- Arizona becomes the 48th state in the Union
- The story of the gunfight at O.K. Corral
- Winnie Ruth Judd: The Jodi Arias of the 1930s
- Pure Evil: The True Story of the Tison Gang
- 5 things to know about Arizona's World War II internment camps
- Luke Air Force Base
- Arizona Governor Evan Mecham's Impeachment
- Arizona's ties to 2 U.S. Supreme Court justices
- Mesa "Monkey Farm": An urban legend or primate sancturary?
- Tortilla Flat is Old West Arizona
- Whatever happened to Arizona favorite Arnold's Pickles?
- What happened to Manzanita Speedway?
- We were there: 125 years of The Arizona Republic
It's hard to imagine that a town as pristine and tranquil as Young, where majestic elk, cardinals and blue jays meander and flitter among towering Ponderosa and plump juniper trees, could own such a dubious and bloody past.
But the sleepy hamlet 30 miles southeast of Payson along the Mogollon Rim, far removed from the hustle and bustle of, well, anything, wasn't always as undisturbed as it is today — far from it.
In fact, during the 1880s as two dueling families – the Grahams and Tewksburys – turned the town of Pleasant Valley, as it was known back then, into a scene right out of a horror film. Think Arizona's Hatfields and McCoys. Bloodshed and bullets flew as the two clans fought over cattle, sheep, grazing land and other perceived slights.
The Graham-Tewksbury Feud, better known as the Pleasant Valley War, lasted for 10 years from 1882-1892 and is considered one of the longest and bloodiest feuds of its kind in the West.
Sheep, cattle, horse rustling, ambushes and vigilantes
A placard outside of an old church in town reads: “...The Grahams and Tewksburys had been in the cattle business and it seems probable that they first fell out over the division of cattle they jointly owned... Sheep were introduced into the valley in 1887 and this was an aggravating factor, drawing in cattle and sheepmen from Holbrook and Flagstaff. Historians still debate the details of the feud that include brand changing, cattle and horse rustling, ambushes, murder, vigilantes, and lynching. But it is well known that as many as twenty men lay dead by its conclusion.”
MORE: Was the Pleasant Valley War really the bloodbath of legend?
Some estimates put the death toll as high as 50 as fighting spilled beyond Pleasant Valley into Globe and Holbrook. Things became so messy and unruly that it was thought that the Pleasant Valley War may have delayed Arizona's statehood, which wouldn't come until 1912.
Author Rob Lammle wrote in “4 Bloody Feuds in American History” that the situation became “more violent in February 1887, when Thomas Graham shot a Tewksbury hired hand who had been herding sheep on contested grazing land. In retaliation, Graham was shot by Ed Tewksbury, who immediately went on the lam. Shortly after, the Grahams and their sympathizers laid siege to the Tewksbury cabin, engaging in a shootout that lasted for hours.”
The war's final shot
The feud finally came to an end in 1892, Lammle writes, when Tom Graham, Jr., the last surviving member of his family, was shot and killed in Tempe by the fugitive Ed Tewksbury, the last of his clan. Tewksbury was tried and convicted, but due to a legal technicality, his case was dismissed in 1895. Tewksbury died of natural causes in 1904 as the sole survivor of The Pleasant Valley War.
During it all, as a bit of a side note, Pleasant Valley in 1890 was renamed Young after the area's first postmaster, Olla Beth Young, perhaps trying to shed its unpleasant reputation.
We'll take wildlife over chaos and prefer the serenity of modern-day Young.
Contact “Only in Arizona” columnist Mark Nothaft at marknothaft.onlyinaz@gmail.com. Send him the weird and fun facts and places found #OnlyInArizona.
READ MORE:
Arizona's deadliest Old West shootout
Arizona's last train robbery took place on Southern Pacific line
How Arizona's version of the Hatfields and McCoys ended in Tempe
Here's why John Wayne loved Arizona and adopted it as his own
Join the Conversation
To find out more about Facebook commenting please read the Conversation Guidelines and FAQs