GST disputes to be less, but complicated, says L&S law firm

Press Trust of India  |  New Delhi 

The number of legal disputes is expected to be less under the new regime than the earlier excise set-up, but would be more complicated -- mostly on goods classification, said a legal expert on indirect taxes.

The has rolled out the new indirect regime -- the Goods and Services (GST) -- from July 1.


"Early disputes are going to be related to procedures. The next round of disputes will be classification and I think that's going to be there for a long time," said L Badri Narayanan, partner, Lakshmikumaran and Sridharan, the country's leading firm dealing in indirect taxes.

He said GST, which is being "branded" as an accounting job, will require a lot of legal brains once the issues relating to classification of goods start coming to the fore.

"We do not have enough lawyers looking at because it has been branded as if it is an accounting job rather than a legal job," said Narayanan.

Classification of goods is a key element, which is set to decide incidence of There are four slabs for both goods and services -- 5 per cent, 12 per cent, 18 per cent and 28 per cent.

"I think primary role is that of a lawyer to help the industry understand what is and how it should be implemented," the expert said.

He further said that today accounting firms are saying they would help industry to comply with "But according to me, it is a very small piece of GST," Narayanan said, adding that there are larger aspects that have a more significant bearing compared to an accounting aspect.

He felt that disputes would start surfacing in the next few months.

"But I do see the aspect of litigation in to be significantly lesser compared to the excise regime. But its going to be more complicated than what we had in excise," Narayanan added.

Pointing to the fact that has not been implemented smoothly everywhere, he said a number of notifications just before the date of implementation attest to this and the experts are still trying to understand their implications.

"Good thing is that the is responsive in terms of giving you time and trying to clarify, bringing out some form of advisories. They are also listening to trade. They are happy to revise their stand based on what the trade is saying," Narayanan said.

(This story has not been edited by Business Standard staff and is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)

First Published: Mon, September 11 2017. 18:48 IST