WATCH: Andrew Neil’s RUTHLESS question to Labour MP leaves him STRUGGLING for words

BBC presenter Andrew Neil’s brutal question to Shadow Transport Secretary Andy MacDonald about countries without free movement in the single market left him floundering.

The BBC host asked if the Remainer could give an example of a country that is a member of the single market but doesn’t have free movement. 

The Labour MP said: “Well people have got, Norway have got their own arrangement...“

Mr Neil quickly cut in saying: “They have free movement.” 

Mr McDonald continued: “Sweden have their own arrangements...“

Brexit news BBC UK EU Andrew Neil Brexit dealBBC

Brexit news: Andrew Neil’s brutal question left the Labour MP bumbling

The BBC host interrupted, saying: “They have free movement.”

Mr McDonald said: “We have got to find, we are a different economy, we’re infinitely bigger than those—“

Interceding again, Mr Neil said: “But there is no example, the price of membership is free movement isn’t it?

The Labour MP said: “Freedom of movement when we leave the European Union goes, it’s then for us to write our immigration policy as we see fits our economy rather than just simply pulling up the draw bridge and damning the economy as people seem to do.”

Britain has been aiming to break the deadlock by making progress on the ’s key Brexit issues – including the Irish border, the financial settlement and citizens’ rights.

They were hoping to make “significant progress” on the three key issues this month so the UK and EU will be able to move to the second stage of Brexit negotiations for the EU summit next week. 

However, had to break off Brexit negotiations with Jean-Claude Juncker on Monday after details of a proposed Irish border deal emerged in the press, prompting the Prime Minister to leave talks to contact DUP leader Arlene Foster.

The leaked deal suggested Northern Ireland would be offered a separate Brexit deal in order to avoid the implementation of the hard border – keeping the country in the EU’s customs union and single market in all but name.

WATCH: Andrew Neil’s RUTHLESS question to Labour MP leaves him STRUGGLING for words

BBC presenter Andrew Neil’s brutal question to Shadow Transport Secretary Andy MacDonald about countries without free movement in the single market left him floundering.

The BBC host asked if the Remainer could give an example of a country that is a member of the single market but doesn’t have free movement. 

The Labour MP said: “Well people have got, Norway have got their own arrangement...“

Mr Neil quickly cut in saying: “They have free movement.” 

Mr McDonald continued: “Sweden have their own arrangements...“

Brexit news BBC UK EU Andrew Neil Brexit dealBBC

Brexit news: Andrew Neil’s brutal question left the Labour MP bumbling

The BBC host interrupted, saying: “They have free movement.”

Mr McDonald said: “We have got to find, we are a different economy, we’re infinitely bigger than those—“

Interceding again, Mr Neil said: “But there is no example, the price of membership is free movement isn’t it?

The Labour MP said: “Freedom of movement when we leave the European Union goes, it’s then for us to write our immigration policy as we see fits our economy rather than just simply pulling up the draw bridge and damning the economy as people seem to do.”

Britain has been aiming to break the deadlock by making progress on the ’s key Brexit issues – including the Irish border, the financial settlement and citizens’ rights.

They were hoping to make “significant progress” on the three key issues this month so the UK and EU will be able to move to the second stage of Brexit negotiations for the EU summit next week. 

However, had to break off Brexit negotiations with Jean-Claude Juncker on Monday after details of a proposed Irish border deal emerged in the press, prompting the Prime Minister to leave talks to contact DUP leader Arlene Foster.

The leaked deal suggested Northern Ireland would be offered a separate Brexit deal in order to avoid the implementation of the hard border – keeping the country in the EU’s customs union and single market in all but name.

WATCH: Andrew Neil’s RUTHLESS question to Labour MP leaves him STRUGGLING for words

BBC presenter Andrew Neil’s brutal question to Shadow Transport Secretary Andy MacDonald about countries without free movement in the single market left him floundering.

The BBC host asked if the Remainer could give an example of a country that is a member of the single market but doesn’t have free movement. 

The Labour MP said: “Well people have got, Norway have got their own arrangement...“

Mr Neil quickly cut in saying: “They have free movement.” 

Mr McDonald continued: “Sweden have their own arrangements...“

Brexit news BBC UK EU Andrew Neil Brexit dealBBC

Brexit news: Andrew Neil’s brutal question left the Labour MP bumbling

The BBC host interrupted, saying: “They have free movement.”

Mr McDonald said: “We have got to find, we are a different economy, we’re infinitely bigger than those—“

Interceding again, Mr Neil said: “But there is no example, the price of membership is free movement isn’t it?

The Labour MP said: “Freedom of movement when we leave the European Union goes, it’s then for us to write our immigration policy as we see fits our economy rather than just simply pulling up the draw bridge and damning the economy as people seem to do.”

Britain has been aiming to break the deadlock by making progress on the ’s key Brexit issues – including the Irish border, the financial settlement and citizens’ rights.

They were hoping to make “significant progress” on the three key issues this month so the UK and EU will be able to move to the second stage of Brexit negotiations for the EU summit next week. 

However, had to break off Brexit negotiations with Jean-Claude Juncker on Monday after details of a proposed Irish border deal emerged in the press, prompting the Prime Minister to leave talks to contact DUP leader Arlene Foster.

The leaked deal suggested Northern Ireland would be offered a separate Brexit deal in order to avoid the implementation of the hard border – keeping the country in the EU’s customs union and single market in all but name.

Brexit News
Brexit news Jacob Rees Mogg European Union Ireland Irish border DUP PMQs Theresa May

Jacob Rees-Mogg's BRILLIANT question to May - 'your Brexit red lines have turned PINK!'

brexit deal live talks theresa may eu uk talks arlene foster dup ireland irish border

Brexit deal LIVE: Ireland are playing 'dangerous' game blasts DUP as May phones Varadkar

Ray Dolby Cambridge University £85m donation revamp lab

Wired for sound: Cambridge University revamps lab following £85m gift from Ray Dolby

victoria cross worth sir harry tombs medal auction siege of delhi lord ashcroft

Victoria Cross won by officer who killed enemy soldiers to save comrade fetches £288,000

Brexit news BBC news Labour Ben Bradshaw Patrick OFlynn Single Market Customs Union pmqs

'Biggest LIARS in political history' British MEP in stunning attack on Labour over Brexit

Animal therapy care home residents overjoyed surprise penguin visit

'Not everyday you get a penguin cuddle!' Care home residents overjoyed by surprise visit

Salford bomb scare Manchester Tallyman Way Pendleton

Bomb ALERT in Manchester - workers ordered to move from windows as police swoop in

Hull recycling bins Leanne Whitaker Hull City Council

Mum caught in bin war after workers 'REFUSE to take recycling with plastic bin liner'

Manchester bombing victim Olivia Campbell-Hardy unanswered questions Terror attack

Manchester bombing: Father of victim says report 'raises more questions than answers'

Prince George ISIS terror plot school Husnain Rashid court latest news

Islamic terror plot to attack little Prince George at his school - foiled

Area 51 aliens UFO double sonic boom

What are they hiding? Double sonic boom heard over 'alien UFO base' Area 51

Star Wars 8 Rey Luke Last Jedi opening scene plot spoilers theories

Star Wars 8 NEW trailer: Rey and Luke FULL DIALOGUE revealed

F1 News Robert Kubica Nico Rosberg Williams Formula 1 Formula One Renault

F1 news: Robert Kubica discusses Nico Rosberg helping him to secure Williams return

I’m A Celebrity 2017 Kiosk Keith real name pay pack Raymond Ant Dec ITV

I’m A Celebrity 2017: Kiosk Keith’s real name REVEALED - you won’t believe his pay packet

Im A Celebrity 2017 Ant and Dec BIZARRE swipe Jamie Lomas trial Dennis Wise ITV

I'm A Celebrity 2017: Ant and Dec make BIZARRE swipe at Jamie Lomas during trial

Brexit news Brexit bill UK EU Stephen Barclay cross-border derivatives

This financial product worth TRILLIONS could be at RISK if Brexit talks go pear-shaped

Theresa May PMQs Jeremy Corbyn Labour tuition fees

PMQs: May shames Corbyn with leaflet with Labour's FALSE pledge to WRITE OFF student debt

Brexit Alastair Campbell Tony Blair remain EU referendum BBC

‘F**k BREXIT’ Blair spin doctor Alastair Campbell poses in profane hoody for BBC interview

UK christmas spending british families presents food drink holiday abroad

British families plan to OVERSPEND this December splashing THIS shock amount on Christmas

PMQs Brexit news Theresa May Peter Bone UK EU Brussels Brexit deal

PMQs: Brexiteer Peter Bone offers to PERSONALLY go to Brussels to sort out a Brexit deal

Brexit news Brexit deal soft Brexit hard Brexit transitioon deal Christophe Donay UK EU

‘It’s a HARD Brexit or NOTHING!’ Investor warns a soft-Brexit would take a DECADE

Theresa May assassination man accused kill Prime Minister plot Westminster Downing Street

Theresa May assassination: Man in court accused of plot to kill PM

John Constable Sothebys London missing painting auction

Missing painting 'worth up to £1.5 MILLION' found hanging under the stairs

Brexit news Northern Ireland Irish border DUP UK European Union

'Bound to lead to trouble!' DUP would NEVER accept Irish border plan - expert's WARNING

Brexit Nicky Morgan Iain Duncan Smith Twitter European Union

Nicky Morgan LOSES it with Iain Duncan Smith over 'screw EU' comments

Black cabs electric cars Wifi USB London Taxi Company

Black cabs go electric with Wi-Fi, USB and new sunroofs

Sir Winston Churchill reading glasses fetch thousands auction Surrey

Winston Churchill's reading glasses fetches THIS much at auction

Ian Brady death taxpayers costs Myra Hindley Moors Murderers Royal Liverpool Hospital

Ian Brady ‘cost taxpayers £19,000' after death: His ashes thrown into sea in rock salt urn

Brexit news Irish border Ireland European Union EU UK Labour Kate Hoey

Brexiteer says Irish border backtrack will turn into ANOTHER weapon for EU to use in talks

Brexit news Nigel Farage Arlene Foster Brexit deal Northern Ireland DUP UK EU

Nigel Farage praises 'TERRIFIC’ Arlene Foster for playing a ‘HEROIC ROLE’ in Brexit

winter solstice when is shortest day 2017 

When is the Winter Solstice 2017? When is the shortest day of the year?

Brexit news Donald Trump US embassy London Woody Johnson UK EU trade

We're PREPARED! US Ambassador to UK reveals determination to make Brexit successful

Brexit news deal talks latest European Union EU Labour Party UK Keir Starmer

Starmer claims Labour are open-minded on soft-Brexit and faces BRUTAL grilling by BBC host

Stacey Flounders Adam Johnson car accident HMP Moorland South Yorkshire Hartlepool

Adam Johnson's ex hurt in car crash on her way to visit paedophile football star in jail

Santa Clause Colin Letchford cancels christmas yob abuse Canvey Island Essex

Yob-hit Santa Claus axes Christmas event at Essex resort

Brexit not going to happen Dutch MEP BBC Newsnight Ireland border David Davis Theresa May

‘Fantastic!’ Dutch MEP claims Irish border plans 'means Brexit is NOT going to happen'

Brexit Theresa May European Union UK Boris Johnson Michael Gove David Davis DUP

Brexit ‘pessimism is more WIDESPREAD’ as over half the UK blames EU for lack of progress

terror plot Theresa May Number 10 Downing Street ISIS attack London Westminster PM

Plot to kill Theresa May: Two men charged as police 'foil plot to blow up Number 10'

german commentator brands brexit political nonsense peter kapern deutschlandfunk

'Political nonsense' German's fury over Brexit amid claims Britain will leave world stage

Rape attack Romanian brothers raped woman UK months after leaving French jail

Romanian brothers with convictions for rape walk into Britain and rape again

bbc 22 million pound audiences team at risk not providing value for money watchdog warns

BBC team costing £22.4 MILLION ‘at risk of not providing value for money’, watchdog warns

brexit news labour single market membership jeremy corbyn keir starmer

Now Keir Starmer wants access to single market - a policy Corbyn SACKED 3 MPs for in June

Brexit news Brexit update Jeremy Corbyn Labour Party UK European Union business tax video

Corbyn government is a 'BIGGER RISK' to UK than Brexit uncertainty, investor claims

Brexit news Keir Starmer Labour party DUP Theresa May UK EU European Union video

'You're NOT helping!' Kay Burley SLAMS Keir Starmer for 'unhelpful' Labour Brexit strategy

brexit latest news iain duncan smith tells eu back off warns theresa may prepare no deal

Duncan Smith: EU need to 'BACK OFF' or UK will exit with NO DEAL and Brussels will suffer

teenage girl sexual harassment online revenge porn unwanted advances

REVEALED: One in THREE teen girls have been sexually harassed online by kids their own age

Brexit news latest BBC host Labour Party UK European Union

'You're not sure?' Shadow Brexit Minister gets a GRILLING over Labour Brexit policy

Brexit news latest Theresa May divorce bill UK EU Northern Ireland European Union video

Scottish Brexiteer EXPLODES over 'unreasonable' EU demands for Brexit divorce bill

Brexit news Brexit update European Union EU news David Jones Mike Russell

'You're the biggest IMPEDIMENT' Ex-Brexit minister & SNP MSP get VERY personal in TV clash

Brexit news EU Jacob Rees Mogg Ireland Irish border European Union

Jacob Rees-Mogg brilliantly shames Davis: UK should be THANKING the DUP for SAVING Brexit

brexit talks theresa may eu ireland dup irish border trade

Brexit deal LIVE: May STILL not spoken to DUP - Foster blames IRELAND for Brexit mess

State pension military wives 16,000 could lose out £500m

16,000 military wives could be losing out on £500m of state pension, warns Sir Steve Webb

train tickets rail fare rises cruel joke

Train tickets: New rail fare rises branded 'A CRUEL JOKE'

Terrorism Tadesse Kersmo Greenwich University lecturer months terrorist training camp

University lecturer spent months at terrorist training camp in Eritrea

Brexit news protest Brexiteers Carlton Jumeirah hotel Knightsbridge

‘We’re the guard dogs’ Brexiteers demand Theresa May respects 'will of the people'

Brexit news Nigel Farage Arlene Foster Theresa May Brexit update UK EU European Union

'Bring it on!' Farage calls on May to END talks for 'IMPOSSIBLE' Brexit deal with EU

  • Find us on Facebook
  • Follow us on Twitter
  • Check us on Google+
  • Subscribe to our rss feed