Jio led to fall in profitability of incumbent telcos: Eco Survey

The share of the telecom sector in the non-performing assets has now increased

Kiran Rathee  |  New Delhi 

Reliance Jio, Jio

The entry of Reliance on September 5 last year has forced incumbent firms to cut voice and data and the stiff competition, price war and reduced revenue has trapped into a highly leveraged sector, part two of the Economic Survey for 2016-17 said.

The survey also said it's worrying that the share of the sector in non-performing assets (NPAs) has now increased.

"Though the total of sector in public sector banks has fallen to Rs 2,335 crore in 2016-17 from Rs 3,456 crore in 2015-16, the share of of infrastructure sector increased to 8.7 per cent in 2016-17 from 5 per cent in 2015-16," the survey said.

The survey said the industry also faces the issue of higher spectrum charges.

The adjusted gross revenue of the top three companies in India Bharti Airtel, and Cellular decreased by 7.98 per cent, 5.14 per cent and 4.91 per cent respectively during Q3 of 2016-17 as compared to its previous quarter.

With the introduction Reliance Jio, the competition extended from cheaper to cheaper data. Reliance recorded the highest net addition of 56.2 million subscribers which is much higher than the others service providers like with 11.7 million and Bharti with 5.9 million subscribers during Q3 of 2016-17.

The survey said the telecommunications sector has experienced its own version of the "renewables shock" in the form of a new entrant that has dramatically reduced prices for, and increased access to, data, thereby benefitting-at least in the short run-consumers.

But like with the renewables shock, the near term implications for the viability of incumbents are serious: their profitability has come down dramatically. After launching of services by the new entrant in September 2016, the average revenue per user (ARPU) for the industry on aggregate has come down by 22 per cent vis-?-vis the long term (December 2009-June 2016) ARPU, and by about 32 per cent since September 2016.

For this reason, Credit Suisse estimates that the share of debt owed by companies with an interest coverage (IC) of less than 1 has more than doubled since late 2016, climbing above 55 per cent, with an associated vulnerable debt of Rs 1.5 lakh crore.

"In the telecommunications case, not only is the banking system exposed but so too is the government to whom the companies owe a variety of fees and taxes," the survey said.

As per the survey, the mobile industry in India, currently contributes 6.5 per cent ($140 billion) to country's GDP, and employing over four million people (direct and indirect).