" candidate in the search. It is unclear if the Giants have interviewed that coach or if he has just been identified as a person of interest.

Panthers Falcons Football
David Goldman | AP

So what happens if the Giants are the bridesmaid three times over?

Say, for example, Shurmur lands with the Cardinals where he is thought to be the favorite, McDaniels is drawn to the idea of quarterback Andrew Luck with the Colts as they reportedly seek an offensive-minded coach and Patricia opts to reunite with a fellow Patriots cohort in Lions general manager Bob Quinn.

That's the reason it's risky that the Giants supposedly didn't narrow their original list to four finalists by keeping (most likely) Panthers defensive coordinator Steve Wilks in the mix just to play the safe numbers game.

Or did they?


Remember, it's still not out of the question that another franchise could suddenly be in the market for a coach, as sometimes happens in the NFL out of nowhere in the second half of January. 

Maybe it's the Titans after a playoff loss — Mike Mularky was reportedly on the hot seat before last week's comeback win against the Chiefs —or some other team unhappy with a disagreement about the offseason plan.

If the Giants get caught flat-footed, it will anger a fan base that already voiced its displeasure at the gameday gates with decisions like the second-guessed hiring Ben McAdoo and not retaining Tom Coughlin in a role like he has with the Jaguars, benching Eli Manning for Geno Smith and drafting but not playing Davis Webb.


It also could become that second-tier candidates think twice after being a backup choice that might not get the great job security expected from Giants ownership if better candidates emerge in the 2019 or 2020 offseasons.

Standing an introductory podium trying to win over fans and media who know you were a No. 4 choice at best is a tough way to command credibility.

In all regards, the general manager Dave Gettleman is better off to lock up one of their three finalists with a handshake agreement early next week — even if an official announcement must be delayed under NFL until after the Super Bowl — before being the unsuspecting kid without a chair when the music stops playing.

If not, here are some names for 'Plan D' — the Doomsday scenario:

nfl-philadelphia-eagles-minicamp-755f6d9315585926.jpg
Bill Streitcher | USA TODAY Sports
John DeFilippo, Eagles offensive coordinator

DeFilippo has worked wonders with second-year Eagles quarterback Carson Wentz, who was in the NFL MVP conversation.

DeFilippo was one of the first logical candidates for the Giants. The Bears and Cardinals acted instead of the Giants, with both teams interviewing DeFilippo last week. 

He was the Jets quarterbacks coach when they drafted Mark Sanchez and the Raiders quarterbacks coach when they drafted Derek Carr. Let's hammer home the point: He has been asked to develop young passers.


nj.com

About Us

  • About NJ.com
  • Advertise with us
  • Contact Us
  • Jobs at NJ Advance Media
  • Newsletters
  • Frequently Asked Questions

More on NJ.com

  • Interact
  • Weather
  • Site map
  • Claim your free business listing
  • Sponsor Content
  • Search
  • Place an ad
  • Sell your car
  • Sell/rent your home
  • Post a job
  • Post a free classified ad
  • Apartments & rentals

NJ.com Sections

  • N.J. News
  • Local News
  • N.J. Politics
  • Sports
  • High School Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Food & Recipes
  • Living
  • Business
  • Opinion
  • Inside Jersey
  • Legal Notices
  • Obituaries
  • Jobs
  • Autos
  • Real Estate
  • Rentals
  • Classifieds
  • Shopping Good Deals
  • Local Businesses
  • Special Sections

Contribute to NJ.com

  • Submit an event

Follow Us

  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • Facebook
  • foursquare

Newspaper stories and photos

  • The Star-Ledger | Subscribe
  • The Times of Trenton | Subscribe
  • The Jersey Journal | Subscribe
  • South Jersey Times | Subscribe
  • Hunterdon County Democrat | Subscribe
  • The Warren Reporter
  • Suburban News
  • Horse News
  • Learn more about our newspapers

Mobile

  • iPhone, Android apps | Tablet apps
Advance Digital

Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy

© 2018 New Jersey On-Line LLC. All rights reserved (About Us).
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of New Jersey On-Line LLC.

Community Rules apply to all content you upload or otherwise submit to this site.

Ad Choices