New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Friday upheld death sentences against four men who fatally gangraped a woman on board a bus in 2012, a crime that sparked widespread protests and drew international attention to violence against women.
Applause broke out in court among relatives of the victim—whose identity is protected by law—as judges explained the crime met the “rarest of the rare” standard required to justify capital punishment in India.
“It’s a barbaric crime and it has shaken the society’s conscience,” Justice R. Banumathi said, as a three-judge Supreme Court panel threw out an appeal on behalf of the defendants.
The five men and a juvenile lured the 23-year-old trainee physiotherapist and her male friend on to a bus in New Delhi on 16 December 2012, before repeatedly raping the woman and beating both with a metal bar and dumping them on a road.
The woman died of internal injuries nearly two weeks later in a Singapore hospital.
“I am very satisfied. Today I am happy,” the victim’s mother said outside the courthouse.
Her father said: “It’s not just a victory for my family, it’s a victory for each and every woman in our country.”
Four of the attackers were sentenced to death 2013 while the fifth hanged himself in prison during the original seven-month trial. That verdict was upheld by the Delhi high court in 2014.
The four—gym instructor Vinay Sharma, bus cleaner Akshay Kumar Thakur, fruit-seller Pawan Gupta and unemployed Mukesh Singh—then appealed to the Supreme Court. The defendants were not in court on Friday.
Review petition
The Supreme Court has bowed to public pressure in confirming the death sentences awarded to the convicts of the Delhi gangrape case, their counsel was quoted as saying by Press Trust of India.
A petition seeking review of the judgement would be filed, as the top court has succumbed to public pressure and the demonstrations which were carried out in protest against the incident, said advocate A.P. Singh, who was the defence counsel for Akshay Thakur and Vinay Sharma—two of the four convicts.
Advocate M.L. Sharma also said a review petition would be filed as he claimed that one of his clients, Mukesh Singh, was implicated in the case.
Moments after the judgement was pronounced, A.P. Singh said he was waiting for the copy of the judgement and would decide future course of action after going through it, but a review petition would surely be filed. “Terrorists are getting relief from the judiciary. But we have full faith in the Supreme Court. All the four hail from poor background, and I hope they will get justice. We will file the review petition after reading the judgement,” the counsel said.
‘Rape epidemic’
The crime sparked large-scale protests and led thousands of women across India to break their silence over sexual violence that often goes unreported.
It also shone a spotlight on what women’s groups call a rape epidemic in the country. In 2015, police registered more than 34,000 rape complaints and 84,000 women filed sexual harassment cases, according to the National Crime Records Bureau.
Authorities have stiffened penalties against sex crimes, introduced fast-track trials in rape cases and made stalking a crime.
A.P. Singh, a lawyer representing three of the condemned men, said justice had not been done. He vowed to file a review petition to the chief justice of the Supreme Court.
The last recourse of the convicts, all of whom are now in their twenties, would be to seek clemency from President Pranab Mukherjee.
The sixth defendant, a minor accused of pulling out part of the woman’s intestines with his own hand, was sent to a reform home for three years and has since been released.
Capital controversy
Despite the toughening of the laws, debate continues over whether they serve as a sufficient deterrent.
On average, 50 crimes against women are registered every day by police in Delhi, including at least four cases of rape, according to a senior official in the federal home ministry.
Opponents of capital punishment argue that public and media pressure swayed the judges in the Delhi gang rape case to impose the death penalty, adding to the hundreds of already waiting on death row in India.
“There are many cases of rape and murder where death sentences were not ordered. It can’t be subjective,” said Seema Misra, a lawyer who has worked extensively on cases involving women.
More than 400 people are known to have been sentenced to death in India, according to a tally by Amnesty International, with 136 being condemned in 2016.
The last rapist to be executed in India was Dhananjoy Chatterjee, on 14 December 2004. He was hanged at Alipore Central Jail in West Bengal, on his 42nd birthday, for raping and murdering a teenage girl. Reuters