Bullet train project an exercise in vanity, won't benefit anyone: Manmohan

Said, 'Gujarati entrepreneurs know very well that if a deal is too good to be true, it probably is not'

Press Trust of India  |  Ahmedabad 

Manmohan Singh
Manmohan Singh

Former prime minister on Tuesday criticised the Centre's project, dubbing it an "exercise in vanity", and said the government's "priorities are misplaced" as it should have focused on the existing passenger rail network.

Addressing an event of the business community in poll-bound Gujarat, the leader claimed the project will not benefit either 65 million people of the state or the nation, adding "Gujarati entrepreneurs know very well that if a deal is too good to be true, it probably is not".


Prime Minister Modi and his Japanese counterpart had in September laid the foundation stone for India's first high speed rail project between and

ALSO READ: Fast bullet train, slow car

The joint venture between Indian and Japan's Shinkansen Technology is expected to be completed by 2022.

India's first will connect Ahmedabad, the largest city in Gujarat, to Mumbai, cutting travel time from seven hours to less than three.

Modi had said that Japan gave a loan of Rs 88,000 crore at 0.1 per cent interest for the project.

"The project, launched with much fanfare, is sadly an exercise in vanity and will not benefit either 65 million Gujaratis or the nation," Singh said here.

"Rs 88,000 crore through a soft loan may seem like easy money, but it still needs to be repaid to the Japanese," he said.

The should have rather focused on the existing passenger rail network, the veteran said.

ALSO READ: Beyond bullet train: Will India gift Japan's Abe the diamond of his dream?

"The project requires the creation of a parallel infrastructure while our existing passenger rail network is languishing and needs a dire infusion of funds to improve both safety and speed," he said.

"The past year has seen the highest number of deaths due to derailments in more than a decade, but the government's priority is misplaced," Singh said.

He wondered if the prime minister considered the alternative of introducing high-speed rail across India by upgrading the existing broad gauge infrastructure.

Singh said the UPA had in 2005 signed a deal with the Japanese for a dedicated freight corridor.

"(The dedicated freight corridor) project will create a multiplier effect on the economy, with upgradation of transportation technology, increase in productivity and reduction in unit transportation cost," he said.

First Published: Tue, November 07 2017. 17:14 IST